acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Program-Centric Memory: A Representation-for-Function Approach to Experience Reuse

Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents can construct memory from past interaction trajectories and reuse it to support future action selection and outcome prediction. However, when these memory functions are carried primarily by language, predictive information may remain implicit, while reusable action patterns require repeated LLM reasoning at runtime. This motivates a memory-form perspective that we call Representation for Function: memory representations should align with the functions they serve at reuse time. By aligning memory form with function, we propose Program-Centric Memory (PCM), which represents explicit probabilistic action-outcome relationships as Predictive Beliefs and reusable action patterns as Executable Programs. PCM achieves consistently strong performance across ALFWorld, WebShop, and TravelPlanner. Controlled experiments further show that, with the underlying information held fixed, using executable rather than textual representations of the same action patterns increases success from 79.9% to 97.8%, while reducing online tokens from 98.4k to 2.5k per task. These results establish memory form as a key dimension of experience reuse.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
agent, memory

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 32%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.50 over 4 reviews, above 68% of the others.
Reviewer_opWFOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Program-Centric Memory, an experience reuse framework for agents based on the representation for function principle. It compiles trajectories into predictive beliefs for estimation and executable programs for control. Experiments across multiple benchmarks show significant performance gains and token reductions.

Critical strengths
  1. Innovative perspective by introducing the representation for function principle, moving beyond traditional language-centric memory.

  2. Harmonious design combining probabilistic beliefs with executable programs to balance accuracy and efficiency.

  3. Strong empirical performance achieving substantial success improvements and massive token reductions across diverse benchmarks.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Heavy reliance on LLM fallback when tasks fall outside program coverage, which may cause performance bottlenecks.

  2. Strong dependence on offline construction and validation, potentially limiting its adaptability in highly dynamic scenarios.

Questions for authors

The authors should clarify the robustness of the program revision mechanism in highly stochastic environments and discuss potential extensions toward online real-time updating.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer opWF (1/3)

Dear Reviewer opWF,

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for recognizing PCM's representation-for-function perspective, its combination of probabilistic beliefs and executable programs, and its strong empirical performance.

We added longitudinal construction data and mechanism clarifications to address your concerns:

  • Reported program and LLM usage across all three benchmarks.
  • Clarified the iterative program update process and reported longitudinal TravelPlanner results and token costs.
  • Explained program acceptance and rollback, and discussed possible enhancements for stochastic and dynamic environments.
  • Outlined a possible online extension with incremental belief updates and background program revision alongside task execution.

Below, we provide detailed responses to each of your questions, with the utmost sincerity, to fully address every concern.


Clarification: PCM’s iterative program update process

Answer:

The original paper did not explain this process clearly enough, which may have caused confusion. We would like to further clarify it here. Although program revision and validation take place offline, each revision is guided by feedback from online execution. PCM iteratively updates its programs to improve task performance. Each iteration consists of four stages:

Program Revision → Program Validation → Program Update → Online Execution.

During Program Revision, the LLM revises the program using trajectories and feedback from previous executions. The revised program then undergoes Program Validation. If it passes validation, Program Update applies the candidate version for the next execution. During Online Execution, the program interacts with the environment, producing new trajectories and feedback. We then determine whether to accept the update based on the overall execution results and whether the intended revision objectives have been achieved. The collected feedback guides subsequent revisions.

We report longitudinal TravelPlanner results from 52 construction iterations, comprising one initial program-generation attempt and 51 revision attempts. Across these iterations, 41 evaluations were completed on the same 45 training queries. The table reports mean success over completed evaluations, together with revision, evaluation, and overall token consumption for each iteration group.

IterationsCompleted EvaluationsMean Success ↑Revision tokensEvaluation tokensOverall tokens
1–1080.00%804,67071,944876,614
11–2077.62%311,34445,578356,922
21–30435.00%594,92237,326632,248
31–401055.11%622,462106,432728,894
41–501091.56%551,304116,389667,693
51–52296.67%86,69123,450110,141
Overall4145.20%2,971,393401,1193,372,512

Although individual revisions do not always improve task success, the evaluated versions show an overall upward trend, supporting continued improvement through execution feedback. We discuss extensions for adaptation to environmental changes, stochastic robustness, and online updating in our responses to W2 & Q1(a) and Q1(b) below. We will include further development results for TravelPlanner, ALFWorld, and WebShop in the revised paper.


W1: "Heavy reliance on LLM fallback when tasks fall outside program coverage, which may cause performance bottlenecks."

Answer:

Thank you for raising this concern. Although uncovered cases require LLM fallback, our results show that PCM achieves higher task success rates with substantially lower online token consumption than the compared baselines, demonstrating overall gains in both task performance and token efficiency.

The table below quantifies program and LLM usage. For TravelPlanner, both components participate in each query; we report their shares of calls.

BenchmarkProgramLLM
ALFWorld (steps)66.21%33.79%
WebShop (steps)66.93%33.07%
TravelPlanner (calls)85.96%14.04%

Furthermore, with beliefs held fixed in Figure 4, the share of program-executed steps increases from 0% to 60.1% over successive iterations. This demonstrates that iterative program revisions expand coverage and reduce reliance on LLM fallback.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer opWF (2/3)

W2 & Q1(a): "Strong dependence on offline construction and validation, potentially limiting its adaptability in highly dynamic scenarios." "The authors should clarify the robustness of the program revision mechanism in highly stochastic environments ..."

Answer:

Thank you for asking about robustness in stochastic and dynamic environments. We would like to clarify PCM’s existing revision mechanism and discuss potential enhancements for these settings.

Robustness of the current mechanism to stochasticity and environmental changes. PCM determines whether to accept a Program Update or roll back to the previous version based on the candidate program’s overall performance on evaluation tasks during Online Execution, together with whether the intended revision objectives have been achieved. A version that previously performed well may be rejected or rolled back based on new evaluation results if its performance deteriorates under changed conditions. These changes are also reflected in execution trajectories and feedback, which guide subsequent revisions. The LLM uses this feedback to modify the program, and the candidate undergoes validation and execution evaluation before another acceptance decision. This cycle allows program revision and version selection to continually incorporate feedback from the current environment.

Enhancements for highly stochastic and dynamic environments. For highly stochastic environments, we could evaluate the current and candidate programs multiple times on the same tasks and compare their average performance, reducing the influence of individual random outcomes on version selection. For highly dynamic environments, we could apply time-decay weights to Online Execution evaluation results, giving recent performance greater influence on version selection. Predictive Beliefs could similarly use an exponential moving average (EMA) to emphasize recent observations, while Executable Programs could use adjustable feedback windows and revision frequencies to respond more promptly to new feedback. Together, these extensions could balance resistance to random fluctuations with responsiveness to environmental changes.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer opWF (3/3)

Q1(b): "... discuss potential extensions toward online real-time updating."

Answer:

Thank you for raising this important question. We agree that real-time memory updating is an important direction for future work. We would like to outline a possible extension with two concurrent processes: task execution and background program updating.

Task execution and feedback collection. At the beginning of each task, the execution process would use the latest accepted program and keep that program version fixed throughout the task. It would continuously collect execution trajectories and feedback. Meanwhile, Predictive Beliefs could be updated incrementally after each interaction by incorporating the observed action–outcome pair into the accumulated statistics and probability estimates. Updated beliefs would become available for subsequent decisions.

Background program updating. A separate process could initiate program revision when sufficient feedback has accumulated, similar execution problems recur, or recent task performance declines. Each revision round would use the current accepted program and a fixed batch of recent feedback to identify revision objectives and generate candidates within a bounded budget. Feedback arriving during that round would continue to accumulate for subsequent revisions. Candidate programs would be developed separately from the program used by ongoing tasks, allowing execution and revision to proceed concurrently.

Candidate evaluation and version switching. Candidates would undergo interface and behavioral tests, followed by task-level comparison with the current version on the same evaluation tasks. Acceptance would depend on overall execution performance and whether the intended revision objectives have been achieved. An accepted version would be made available to subsequently started tasks, while ongoing tasks would continue using their existing version. If a candidate fails validation or does not meet the acceptance criteria, the current version would remain in use.

This design would allow the agent to incorporate new experience through incremental belief updates and background program revision, without requiring task execution to wait for program revision and validation to finish. We would welcome your insights and suggestions on this direction and would be happy to discuss it further.

Thank you again for recognizing the value of our work. Your recognition and thoughtful feedback mean a great deal to us. We hope these clarifications and additional results address your concerns and encourage you to reassess our work. We look forward to your further feedback and would be happy to discuss any remaining questions.

Reviewer_VYyoOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Program-Centric Memory (PCM) represents past agent experience through explicit probabilistic beliefs about action outcomes and executable programs encoding reusable procedures. These components support action selection and execution, with LLM fallback for situations outside program coverage. Experiments on ALFWorld, WebShop, and TravelPlanner report improved performance and reduced online token usage.

Critical strengths

I appreciate the proposal of a useful controlled investigation of memory representation. The experiments go beyond comparing a complete system against memory-free baselines. It examines how different representations of the same underlying experience affect performance, and hence providing evidence relevant to the design of agent memory systems. Moreover, PCM achieves favorable results across three different environments. On ALFWorld, replacing textual procedures with executable ones under quantitative beliefs increases success from 79.9% to 97.8% while reducing online tokens, showcasing potentially meaningful practical value.

Critical weaknesses

(1) The advance over existing procedural-memory approaches is insufficiently established. Voyager already learns and reuses executable skills, while MACLA combines hierarchical procedures with Bayesian reliability estimates and utility-based selection. PCM’s local actio-outcome beliefs and representation study offer distinctions, but the paper does not sufficiently establish what these add beyond existing executable reuse and probabilistic procedure selection. The central result also changes the execution mechanism alongside representation, leaving uncertainty about how much insight extends beyond the expected benefits of executing reusable code.

(2) Memory-construction details and total costs are insufficiently characterized. The paper clearly describes frozen evaluation and task-disjoint construction for ALFWorld, but provides less detail about the construction data and revision process for its TravelPlanner programs. Its efficiency results emphasize online tokens without establishing the total construction and validation cost or the reuse volume needed to amortize it. These omissions limit assessment of reproducibility and practical efficiency.

Questions for authors

(1) What capabilities or empirical findings distinguish PCM from executable-skill approaches such as Voyager and probabilistic procedural-memory approaches such as MACLA?

(2) How was equivalence between textual and executable procedures established? Were textual procedures given access to the same state information and computational tools, and how should the reported gains be attributed between memory representation and the execution mechanism?

(3) For TravelPlanner and WebShop, what data and feedback were used to construct, revise, and validate programs, and how were these separated from evaluation?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer VYyo (1/4)

Dear Reviewer VYyo,

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for recognizing our work as a “useful controlled investigation of memory representation,” with favorable results across three environments and potential practical value.

During the rebuttal period, we added experiments and construction analyses to address your concerns:

  • Added a reconstruction test for information consistency.
  • Added PE-Sim to compare execution modes using the same program.
  • Clarified data separation and reported construction costs and break-even task counts.

Below, we provide detailed responses to each of your questions, with the utmost sincerity, to fully address every concern.


W1 & Q1: "What capabilities or empirical findings distinguish PCM from executable-skill approaches such as Voyager and probabilistic procedural-memory approaches such as MACLA?"

Answer:

Thank you for asking us to clarify PCM’s added value. We agree that it is important to distinguish PCM’s contribution from existing executable skill reuse and probabilistic procedure selection.

Voyager learns and reuses executable skills, while MACLA uses Bayesian estimates of procedure reliability to support utility-based selection. PCM’s distinctive design connects local action–outcome predictions with decision-making inside executable programs. Its Predictive Beliefs estimate observable action–outcome relationships, which programs can query when comparing possible outcomes and choosing actions. This allows reusable control logic to make execution decisions using explicit predictive information.

This design follows the Representation for Function principle: probabilistic beliefs support outcome estimation, while executable programs support control. Our controlled representation study provides empirical evidence for this functional pairing, and the belief-replacement experiment further tests the contribution of predictive beliefs with executable control held fixed. Specifically, we conducted a controlled belief-replacement experiment on ALFWorld, replacing PCM’s Predictive Beliefs with MACLA-style beliefs while keeping the executable programs and all other experimental settings unchanged.

ConfigurationSeen success (140 tasks)Unseen success (134 tasks)Steps/taskOnline tokens/task
PCM + MACLA-style beliefs76.43%91.79%16.698,927.86
Full PCM93.57%97.01%9.381,412.03

Full PCM improves success by 17.14 percentage points on seen tasks and 5.22 percentage points on unseen tasks, while reducing average steps by approximately 43.8% and online token consumption by approximately 84.2%. These gains are obtained with the same executable programs and execution mechanism. They therefore provide evidence that PCM’s predictive belief design contributes additional task-performance and execution-efficiency benefits within the same executable-program framework, beyond the shared benefits of executable reuse.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer VYyo (2/4)

W1 & Q2: "How was equivalence between textual and executable procedures established? Were textual procedures given access to the same state information and computational tools, and how should the reported gains be attributed between memory representation and the execution mechanism?"

Answer:

Thank you for raising these important and insightful questions. We agree that they are fundamental to establishing a fair comparison between textual and executable procedures and to understanding the sources of PCM’s gains. To address these concerns, we conducted additional experiments and provide further methodological clarifications. Below, we address three aspects: procedural equivalence, access to state information and computational tools, and the respective contributions of representation and execution.

(a) How was equivalence between textual and executable procedures established?

We agree that a fair comparison requires the two representations to preserve the same procedural information. As described in Appendix A.3 (Program Form × Belief Form Implementation), the Textual Program and Executable Program are derived from the same source procedure. Specifically, we construct a structured natural-language specification based on the source program’s execution logic. This specification describes when the program applies, how task entities are bound, how actions are selected under different conditions, and how execution progress, failure recovery, and termination are handled. A deterministic renderer then organizes these rules into the Textual Program using a fixed field order, labels, and numbering. The resulting text is provided to the runtime LLM as frozen procedural guidance.

Building on this construction, we further examine whether the two representations express the same decision and execution rules—that is, whether the textual description allows the original program’s mapping from inputs and execution states to actions to be recovered. To investigate this, we designed a program-reconstruction experiment: we withheld the original executable source, asked the LLM to implement executable programs using only the Textual Program, and compared the reconstructed programs with the original under identical inputs. If independently reconstructed programs produce action choices that closely match those of the original, this provides empirical support for consistency in the procedural logic conveyed by the two representations.

Specifically, we conducted this reconstruction experiment with PCM on ALFWorld, using five independent LLM runs to reconstruct executable programs from the Textual Program. Each reconstruction was compared with the original on the same 500 randomly sampled cases from 103 tasks, using the same public input interface. All reconstructions were evaluated as generated, without modifying their code or the shared test cases.

ReconstructionMatched / casesAgreementRuntime failuresAction mismatchesAST SHA-256 (first 12)
1491/50098.20%818250d70df444
2499/50099.80%011197422a7529
3500/500100.00%007a1e3bdbf2b1
4500/500100.00%00fffbcf82b676
5492/50098.40%714344ed47cd0d

The five reconstructions have distinct AST fingerprints, indicating that their syntactic implementations are not identical. Nevertheless, their mean behavioral agreement with the original program reached 99.28%, with a sample standard deviation of 0.90 percentage points. These results show that independently reconstructed implementations recover highly consistent input–action mappings on the sampled cases, providing empirical support for the consistency of the procedural logic conveyed by the Textual and Executable Programs.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer VYyo (3/4)

W1 & Q2 (continued): Information access and execution effects

(b) Were textual procedures given access to the same state information and computational tools?

PT and PCM have matched access to public information and share the same environment interfaces and host-provided computational support. Public-state maintenance, belief provision according to the experimental condition, and action submission are handled by the shared host. PT therefore does not need to invoke additional computational tools to obtain this information. The two conditions differ in how they use the stored procedure: PT relies on the LLM to interpret textual rules and select actions, without a general-purpose code executor or callable computational tools, whereas PCM directly executes the program in covered states.

Specifically, in the comparison on 274 ALFWorld tasks, both conditions use the same public-input definitions, including the task goal, current public observation, admissible actions, execution context, confirmed facts, and recent interaction history. They also submit actions and receive environment feedback through the same host interface.

Belief information follows the experimental condition: in the 3 × 3 study, B0 provides no beliefs, BD provides descriptive information, and BQ provides numerical estimates. In the comparison with BQ fixed, the host retrieves numerical estimates and associated statistics from the frozen belief memory and supplies them to both conditions. PT receives this information through its model context, without needing to re-estimate probabilities from interaction history; PCM’s programs read the corresponding information directly.

These shared host settings match PT and PCM in two respects: access to public information and computational support.

(c) How should the gains be attributed between memory representation and the execution mechanism?

We agree that the roles of program representation and execution mechanism should be distinguished when interpreting the gains. We therefore introduced PE-Sim to examine the contribution of direct execution while keeping the executable-program representation fixed.

In PE-Sim, the LLM simulates PCM’s executable source instead of running it directly. PCM and PE-Sim share the same source code, quantitative beliefs, public state inputs, and fallback interfaces. The key difference is whether the program’s control logic is executed directly or simulated by the LLM.

We evaluated PE-Sim on all 274 ALFWorld tasks and compared it with the frozen PCM results. PT, which uses a different reasoning budget, is included solely as a performance reference.

MethodRepresentationExecutionSeen SR ↑ (140 tasks)Unseen SR ↑ (134 tasks)Tokens/task ↓Steps/task ↓LLM calls/task ↓
PTTextual programLLM79.29% (111/140)88.81% (119/134)76.54k18.8620.00
PE-SimExecutable programLLM95.71% (134/140)99.25% (133/134)73.36k9.3911.90
PCMExecutable programDirect execution96.43% (135/140)99.25% (133/134)7.14k9.642.68

Both PE-Sim and PCM achieve higher success than the PT reference and perform similarly to each other. They differ by only one successful task on the seen split, while both succeed on 133 of 134 unseen tasks. Thus, the same program logic retains high task success when simulated by the LLM.

PE-Sim consumes more tokens because the LLM must reason through and simulate program execution. The similar success rates across execution modes indicate that the control logic encoded in the executable representation supports high task performance under different execution mechanisms, while the main benefit of direct execution in this experiment is lower online token consumption.


Reviewer_uczEOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Program-Centric Memory (PCM), which stores an agent’s accumulated experience in two forms: Predictive Beliefs, explicit probability estimates of observable action-outcome relationships, and Executable Programs, stateful control structures that encode reusable action patterns. At runtime, PCM matches a program, queries beliefs when that program requires outcome comparisons, and falls back to an LLM for uncovered states. Beliefs are estimated with a Dirichlet-multinomial shrinkage method; programs are generated or revised from trajectories and accepted after interface and behavioral validation. Experiments compare PCM with agent-memory baselines on ALFWorld and WebShop, with an additional TravelPlanner evaluation. A controlled 3×3 study on ALFWorld varies program and belief representation while holding the underlying information fixed; additional analyses examine belief estimation and use, program execution, and program revisions. The paper reports strong performance and lower online token use, especially on ALFWorld.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides a meaningful controlled test of memory form. In the ALFWorld 3×3 experiment, executable programs and quantitative beliefs are compared with textual/descriptive forms derived from the same action patterns and predictive evidence. With quantitative beliefs, replacing textual programs with executable programs raises success from 79.9% to 97.8%, reduces steps from 20.8 to 10.9, and reduces online tokens from 98.4k to 2.5k per task. This directly addresses the paper’s central hypothesis more convincingly than an uncontrolled comparison of complete systems would.
  2. The system is specified in operational terms and evaluated beyond a single task family. Belief construction, program applicability/binding, context updates, fallback behavior, and program validation are described explicitly. PCM is evaluated on ALFWorld, WebShop, and TravelPlanner, and the paper reports task success alongside steps, calls, and tokens where applicable. The authors also include a program-revision case study and explicitly note a case where a locally validated revision slightly decreased real-environment success.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The strongest evidence for the general “Representation for Function” claim is concentrated in ALFWorld. The main analysis all use ALFWorld. WebShop and TravelPlanner demonstrate transfer of the overall system, but do not test whether executable versus textual programs or quantitative versus descriptive beliefs explain the gains there. Moreover, the main cross-method results compare PCM with reimplementations for several baselines, with no reported uncertainty estimates, while TravelPlanner includes both general and task-specific systems and uses 180 validation queries.
  2. The program and belief construction pipeline has important validity and reproducibility details that remain difficult to assess. Program updates rely on an LLM to generate/revise executable control logic, and validation tests are generated from the revision proposal itself; the appendix correctly notes that these tests do not interact with the actual environment and cannot replace real task evaluation. The five-case revision study evaluates a small 36-task panel, with one revision reducing success from 97.2% to 94.4% despite passing validation. This illustrates the gap between implementation-level checks and robust behavior.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide the number of learned programs, their coverage on each benchmark, and the precise rules for matching among multiple applicable programs and for accepting or rolling back an update? How often are generated validation tests insufficient to catch a real-environment regression, and is there a held-out regression suite beyond the five-case study? These details materially affect confidence in the proposed program-update mechanism.
  2. Could the controlled Program Form × Belief Form comparison be replicated on WebShop or TravelPlanner, or could the authors explain why equivalent matched-form controls are infeasible? Without this, it is difficult to distinguish a generally useful representation principle from an ALFWorld-specific benefit of these implementations.
  3. For the reproduced baselines and PCM on WebShop and TravelPlanner, how many seeds or repeated API runs were used, and what is the uncertainty in the reported scores? In TravelPlanner, can the authors clarify the validation protocol and explain how comparisons with task-specific methods should be interpreted alongside the general-agent baselines?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer uczE (1/5)

Dear Reviewer uczE,

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for recognizing our work as a “meaningful controlled test of memory form,” with explicit system details and evaluation across multiple task families.

During the rebuttal period, we added experiments, uncertainty analyses, and protocol clarifications to address your concerns:

  • Added a full 3 × 3 Program Form × Belief Form comparison on WebShop.
  • Reported API-run counts and uncertainty estimates for WebShop and TravelPlanner.
  • Completed evaluation on the full official TravelPlanner test split and clarified the comparison protocol.

Below, we provide detailed responses to each of your questions, with the utmost sincerity, to fully address every concern.


W1 & Q2: "The strongest evidence for the general “Representation for Function” claim is concentrated in ALFWorld." "Could the controlled Program Form × Belief Form comparison be replicated on WebShop or TravelPlanner, or could the authors explain why equivalent matched-form controls are infeasible?"

Answer:

Thank you for suggesting this additional experiment. We agree that comparing program and belief representations beyond ALFWorld is important for assessing the generality of the Representation for Function principle. To address this concern, we added a 3 × 3 Program Form × Belief Form comparison on the same 240 WebShop tasks, crossing three program forms—none, textual, and executable—with three belief forms—none, descriptive, and quantitative. This experiment examines how the different combinations perform in another environment.

Program formBelief formExact Success ↑Mean Reward ↑Tokens/task (k) ↓Steps/task ↓
No Program (P0)None (B0)30.42%0.431953.947.82
No Program (P0)Descriptive (BD)30.42%0.401553.727.31
No Program (P0)Quantitative (BQ)31.25%0.414452.667.15
Textual Program (PT)None (B0)38.33%0.5663183.066.34
Textual Program (PT)Descriptive (BD)39.58%0.5670186.206.37
Textual Program (PT)Quantitative (BQ)37.50%0.5536184.936.30
Executable Program (PE)None (B0)40.00%0.553694.178.98
Executable Program (PE)Descriptive (BD)44.17%0.689876.638.07
Executable Program (PE)Quantitative (BQ)47.08%0.71299.228.49

k = 1,000. Bold marks the best value for each metric.

The combination of executable programs and quantitative beliefs achieves the highest exact success (47.08%) and mean reward (0.7129), with the lowest online token consumption (9.22k per task). With quantitative beliefs, executable programs outperform textual programs by 9.58 percentage points in success while using approximately 95.0% fewer tokens. Within the executable-program configurations, quantitative beliefs outperform descriptive beliefs by 2.92 percentage points, with approximately 88.0% fewer tokens.

The WebShop results are consistent with the ALFWorld findings, showing that executable programs combined with quantitative beliefs achieve strong task performance and token efficiency across both environments. This consistency supports the applicability of this representation combination across different task settings. It also provides further empirical support for the Representation for Function principle beyond ALFWorld.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer uczE (2/5)

W2: “The program and belief construction pipeline has important validity and reproducibility details that remain difficult to assess.” “This illustrates the gap between implementation-level checks and robust behavior.”

Answer:

Thank you for raising this concern. We agree that assessing program updates requires actual task evaluation alongside implementation-level checks. We would like to clarify how PCM’s iterative development process combines offline validation with execution feedback from the environment. During PCM construction, this process follows four stages:

Program Revision → Program Validation → Program Update → Online Execution.

During Program Revision, the LLM revises the program using trajectories and feedback collected on the development set. The candidate then undergoes Program Validation, which checks its interface and whether it implements the intended modification. If validation passes, Program Update temporarily applies the candidate version for evaluation. During Online Execution, the candidate interacts with the actual task environment, producing task outcomes and new execution feedback. We then decide whether to retain the update or roll back to the previous version based on overall task performance and whether the intended revision objectives have been achieved. The resulting feedback guides subsequent revisions.

Thus, the revision loop combines offline validation with online execution feedback. Issues missed by offline tests can be identified during actual task execution and addressed through rollback or subsequent revision. The development set supports both iterative revision and version selection; persistent memory remains frozen during final benchmark evaluation. We provide the detailed update rules and independent regression evaluation in Q1(c)–(d), and will include further details of PCM’s development process in the revised paper.


Q1:

“Can the authors provide the number of learned programs, their coverage on each benchmark, and the precise rules for matching among multiple applicable programs and for accepting or rolling back an update? How often are generated validation tests insufficient to catch a real-environment regression, and is there a held-out regression suite beyond the five-case study? These details materially affect confidence in the proposed program-update mechanism.”

Answer:

Thank you for these questions about program execution and update reliability. We agree that precise operational rules and independent task-level evaluation are important for assessing the program-update mechanism. We address these concerns in four parts below.

(a) How many programs are learned, and what is their coverage on each benchmark?

The table below reports the number of learned executable programs and their coverage on each benchmark.

Benchmark# ProgramsProgramLLM
ALFWorld (steps)1466.21%33.79%
WebShop (steps)8566.93%33.07%
TravelPlanner (calls)4985.96%14.04%

(b) How does PCM select among multiple applicable programs?

As described in Sections 3.3–3.4, PCM matches programs using the current observable state StS_t, execution context CtC_t, and program applicability conditions CONDΠ=(m1,m2,…)\mathrm{COND}_{\Pi}=(m_1,m_2,\ldots). Each program’s applicability function mjm_j determines whether the program applies and binds the required entities. The matching operation MatchΠ\mathrm{Match}_{\Pi} returns the selected program πj\pi_j together with its entity bindings ztz_t.

In our ALFWorld implementation, this matching operation follows a predefined program priority order established during PCM development. Programs are checked in that order, and the first applicable program whose decision rule djd_j returns an admissible action is used. If a program is inapplicable or does not return an admissible action, the system proceeds to the next program. If no program provides an admissible action, the common LLM fallback is invoked. This specifies how the matching operation resolves cases in which multiple programs are applicable.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer uczE (3/5)

Q1 (continued): Program update decisions and regression evaluation

(c) How are program updates validated, accepted, or rolled back?

As described in W2, PCM follows four stages: Program Revision → Program Validation → Program Update → Online Execution. Once a revised program passes validation, the candidate version is temporarily applied and evaluated through actual environment execution on the Development Set.

The LLM then decides whether to retain the update or roll back to the previously accepted version based on overall task performance and whether the intended revision objectives have been achieved. These decisions are made without human intervention. The development set also supplies execution trajectories and feedback for subsequent revisions. The Held-out Regression Set and Evaluation Pool are excluded from program revision and version selection.

(d) How often do generated validation tests miss real-environment regressions, and is there an independent held-out regression suite?

In Appendix B.3, all five revisions passed generated validation, but one reduced task success from 97.2% to 94.4%. We further examined regressions by retrospectively evaluating historical program versions from PCM’s original development.

ALFWorld. Our program development involved 35 completed iterations on a Development Set, which is a subset of the original Construction Set described in Appendix A.1 (Table 6). This development set provided execution feedback for program revision and supported version selection. For the additional held-out evaluation, we sampled 60 tasks from the ALFWorld training set, outside the original Construction Set, with 10 tasks from each of the six task types. We evaluated the historical versions on this Held-out Regression Set after the program versions and their original selection decisions had been frozen. These results did not contribute to program revision or version selection.

The retrospective evaluation identified three candidate revisions (3/35, 8.6%) with lower held-out success than the then-current accepted program. All three had already been rejected during development based on development-set performance. Across the accepted revisions, held-out success improved from 48.33% to 100%, with no decreases between successive accepted versions on these tasks.

TravelPlanner. Because TravelPlanner provides only 45 training queries, we did not set aside a separate held-out regression suite. Instead, we examined performance changes during development on these same 45 queries. Of 52 construction and revision iterations, 41 completed evaluation. Success decreased in 12 of the 40 comparisons between consecutive evaluated versions (30.0%), despite an overall upward trend.

Overall, these individual regressions did not prevent task performance from improving through iterative development. The ALFWorld results further show that development-set selection rejected the candidates that later exhibited held-out regressions. We will include more detailed development and evaluation results in the revised paper.


Reviewer_MphbOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an agent memory system, Program-Centric Memory where its core is modeling action-outcome probabilities and apply it to maintain a list of executable programs. They tested on three benchmark datasets (ALFWorld, Webshop and TravelPlanner) and claim stronger performance over baselines.

Critical strengths

None.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Neither of the core components (predicate belief and library of executable programs) is new. Incorporating programs and functions into memories is already a standard procedure, as seen in very popular papers, e.g., Dynamic Cheatsheet and ReasoningBank [1, 2]. Predicate belief update was also introduced in BeliefMem [3]. I don't believe the paper provides sufficient discussion on its distinction, and also most included baselines are pre-2026.
  2. The performance gain is incremental and the paper sometimes makes apples-to-oranges comparisons. The gain over the already old baselines in WebShop and TravelPlanner is merely 1.7% in exact success for WebShop, 0% in HC-macro, and 4.5% in FPR for TravelPlanner. In comparison with MACLA in ALFWorld, the paper reports the metric obtained by Llama-2-7B versus DS-V4-flash (a 284B-parameter model) for their proposed PCM. This comparison is obviously vastly unfair.

[1] Dynamic Cheatsheet: Test-time Learning with Adaptive Memory (EACL 2026)
[2] ReasoningBank: Scaling Agent Self-Evolving with Reasoning Memory (ICLR 2026)
[3] Belief Memory: Agent Memory Under Partial Observability (arxiv 2026)

Questions for authors
  1. What are HC-Macro and CS-Macro? Sec. 4.1 Experimental Setup did not include or explain them in the evaluation metrics but these metrics came out of nowhere in the results section.
  2. Why is the paper using the validation split (n=180) instead of the official test split (n=1000) of TravelPlanner?
  3. What is the ratio of instances where a program can be directly reused to those where an LLM fallback is triggered throughout the trajectory?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Mphb (1/3)

Dear Reviewer Mphb,

Thank you for your review. We have added the following experiments and clarifications:

  • Clarified PCM’s contribution and its distinctions from related work.
  • Added a MACLA comparison using the same backbone as PCM.
  • Evaluated PCM and five baselines on all 1,000 official TravelPlanner test queries.
  • Further analyzed the performance gains on TravelPlanner and WebShop.
  • Clarified the definitions of HC-Macro and CS-Macro.
  • Reported the proportions of program and LLM use across all three benchmarks.

Below, we provide detailed responses to your concerns.


W1: "Neither of the core components (predicate belief and library of executable programs) is new. Incorporating programs and functions into memories is already a standard procedure, as seen in very popular papers, e.g., Dynamic Cheatsheet and ReasoningBank [1, 2]. Predicate belief update was also introduced in BeliefMem [3]. I don't believe the paper provides sufficient discussion on its distinction, and also most included baselines are pre-2026."

Answer:

Thank you for pointing out these important related works. We agree that executable programs and probabilistic memory updates have been explored in prior research, and we do not claim to introduce either component in isolation. Our contribution instead lies in the Representation for Function perspective: memory representations should align with their computational functions at reuse time.

Distinction from prior work. Works such as Dynamic Cheatsheet and ReasoningBank explore incorporating reusable experience and procedural knowledge into agent memory, while Voyager, MACLA, Memp, and Skill-Pro investigate learning and reusing procedural knowledge. Similarly, BeliefMem studies probabilistic memory representations and belief updates. PCM differs in how these forms of experience are represented and coordinated at runtime. Specifically, Executable Programs encode stateful control structures, including applicability conditions, entity bindings, decision rules, and execution progress (§3.3), allowing reusable behavior to be directly executed rather than repeatedly interpreted by the LLM. Predictive Beliefs explicitly represent local action–outcome relationships as queryable conditional distributions, P(outcome∣state,action)P(\text{outcome}\mid\text{state},\text{action}), which Executable Programs can query when comparing candidate actions (§3.2–3.4). Thus, PCM does not simply combine two independent memory components; it coordinates representations for prediction and execution within a unified runtime framework.

Empirical evidence for memory representation. Importantly, our contribution is supported by controlled experiments rather than architectural design alone. In §4.3, we conduct a 3 × 3 Program Form × Belief Form study, holding the underlying action patterns and predictive evidence fixed while varying their representations. Under the same Quantitative Belief condition, replacing Textual Programs with Executable Programs increases success from 79.9% to 97.8%, reduces interaction steps from 20.8 to 10.9, and reduces online tokens from 98.4k to 2.5k per task. These results provide direct evidence that how experience is represented, not merely what information is retained, substantially affects its reuse effectiveness.

Finally, we acknowledge that the original Related Work section did not sufficiently discuss recent developments. We will expand it to include and clarify the distinctions from Dynamic Cheatsheet, ReasoningBank, BeliefMem, and other recent procedural-memory approaches, including MACLA, Memp, and Skill-Pro. We will also clarify that PCM's contribution is the Representation for Function perspective and its controlled empirical investigation, rather than the isolated introduction of executable memory or probabilistic updates.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Mphb (2/3)

W2(a): "... the paper sometimes makes apples-to-oranges comparisons." "In comparison with MACLA in ALFWorld, the paper reports the metric obtained by Llama-2-7B versus DS-V4-flash (a 284B-parameter model) for their proposed PCM. This comparison is obviously vastly unfair."

Answer:

Thank you for pointing this out. We originally reported MACLA with Llama-2-7B because this is the model used in its paper. We additionally evaluated MACLA using DS-V4-flash, the same backbone as PCM. As shown below, PCM achieves higher success on both splits with fewer steps and online tokens. We will add these details to the revised paper.

MethodModelSeen SR ↑ (140 tasks)Unseen SR ↑ (134 tasks)Steps / task ↓Online tokens / task ↓
MACLA (original paper)Llama-2-7B87.2%90.3%——
MACLADS-V4-flash90.7%91.8%17.136.4k
PCMDS-V4-flash97.9%97.8%10.92.49k

W2(b): "The performance gain is incremental ... The gain over the already old baselines in WebShop and TravelPlanner is merely 1.7% in exact success for WebShop, 0% in HC-macro, and 4.5% in FPR for TravelPlanner."

Answer:

Thank you for raising this concern about the performance gains.TravelPlanner. On the original validation split (n=180), PCM achieves 100.0% CS-Macro, 98.9% HC-Macro, and 98.9% FPR. Compared with the published Formal Verification results, PCM improves CS-Macro by 5.0 percentage points and FPR by 5.6 percentage points. Both methods achieve 98.9% HC-Macro. FPR is the primary metric, measuring the proportion of complete itineraries satisfying all commonsense and hard constraints. The HC-Macro result is near saturation: only two of the 180 itineraries fail to satisfy all constraints, leaving limited room to distinguish methods on this split. To further assess performance at scale, we evaluated PCM and all five baseline implementations on the 1,000 official test queries (see Q2 for detailed results). PCM achieves 100.0% CS-Macro (+5.7 pp), 99.6% HC-Macro (+5.7 pp), and 99.6% FPR (+5.7 pp) on the test set, compared with Formal Verification. Under the same DS-V4-flash backbone, PCM also substantially outperforms the five baselines in HC-Macro (99.6% vs. 70.4%–77.2%) and FPR (99.6% vs. 12.8%–15.8%). Meanwhile, PCM consumes only 0.544k online tokens per query, compared with 69.7k–71.8k for the baselines.

WebShop. PCM improves Exact Success from 45.4% to 47.1% (+1.7 percentage points) over the strongest baseline (AWM). Beyond exact task completion, PCM also improves Mean Reward from 0.665 to 0.713 (+0.048). We will incorporate these additional results and analyses into the revised paper.


AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Mphb (3/3)

Q1: "What are HC-Macro and CS-Macro? Sec. 4.1 Experimental Setup did not include or explain them in the evaluation metrics but these metrics came out of nowhere in the results section."

Answer:

Thank you for pointing out this omission. HC-Macro is the proportion of evaluated plans satisfying all applicable hard constraints (e.g., budget and accommodation requirements), while CS-Macro is the proportion satisfying all commonsense constraints (e.g., route consistency). Both are official TravelPlanner metrics (Xie et al., 2024).

HC-Macro=Number of plans satisfying all applicable hard constraintsN.\text{HC-Macro}=\frac{\text{Number of plans satisfying all applicable hard constraints}}{N}.

CS-Macro=Number of plans satisfying all commonsense constraintsN.\text{CS-Macro}=\frac{\text{Number of plans satisfying all commonsense constraints}}{N}.

Here, NN is the total number of evaluated tasks. We will add these definitions and formulas to Section 4.1 in the revised paper.


Q2: "Why is the paper using the validation split (n=180) instead of the official test split (n=1000) of TravelPlanner?"

Answer:

Thank you for raising this question. Following prior TravelPlanner studies [1–5], which evaluate on the 180-query official validation split covering all nine duration–difficulty combinations, we adopted the same evaluation protocol in our initial experiments.

To directly address this concern, we have now evaluated PCM and all five baseline implementations on all 1,000 official test queries using the same backbone, DS-V4-flash, enabling a consistent comparison across methods. We additionally report the published Formal Verification results [6] using Claude 3 Opus as an external reference. We use Final Pass Rate (FPR) as the primary metric, measuring the proportion of complete itineraries satisfying all commonsense and hard constraints. The full test-set results are presented below and will be incorporated into the revised paper.

MethodModelCS-Macro ↑HC-Macro ↑FPR ↑Online tokens/query ↓
ReActDS-V4-flash19.60%73.40%15.80%69.7k
ReflActDS-V4-flash19.90%77.20%14.80%71.6k
ExPeLDS-V4-flash19.90%73.10%15.00%71.7k
AWMDS-V4-flash17.50%70.40%12.80%71.8k
MACLADS-V4-flash18.60%73.50%14.70%69.8k
Formal Verification [6]Claude 3 Opus94.30%93.90%93.90%—
PCMDS-V4-flash100.00%99.60%99.60%0.544k

References

[1] HyperTree Planning: Enhancing LLM Reasoning via Hierarchical Thinking (ICML 2025)
[2] EvoAgent: Towards Automatic Multi-Agent Generation via Evolutionary Algorithms (NAACL 2025)
[3] SwarmAgentic: Towards Fully Automated Agentic System Generation via Swarm Intelligence (EMNLP 2025)
[4] Plan and Budget: Effective and Efficient Test-Time Scaling on Reasoning Large Language Models (ICLR 2026)
[5] Agent Learning via Early Experience (ICML 2026)
[6] Large Language Models Can Solve Real-World Planning Rigorously with Formal Verification Tools (NAACL 2025)


Q3: "What is the ratio of instances where a program can be directly reused to those where an LLM fallback is triggered throughout the trajectory?"

Answer:

Thank you for asking about program reuse and LLM fallback. The table below summarizes program coverage and LLM use across the three benchmarks, showing their respective shares during task execution.

BenchmarkProgramLLM
ALFWorld (steps)66.21%33.79%
WebShop (steps)66.93%33.07%
TravelPlanner (calls)85.96%14.04%

Thank you again for your valuable comments on our work. We hope these clarifications and additional results address your concerns and encourage you to reassess our work. We look forward to your further feedback and would be happy to discuss any remaining questions.


Comments on the paper

4 comments

Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. I appreciate that the authors directly addressed my concerns. These results provide stronger evidence for the contribution of predictive beliefs and help clarify the respective benefits of program representation and direct execution. The additional details on data separation and construction costs are also helpful.

I still have some concerns regarding the novelty over existing executable-memory approaches, the fairness of the textual versus executable comparison, and the generality of the results beyond the evaluated environments. I encourage the authors to clarify these limitations and the differences between experimental settings in the revised paper. Overall, I think the rebuttal has substantially strengthened the paper and addressed enough of my original concerns.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer VYyo

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback and for recognizing the value of our additional experiments and clarifications. We will address the remaining points in the revised paper as follows:

  • Novelty: Clarify PCM’s distinctions from existing executable-memory approaches.

  • Fairness: Explain the conditions and limitations of the textual–executable comparison.

  • Generality: We have additionally compared PCM with MACLA on ALFWorld using three additional backbones: GPT-4o, Claude-haiku-5-5, and Qwen3.8-27b. Across all three, PCM achieves higher success rates with fewer online tokens and LLM calls, providing further evidence of its applicability across backbones. We will incorporate these results into the revised paper, while clarifying that generalization beyond the evaluated environments remains to be established.

  • Experimental settings: Describe the differences between experimental settings and their implications for interpreting the results.

We are glad that our responses and additional experiments have helped address your concerns. We welcome any further feedback or discussion.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Rebuttal and Discussion

Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,

Thank you for your time and constructive feedback. We summarize the main developments during the discussion to facilitate the final assessment.

Discussion progress. Reviewers opWF and uczE confirmed that our responses addressed their concerns. In their November 17 comment, Reviewer VYyo stated that the rebuttal substantially strengthened the paper and addressed enough of their original concerns. They also encouraged us to clarify the limitations and differences between experimental settings in the revised manuscript.

Additional evidence. Our responses cover three main areas:

  • Contribution and comparisons with prior work. We clarified how PCM reuses procedural memory. Each program encodes both the conditions under which it applies and the logic for selecting the next action. When those conditions are met, the runtime executes the program directly. In our November 16 response to Reviewer Mphb, we reported a comparison on ALFWorld using the same backbone for all three methods. PCM achieved 97.81% success, compared with 83.58% for Dynamic Cheatsheet and 67.15% for ReasoningBank. In a separate ALFWorld comparison across four backbones, PCM achieved higher success and used fewer online tokens than MACLA on all four.

  • Memory representation and execution (updated November 18). We added a Program Form × Belief Form study on WebShop and a program-reconstruction experiment. In our November 18 follow-up to Reviewer VYyo, we also reran all three methods on the same 274 ALFWorld tasks under a common token limit. The LLM solved 220 tasks when following the textual procedure (PT) and 266 when simulating the executable program (PE-Sim). Direct execution of the same program (PCM) solved 267 tasks and reduced online tokens per task by 90.9% relative to PE-Sim, from 73.58k to 6.70k.

  • Evaluation and reliability. We evaluated PCM and five baselines on all 1,000 official TravelPlanner test queries. We also provided uncertainty estimates, an independent regression evaluation, and further details on data separation and memory-construction costs.

The corresponding responses provide the full results and experimental settings. We will incorporate these additions into the revised manuscript and clarify how PCM differs from prior work, how the experimental settings affect interpretation, and the limits of generalization beyond the evaluated environments.

We welcome further discussion of any remaining concerns and appreciate your consideration of the updated evidence.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up Response to Reviewer VYyo

Dear Reviewer VYyo,

Thank you for asking how we ensured a fair comparison between textual and executable procedures and what PCM adds to prior work. We clarify both points below and report updated ALFWorld results.

1. Fairness of the Comparison between Textual and Executable Procedures

The textual program (PT) and the executable program (PE) derive from the same source procedure. In our earlier reconstruction experiment, programs reconstructed from PT achieved 99.28% mean action agreement with the original program on the sampled cases.

All three methods have access to the same public state information, admissible actions, and quantitative beliefs. The same host maintains the public state, supplies the beliefs, and submits actions. In PT, the LLM interprets the textual instructions to select an action. PE-Sim and PCM share the same executable source code and fallback interface. PE-Sim uses the LLM to simulate the code, while PCM executes it directly in states the program covers.

2. Experimental Settings

In our earlier response, “reasoning budget” referred to the configured limit on total tokens. To accommodate the potential cost of simulating program execution, we raised the limit for both PE-Sim and PCM in the original comparison. PT retained its original limit. We then reran all three methods on the same 274 ALFWorld tasks under a common token limit and verified that every run stayed below it. The table reports actual online token usage.

MethodSeen successUnseen successOnline tokens/taskSteps/taskLLM calls/task
PT80.71%79.85%78.92k19.2220.67
PE-Sim95.71%98.51%73.58k9.3911.93
PCM96.43%98.51%6.70k9.412.56

With the executable source held fixed, PE-Sim solved 266 of 274 tasks and PCM solved 267. Native execution reduced online tokens per task by 90.9%, from 73.58k to 6.70k, with similar task success.

3. Novelty over Existing Executable-Memory Approaches

Voyager provides executable skills that the LLM can invoke or compose, Dynamic Cheatsheet lets the LLM reuse strategies and code snippets, and ReasoningBank retrieves reasoning strategies from prior experience. In each case, the model decides how to apply the retrieved experience. Following our Representation for Function principle, PCM encodes both when a procedure applies and how it selects the next action. When the current state matches a stored procedure, the runtime executes it directly. The program can consult Predictive Beliefs to compare candidate actions, and the LLM handles uncovered states. In a separate ALFWorld comparison using the same LLM backbone, PCM achieved 97.81% task success, compared with 83.58% for Dynamic Cheatsheet and 67.15% for ReasoningBank. Online token usage averaged 2.49k per task for PCM, 49.00k for Dynamic Cheatsheet, and 22.27k for ReasoningBank.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.