- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes NK-OLMC, a nonlinear kernel method for large-scale multi-view clustering. It uses random Fourier features (RFF) to approximate Gaussian kernels and weighted tensor nuclear norm (WTNN) to capture high-order cross-view correlations, enhancing nonlinear modeling while maintaining linear computational complexity.
Critical strengths
The paper is clearly written and provides extensive experiments. The experiments cover datasets of various scales, include direct comparisons with strong baselines, and provide several auxiliary experiments.
Critical weaknesses
The novelty is insufficient for ICLR. Compared with LMTC, the paper only replaces the linear kernel with a nonlinear kernel and the tensor norm with WTNN. LMTC has already identified and addressed the issue of tensor rotation exploiting sample-order structures. Thus, the paper offers no substantial contributions beyond introducing nonlinear kernels and WTNN.
Questions for authors
-
The novelty is insufficient for ICLR. Compared with LMTC, the paper only replaces the linear kernel with a nonlinear kernel and the tensor norm with WTNN. LMTC has already identified and addressed the issue of tensor rotation exploiting sample-order structures. Thus, the paper offers no substantial contributions beyond introducing nonlinear kernels and WTNN.
-
The authors emphasize the ability to capture complex nonlinear manifold structures, but the experiments mainly report final clustering metrics without controlling the degree of nonlinearity. For example, synthetic multi-view datasets with varying manifold curvature could verify whether the advantages of RFF come from nonlinear modeling rather than additional hyperparameter tuning.
-
Page 6 reports wide search ranges for . A full grid search would require 1,280 runs, which is too expensive for unsupervised clustering and difficult to reproduce.
-
LMTC already shows stable robustness to sample ordering. On some datasets, such as COIL20, the proposed method exhibits slightly greater variation than LMTC.
-
To avoid sample-order dependence, the authors apply FFT along the view dimension. However, this may introduce dependence on view ordering. The authors should clarify this issue.
-
There are apparent numerical inconsistencies in the experimental tables. The ALOI results in Tables 2 and 4 may contain reporting errors. The authors should verify them.
I will consider revising my score based on the authors' responses.