- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper constructs an overall head motion modeling method for real-time interaction between two people. The task of this paper has been improved on existing related head motion tasks, with better applicability. As a reviewer, I had already seen this article from arXiv and logged into the paper homepage before reviewing it. Overall, this article does have some innovation, but from a holistic perspective, it does not deviate from the architecture of head motion, and the generated effects still have some issues with head motion itself, such as image jitter, large action offset, and insufficient parallel synchronization of dialogue actions. The specific opinions are as follows. I believe the author still needs to further polish the article.
Critical strengths
1.A new task with greater potential for application, which has made new improvements on existing head motion tasks and achieved preliminary dialogue effects. 2.The author conducted extensive experimental verification and demonstrated real-life scenarios. 3.By defining some basic action units, enrich the prominent features of head motion.
Critical weaknesses
There has been innovation in the task define, but there has been no significant improvement in terms of the results and effects. There are still many traditional problems with 3D head generation, especially in the display of dynamic effects. The biggest problem with the article is that the methodology section is somewhat disorganized, such as the messy presentation of Figure 2, which fails to highlight the core innovation of the methodology.
Questions for authors
-
There has been innovation in the task define, but there has been no significant improvement in terms of the results and effects. There are still many traditional problems with 3D head generation, especially in the display of dynamic effects.
-
The biggest problem with the article is that the methodology section is somewhat disorganized, such as the messy presentation of Figure 2, which fails to highlight the core innovation of the methodology
-
The hypothesis of the paper was validated through several indicators in Figure 3. This section is a bit self explanatory and does not effectively convince readers. It feels like an analysis is being conducted for the sake of rationality
4.The innovation at the methodological level is not strong, and many of them are conceptual integrations.
5.The academic nature of the entire work is not strong enough, it is more like an engineering pipeline.
6.The dynamic head motion effects presented by the author are not comprehensive. Some display effects still have unreasonable situations, such as unreasonable opening and closing of the mouth, understanding of the head, and rapid action conversion.