acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Imprint Reader: From Weight-Update Readout to Behavioral Intervention

Abstract

As language models take a growing role in AI development, a natural aspiration is for them to reflect on their own learning process, as humans do, and use that reflection to improve themselves. At the same time, these models have an advantage that human learners lack, since training leaves parameter-level traces that can, in principle, be inspected directly. However, current models cannot decode these traces into an explicit account of what they have learned. To this end, we introduce the Imprint Reader, a model trained with Mount-and-Read Tuning (MaRT) to describe frozen weight updates. MaRT mounts each update onto the Reader and uses an anchor-free meta-query to elicit a natural-language description, while no-change and random-perturbation controls discourage unsupported claims. On held-out updates, the joint Reader reaches judge-based Pass@100 of for knowledge and for behavior. These results demonstrate the feasibility of natural-language readout while pointing to reliability across updates as the next step Beyond free-form generation, the Reader provides a differentiable proxy for the gap between a specified target behavior and a candidate weight update. Its coordinate-aligned gradients support intervention through MetaEdit. At a pruning rate, Reader-guided selection raises measured harmful-prompt refusal from to under a safety-maintenance target. Using behavior descriptions without target-task training data, MetaEdit increases the frequency of backtracking and sub-goal expressions in mathematical reasoning traces and raises BFCL Overall from to .

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Weight Update Interpretation, Parameter-Space Introspection

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_QMPBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

As I understand it, the authors fine-tune Qwen3-14B so that, when a LoRA update that taught it one fact or one response habit is added to its weights, it describes what the update changed. On 100 unseen fact updates and 100 unseen behaviour updates, an LLM judge accepts at least one of 100 sampled descriptions for 2% and 16% of them. They then use the gradient of a desired self-description ("the update made me better at checking intermediate results") to prune or shift a few rows of the original model, and report the refusal rate, GSM8K, MATH-500, and BFCL.

Critical strengths

The question of whether a model can describe a change to its own weights is interesting, and the readout has sensible controls (empty, random, and swapped updates).

Critical weaknesses

I fail to see what either result enables. Fact readout works for 2 of 100 updates with 100 attempts each, and A.6 shows that a wrong update of the same type lowers the target loss by 0.097 nats per token against 0.223 for the right one, so almost half of the signal is not update-specific. The edits give small changes: 94.77 to 95.00 on GSM8K is about three problems, and 82.8 to 83.0 on MATH-500 is one.

Furthermore, the editing baselines do not isolate the Reader. For maths and BFCL, the only comparisons are a system prompt and a vague target of equal norm, which already reaches 43.68 of the 44.60 on BFCL. Missing are the same edit with gradients from the original model (done only for safety, Section 5.1) and a random direction of equal norm on the same rows. To recommend acceptance, I would need these controls and a clearer case for why the readout is useful at its current accuracy.

Questions for authors

What is Pass@100 when the Reader is given an empty update or a mismatched update of the same type?

Reviewer_5MAFOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper trains a Reader model to describe the updates applied to the original model, in natural language. The Reader and the original model are copies of the same model architecture, and the weight update is shown to reader by adding the update to the Reader's own weights pointwise.

The Reader is trained to describe updates from a number of fact and behavior learning tasks, though pass@100 test accuracy for its descriptions remains low.

The authors also use the Reader to update the original model. By taking gradients of a fixed description's negative log-likelihood with respect to the Reader's weights, they seek to find updates to the original model consistent with the description. They then apply the update to the original model and test whether it induces the behavior described. There are some promising results on tool use, though other gains remain modest.

Critical strengths
  • I thought this was a clever and creative idea! For example, the idea of an additive interface to the Reader's own weights is a nice way to avoid an excessively large hypernetwork (though I believe also appeared in DIT). The method for using the Reader to generate updates via is also nice.
  • The presentation is clear and easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
  • The pass@100 reader results (2% and 16%) seem very low.
  • The training/steering results are more promising, but:
    • There seems to be a sign mismatch in safety setting, where where we drop the rows that should make the description more likely, according the reader gradients.
    • Math and BFCL are missing the base-model-gradient baseline that would help establish the causal role of the trained reader.
    • In general, this section would benefit from baselines and controls. For example, do the updates cause regressions in other areas? Does the safety pruning preserve helpfulness, and avoid overrefusal?
    • Across the board, the update performance gains are modest.
Questions for authors

In the safety pruning application, can you clarify the sign conventions? As it stands, it seems as though the removals should make description less likely, rather than more.

Reviewer_PnrqOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a training technique, Mount-and-Read Tuning (MaRT), to enable language models to identify and describe the knowledge or behavioral changes induced by their own weight updates. The setting consists of a pretrained language model with parameters (\theta_0), fine-tuned to acquire a specific piece of knowledge or behavior (k), resulting in parameters (\theta_k = \theta_0 + \Delta\theta_k). MaRT trains a new set of parameters (\theta_R) such that the model with weights (\theta_R + \Delta\theta_k) can identify the acquired knowledge (k) in response to a generic meta-query (m), such as “Summarize the knowledge change you just experienced.” The underlying motivation is that, while the fine-tuned model (\theta_0 + \Delta\theta_k) already possesses the knowledge (k), it is not necessarily able to identify it as the knowledge acquired through fine-tuning. To discourage unsupported claims, MaRT also introduces control updates: a zero update (\Delta\theta_{\mathrm{noop}}=0), associated with no newly acquired knowledge, and random perturbations (\Delta\theta_{\mathrm{rand}}), for which the model is trained to express uncertainty about any potential changes. The Reader parameters (\theta_R) are optimized by minimizing the readout loss −Ek,m[log⁡p(k∣m,θR+Δθk)].-\mathbb{E}_{k,m}\left[\log p(k\mid m,\theta_R+\Delta\theta_k)\right]. The authors further exploit the trained Reader to identify parameter directions associated with a desired behavior (b). Specifically, they compute the gradient of the negative log-likelihood of a self-reported behavioral description, gb=∇θR[−log⁡p(b∣m,θR)].g_b=\nabla_{\theta_R}\left[-\log p(b\mid m,\theta_R)\right]. This gradient is then used in MetaEdit to modify the original model (\theta_0), either by pruning selected parameter rows based on gradient magnitudes and directions or by applying a sparse gradient update (-\alpha g_b). The goal is to induce a desired behavior using only its natural-language description, without requiring task-specific fine-tuning examples at the intervention stage. The authors investigate two applications: (i) increasing or decreasing the refusal rate on harmful prompts through guided pruning, and (ii) vibe alignment, which aims to induce specific reasoning or interaction styles, such as explicitly introducing intermediate steps and verifying results during mathematical reasoning. Experiments are conducted on Qwen3-14B. MaRT achieves rather limited performance in identifying knowledge and behavioral changes from unseen weight updates. Under a Pass@100 evaluation, where 100 responses are generated for each update and the attempt is considered successful if at least one correctly identifies the target, the success rates are only 2% for knowledge and 16% for behavior. MetaEdit produces modest behavioral improvements: at a pruning rate of 0.5%, the harmful-prompt refusal rate increases from 57.9% to 64.1% under the safety-maintenance target, while the refusal-relaxation target decreases it to 55.4%. For reasoning and agentic tasks, the improvements are similarly limited, with mathematical accuracy increasing by approximately 0.2 percentage points on

Critical strengths

The addressed question of language models’ introspection and vibe alignment are interesting ones.

Critical weaknesses

I found that the empirical results are too modest to claim that they support the efficacy of the method. Moreover, the idea of a very similar method (with the same reader objective) has already appeared in arxiv:2510.05092.

Questions for authors

Can the authors explain thoroughly the differences of their method with those existing in the literature (e.g., with arxiv:2510.05092) and compare their performances?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.