- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper discuses channel modeling in time-series forecasting. The key claims is that channels are often treated as if they have the same importance in modeling. However, channel dependency changes across future offsets, and an adaptive selection strategy would be beneficial. Authors decompose dependency, controlled utility, and functional reliance, and demonstrate that functional source reliance is dependent on forecaster models.
Critical strengths
The authors investigate spatial/channell dependency modeling, which is a critical topic in time-series forecasting.
The authors provide a comprehensive and thorough literature review from three aspects in time-series forecasting, including forecasting backbones and channel modeling, adaptive cross-channel structure, and feature importance and intervention.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution of is paper is not very clearly introduced. The limitation of existing studies should be more carefully analyzed and justified, with substantial discussion with literature support and quantitive/qualitative analysis.
Experiments results should report in similar protocol (metric system, datasets, statistics). For example, the CI should be reported in the involved tables and figures, not only table 4. The experiment setup should be detailed in the main paper, to make the paper self-contained.
The structure of this paper is not very clear and different from existing papers. Referring to standard structures (possibly using subsections, research questions) could improve the clarity of this paper.
Theoretical justification is not available. While not necessary for application-directed papers, an insightful theoretical analysis could improve the rigor of the statement in the paper and help the authors (readers) to understand the research questions.
The quality of tables and figures should be improved. Some figures and tables would be not very informative but takes large space. For example, figure 2 (a) contains only 4 numbers but takes 10+ lines (left panel). Figure 2 (b) is a table, instead of a figure.
Questions for authors
How does the referred cross-channel dependency relate to cross-time dependency? That is, is there unique challenges for modeling cross-channel dependency, given the rich literature on modeling time dependency (self-attention, mlp, gnn, etc)?