- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses a new viewpoint to understand the role of video generation in action prediction. Based on this, it develops a framework called privileged foresight distillation (PFD) that trains an adapter to predict the residuals between the student and future-conditioned teacher to improve the precision of action prediction.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a new viewpoint to understand the role of video generation in action prediction.
-
The PFD surpasses Fast-WAM and other methods on benchmarks
Critical weaknesses
-
The evidence in Appendix B that the cosine similarity is negative does not support the paper's central "foresight correction" interpretation.
-
There is an inconsistency in the reported RoboTwin score improvements. Table 2 reports Fast-WAM = 91.88 / 91.78 / 91.83 for Clean / Randomized / Average, whereas PFD reports 94.23 / 93.59 / 93.91. These numbers correspond to improvements of approximately +2.35, +1.81, and +2.08 percentage points. However, Section 4.2 states that the improvements are +1.23, +0.91, and +1.07, respectively.
Questions for authors
1.How do you explain the negative cosine similarity between residuals and the ground-truth correction direction, which does not support the central interpretation of the paper?
2.Can the authors explain the RoboTwin numerical inconsistency?