- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces IECLA, a method that aims to evoke a target emotion while preserving the content and the structure of the original image. IECLA separates source-emotion attribution from target-aware editing. At first, they extract the source emotion of the image for image-level supervision. Then, their Context-Conditioned Object Contribution Learning, built on the SigLIP2 vision backbone, integrates region-conditioned visual features, the inferred source emotion, and geometric metadata to recover the signed contribution target. Finally, the target-aware agent combines the signed regional evidence and the target emotion to edit the image. They used six editing backbones combined with their method. They claim structural and emotion expression improvements.
Critical strengths
Well-written, well-motivated, and sufficient novelty regarding the architecture.
The proposed method improves emotion and structural preservation in several metrics.
Extensive ablations makes the method's contribution easy to understand.
Sufficient comparisons with six backbones.
Qualitative as well as quantitative results.
The isolation of the contribution of each term of the total loss is essential for understanding the impact of each term.
Nice tables and visualizations make the results interpretable.
Critical weaknesses
Lack of a metric measuring the realism of the edited image.
Some images contain artifacts like fires in some places.
No clear bounds between changing the emotion of the image and changing central image characteristics. For example, objects have entirely changed for example from bat to lollipop. Colors have been changed significantly as well.
A metric that measures the realism of the image would be necessary.
Insufficient justification about the coefficients of the loss function. An ablation of different coefficients is missing.
Questions for authors
Where is the bound between changing significantly the image's colors or objects and altering the emotion of the image?
Could the authors provide realism metrics like MUSIQ or CLIPIQA, or compute distribution realism via FID / KID?
How sensitive is the loss to the coefficients of each term. Why do the authors gave these weights for each term Could they provide an ablation of different loss factors?