acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Let the Mind Conceive, Let the Hand Achieve: Following Multimodal Instructions for Long-Horizon Robotic Manipulation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Following a complete robot instruction requires maintaining task continuity and preserving the connection between intent and physical referents as the scene changes. These challenges are coupled: executing the correct sequence is insufficient if actions target the wrong entities, and grounding the correct entities is insufficient if operations are repeated or omitted. We introduce Orchestra, an agent harness that separates task-level interpretation and execution management from local action generation. Given a complete multimodal instruction, Orchestra constructs structured subtasks and maintains a shared context aligning the active goal, spatial grounding, observation history, and task progress. A spatially and temporally grounded action policy and an independent progress evaluator use aligned context to generate actions and guide subtask transitions. We also introduce RMBench-Compose to evaluate longer compositions of skills learned from atomic instructions and short trajectories. Orchestra achieves mean success across nine RMBench tasks, exceeding Mem-0 by percentage points. On RMBench-Compose, it achieves an Average Success Length of subtasks, times that of HarnessVLA. Across four real-world tasks, it improves mean Average Success Length by over its base-policy variant. These results support shared-context coordination as an effective approach to sustaining grounded instruction following over long horizons.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Long-Horizon Robotic Manipulation, Agent Harness, Multimodal Instruction Following, Spatial Grounding, Memory-Augmented Robotic Control, Compositional Task Execution

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_t5L3OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

Orchestra integrates instruction decomposition, grounding, visual history, and learned subtask transitions around an adapted pi_0.5 policy. Its contribution is primarily this particular integration, the policy adaptations, and RMBench-Compose for evaluating longer compositions after atomic-skill training.

Critical strengths
  • Strong empirical results:
    • Orchestra achieves 68.22% RMBench success (vs. Mem-0's 42%)
    • Orchestra achieves 7.35 Average Success Length (ASL) on RMBench-Compose (vs. HarnessVLA's 2.986).
    • Real-world mean ASL improves from 2.20 to 2.75 over Orchestra with the base policy.
  • Implementation and evaluation contributions:
    • The policy combines spatial prompts with temporal visual fusion without increasing the language model's visual-token count.
    • Component ablations are useful and learned transitions match oracle transitions in aggregate ASL.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Distinct contribution over existing hierarchies

The integration and empirical results are promising, but the broad agent loop alone does not establish novelty.

  1. Some comparisons do not isolate the coordination benefit
  • Removing orchestration tests the value of hierarchy, rather than superiority over an existing hierarchy.
  • Orchestra with the base policy achieves 2.884 ASL versus HarnessVLA's 2.986; the full system's 7.350 also includes policy adaptations.
Questions for authors
  • How many attempts were excluded for each configuration, and were interruptions external or policy-induced?
  • Does the improvement persist when policy-related interruptions count as failures?
  • What distinguishes Orchestra's progress evaluator and coordination mechanism from existing work, and what evidence shows the benefit of those differences?
Reviewer_rFLSOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents Orchestra, an agent harness for long-horizon robotic manipulation that coordinates task decomposition, spatial grounding, visual memory, action generation, and subtask progress estimation through a shared execution context. The framework integrates vision-based grounding modules, a spatiotemporally conditioned policy adapted from π0.5, and a learned progress evaluator to manage transitions between subtasks.

The paper evaluates Orchestra on existing robotic manipulation benchmarks, the proposed RMBench-Compose benchmark, and real-world robotic tasks. The results demonstrate improved long-horizon execution performance, including a mean ASL of 7.350 on RMBench-Compose and a 25% improvement in mean ASL in real-world experiments compared with Orchestra using the base π0.5 policy.

Critical strengths

A key strength of this paper is its system-level evaluation. The authors conduct experiments across existing benchmarks, compositional manipulation tasks, and real-world robotic settings, and report consistent improvements over selected baselines in several evaluations. These results provide meaningful empirical evidence that the integrated system can improve long-horizon robotic manipulation, even though the specific contribution of the proposed shared execution context remains insufficiently isolated.

Critical weaknesses

My main concerns are limited methodological novelty and insufficient experimental validation of the central architectural claim. Most individual components rely on established ideas, including hierarchical task decomposition, explicit spatial grounding, temporal visual context, and progress estimation. The main distinguishing contribution appears to be their coordination through a shared execution context. However, the paper does not sufficiently establish how this architecture differs from existing modular or hierarchical robotic systems or what unique benefits it provides.

The ablations show that task orchestration, visual memory, and spatial grounding contribute to performance, but do not isolate the benefits of the shared execution context relative to alternative coordination mechanisms using the same components. Similarly, the memory and grounding ablations establish the usefulness of these components without demonstrating the specific advantages of the proposed temporal encoding or grounding design. The comparison with a simulator-provided completion indicator also does not sufficiently characterize the learned evaluator's completion-detection accuracy or robustness.

Questions for authors

1. Clarification - Architectural novelty.

Could the authors clarify what capabilities or performance benefits are specifically enabled by the shared execution context beyond those provided by the individual components? In particular, have the authors compared Orchestra with an alternative coordination architecture that uses the same components and action policy under comparable computational budgets? Such a comparison would help isolate the contribution of the proposed architecture.

2. Additional evidence request - Contribution of the learned progress evaluator.

The learned progress evaluator achieves a mean ASL of 7.350, close to the 7.374 obtained with the simulator-provided completion indicator. While this suggests similar aggregate rollout performance, it does not establish equivalent completion-detection accuracy or robustness. Could the authors provide transition-level metrics, such as premature and delayed transition rates, and clarify the evaluator's advantages over existing termination classifiers?

Reviewer_fTasOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper at hand introduces Orchestra, an agent harness for long-horizon robotic manipulation. The paper first motivates the need to preserve task order, grounding, and progress across changing scenes. It then decomposes complete multimodal instructions into ordered subtasks and maintains a shared context for an adapted π0.5 policy and a separate progress evaluator. Next, it introduces RMBench-Compose, where policies trained on atomic demonstrations execute sequences of 6 to 18 subtasks. Finally, experiments on RMBench, RMBench-Compose, and four real-world tasks show improved sustained execution, although performance remains task-dependent.

Critical strengths
  • RMBench-Compose evaluates an important gap between isolated manipulation skill and sustained instruction following. Its atomic-training and composed-evaluation design shows that strong atomic success does not guarantee correct execution across ordered state changes.

    • line 374: I liked that the authors explicitly distinguish isolated competence from sustained execution because this prevents Atomic Success Rate from being overinterpreted.
  • The component ablations and physical-robot experiments provide useful evidence for the complete system. Removing orchestration or visual memory substantially lowers Average Success Length, while the failure analysis identifies action execution as the main remaining limitation.

    • line 457: I liked that the authors avoid claiming equivalent completion detection from similar rollout performance because the reported metric cannot establish that conclusion.
Critical weaknesses
  • The main comparison does not isolate the harness from the improved action policy. Complete Orchestra reaches 7.35 Average Success Length, but Orchestra with the base π0.5 policy reaches 2.88, slightly below HarnessVLA at 2.99. The results therefore support the complete bundle more clearly than the claimed orchestration contribution.

    • line 369: This result makes the 2.46-times headline improvement difficult to attribute specifically to the agent harness.
    • line 1164: Retraining the no-orchestration policy on long-horizon instructions changes the supervision regime as well as the execution structure.
  • The progress evaluator predicts normalized demonstration time, which is not necessarily equivalent to semantic task completion. The near-oracle Average Success Length does not reveal premature transitions, delayed transitions, or compensating errors. Direct completion-detection measurements are needed to validate this central mechanism.

    • line 958: Nonzero progress at the first frame confirms that the label represents trajectory position rather than partial achievement of the requested goal.
    • line 962: The terminal-bin transition rule needs validation against actual completed states.
Questions for authors
  • Can the authors compare Orchestra and HarnessVLA using the same action policy, training data, grounding, and atomic competence? This would clarify whether the harness itself produces the reported gain.
  • What are the evaluator’s false-advance, missed-completion, and transition-delay rates relative to actual task completion?
  • How are language-only, reference-image, and point or box instructions distributed across the evaluation, and what are their separate results?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.