- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PECV-RT proposes a lightweight framework that focuses on three bottlenecks in prior work: suboptimal computation allocation across resolutions, costly global spatial context modeling, and redundant computation across overlapping temporal windows. Resolution-aware computation allocation optimizes the distribution of computation by shifting intensive global context modeling to low resolutions, while making local processing lightweight at high resolutions. Linear spatial attention reduces computational complexity from quadratic to linear in the number of spatial tokens. Cross-frame computation sharing limits repeated feature extraction and reuses temporal-attention keys and values across output frames. Experiments show that PECV-RT achieves state-of-the-art LPIPS performance with negligible PSNR degradation. It is the first method to perform perceptual enhancement of 1080 p compressed video at over 60 FPS on such hardware.
Critical strengths
It is the first method to perform perceptual enhancement of compressed video at real-time speed. A state-of-the-art method of Real-Time Perceptual Compressed Video Enhancement in terms of LPIPS. A good insight for perceptual enhancement of compressed video at real-time speed and practical application.
Critical weaknesses
The paper organization and writing should be improved. Such as the gap of figure and caption is too large. In figure 3, sub-figure (b) cannot found in the paper. The related work section should be out into the second section. The core contributions should be clarified in introduction section. Why author illustrate the figure 1 and figure 2 in the introduction section. The corresponding descriptions of Figure 1(b) and Figure 2 are missing. Some redundancy of motivations and presentations are obvious.
Why only conduct the experiments on QP=37 and 42? For other compressed video quality enhancement methods, 4 QPs or 5 QPs are adopted to verify the effectiveness of enhancement models. Besides, how to obtain the results of other compared methods on HM-16.5andVTM-17.0 conditions? STDR, STCF, TGAF are trained on MFQEV2 dataset and tested on JCT-VC sequences. Are the comparisons fair, given that the models were trained on different datasets? The more detailed settings should be provided and clarified. Could author provide the other perceptual metrices rather than only LPIPS for comprehensive comparisons? Could author the real-world compressed video quality enhancement results of the proposed method and other state-of-the-art methods for verifying the perceptual enhancement performance?
Why the proposed model cannot achieve the best PSNR performance?
Compared SOTA method HFGAT, PECV-RT only has a small perceptual quality gain while has large PSNR degradation. For the visual results in Figure 8, the perceptual quality is hard to distinguished compared other methods, especially compared with TGAF. The more visual results should be provided and compared.
Other complexity results of calss A-E of testing sequences should be provided rather than only have small resolutions.
Moreover, how to evaluate the temporal consistency of enhanced videos, the corresponding results should be provided and discussed. The more comprehensive comparisons and discussion should be provided for further verifying the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Some recent compressed video quality enhancement methods should be discussed and compared, such as: [1] CPGA: Coding priors-guided aggregation network for compressed video quality enhancement. CVPR2024 [2] MDEformer: Mixed difference equation inspired transformer for compressed video quality enhancement. TNNLS2024 [3] Rivuletmlp: An mlp-based architecture for efficient compressed video quality enhancement. CVPR2025 [4] Multi-frame deformable look-up table for compressed video quality enhancement. AAAI2025 [5] Perceptual quality enhancement for compressed video with high-frequency details and high-dimensional features. TIM2025 [6] Blind Quality Enhancement of Compressed Video via Fine-Grained Degradation-Guided Sequential Inference. TCSVT2026
Questions for authors
Please view Critical Weaknesses.