acceptodds
Desk rejected at ICLR 2027

TraceAhead: Learning Non-Myopic Control for LLM Search Agents from Branched Executions

Desk rejected at ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

LLM search agents often need to decide whether to keep searching and, if so, which direction to pursue, even though the value of a search action may only become apparent several steps later. Judging a search action only by its immediate effect can therefore overlook actions that enable valuable future searches. We introduce TraceAhead, a lightweight value-based controller for non-myopic control of LLM search agents. TraceAhead models search control as a finite-horizon decision problem, with stopping as the zero-value reference and each search action valued by its immediate net gain together with the continuation value it enables. It learns these history-dependent action values from branched training executions: starting from shared checkpoints, alternative actions are executed and regularized backward fitting propagates downstream value from successor histories to earlier decisions. At inference time, the learned values guide the agent's decision of whether to stop and, if continuing, which search direction to pursue, while only the selected action is executed along a single search path. We evaluate TraceAhead on three multi-hop question answering benchmarks with three LLM search actors. At development-selected operating points with similar token use, TraceAhead achieves higher final-answer quality than three alternative search-control policies in all nine model–benchmark settings, with gains of up to 8.2 F1 points over the immediate-value policy. Additional analyses indicate that the learned continuation signal contains predictive information about future search opportunities. Together, these results show that training-time branches can provide supervision for history-dependent, non-myopic search decisions in LLM agents without requiring branch expansion at inference time.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, sequential decision making, action-value functions, adaptive retrieval

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_kGb4OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces TraceAhead, a lightweight controller that helps a fixed LLM search agent decide when to stop and where to search next. It learns the immediate and future value of search actions from branched training runs, while following only one search path during inference. Experiments on three multi-hop QA benchmarks with three LLMs show higher answer F1 than the compared control policies at development-selected settings with similar token use.

Critical strengths
  1. A small linear controller guides a fixed LLM actor without actor fine-tuning or inference-time branch expansion.
  2. TraceAhead improves F1 over all three controls in all nine benchmark–actor settings at development-selected operating points with similar token use.
  3. TraceAhead separates training from deployment: training uses branched executions, while inference follows a single search path.
Critical weaknesses
  1. None of the baselines learns history-dependent continuation value, leaving the advantage of the proposed backward fitting over other non-myopic approaches unclear.
  2. Key implementation details are underspecified, limiting reproducibility.
  3. The paper lacks ablation studys like backup penalty and lookahead depths H.
Questions for authors
  1. Why does TraceAhead’s advantage disappear at some token budgets in Figure 2?
  2. Can you add an ablation study on the backup penalty?
  3. Can you add an ablation study on the lookahead depths H?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer kGb4 (1/2)

Thank you for the positive assessment. You asked for a learned non-myopic baseline, implementation details, ablations of κ and H, and an explanation of Figure 2.

W1. A baseline that learns history-dependent continuation value

We added such a baseline, and TraceAhead outperforms it with both actors.

Direct return regression fits the realized multi-step net return of zero-offset SA Mean on the same history features, so it credits delayed gains without backward fitting. To build each label, we force the labeled action and then continue with the out-of-fold SA Mean policy. The target is F1(stop) − F1(start) − 0.025 × added queries, including the forced action. Each comparison shares the actor, trees, features, query limit and cost calibration rule. The ridge precision of return regression is selected independently.

We test on held-out MuSiQue questions with GLM-5.3 Flash and on the Table 1 MuSiQue questions with DeepSeek v4.1 Flash.

ActorMatched tokens (k)TraceAhead F1Return regression F1ΔF1 [95% CI]
GLM-5.3 Flash12.14559.0556.46+2.58 [0.91, 4.61]
DeepSeek v4.1 Flash14.70460.6258.41+2.21 [0.94, 3.73]

(Added to the revised paper: Section 5.6, Table 3; Appendix E.1, Table 7.)

W2. Implementation details

The revised paper now specifies every implementation detail. In brief, the controller reads 33 public features at the first checkpoint and 60 thereafter, the verifier returns a JSON decision, and the operating offsets are set on development trajectories and then frozen. The full specification follows.

1. Public features

Tokenize text with [A-Za-z0-9]+, then lowercase and deduplicate. Let J denote Jaccard overlap, with J = 0 for two empty sets.

Feature groupInputs and transformations
Every checkpoint (12)Bias, four current-verdict indicators (SUCCESS, CONTINUE, PIVOT, UNKNOWN), an empty-answer indicator, J between the question and each of the answer, latest query, top title and top passage text, tanh(BM25/10), and min(c/8, 2). Here c counts “unresolved”, “missing”, “ambiguous”, “uncertain” and “not verified” in the raw verifier output.
After the first checkpoint (+9)Three previous-verdict indicators (SUCCESS, CONTINUE, PIVOT), an answer-change flag, J between current and previous answers, 1 − J for each of the query, top title and top passage text relative to the previous checkpoint, and tanh(ΔBM25/10), where ΔBM25 is current minus previous BM25. The answer-change flag compares stripped, lowercased strings.
Verifier interactionsMultiply each of the three known current-verdict indicators by each feature other than the bias and the current and previous verdict indicators. This gives 12 + 3 × 7 = 33 features at q1 and 21 + 3 × 13 = 60 thereafter.

2. Verifier

The actor receives the current conversation and the verifier prompt, followed by Current answer: {answer}. It returns one JSON object with keys verification, decision, justification, trajectory_summary and details. The decision is SUCCESS, CONTINUE or PIVOT. If JSON parsing fails, the parser checks for the quoted labels in that order and otherwise assigns UNKNOWN. Appendix D.4 reproduces the prompt verbatim, and the end of our next comment shows its key parts.

3. Training and development questions

Each training question yields one branch tree. Every setting scheduled 150 training questions, and 138 to 150 of them produced complete trees (below). Development trajectories are the out-of-fold trajectories of the same trees, so their counts are identical.

Training questions (trees)DeepSeek v4.1 FlashGLM-5.3 FlashGPT-6 Luna
MuSiQue147150150
HotpotQA150150150
2Wiki138150150

Every Table 1 setting uses the selected H4 design (five-query cap, α = 0.25, κ = 0.25), refitted on its own training trees and calibrated on their out-of-fold trajectories. For MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash, this is the 147-tree fit.

4. Operating offsets for Table 1

Each Table 1 operating point is set on development trajectories in three steps.

  • Candidates. Non-Stop offsets from −0.30 to 0.20 in steps of 0.01, plus 0.5 and 1.5; Stop scores zero.
  • Selection criterion. On development trajectories, we sort the fixed-offset policies by mean logical tokens and take the two adjacent offsets whose costs bracket the cost target. Ties favor the offset closest to zero, then the lower offset.
  • Assignment. The higher-cost offset is assigned to the fraction (target − lower cost)/(upper cost − lower cost) of questions by a deterministic hash of the question ID, and it stays fixed throughout that question.

(Added to the revised paper: Appendix D.2–D.5, Table 6.)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer kGb4 (2/2)

W3, Q2, Q3. Ablations of the backup penalty and lookahead depth

Both components help on the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions: the penalty adds +1.10 F1, and H4 adds +0.73 F1 over H2.

In the same setting, the grid is scored by five-fold task-level validation over the 147 training trees. We select α, κ and H by mean net utility, F1 − 0.025(Q − 1), where F1 is on a 0–1 scale and Q is the query count. The last column reports replay F1 at the selected H4 cost of 29.628k tokens, using linear interpolation where needed.

Configuration (α = 0.25)F1 (zero offset)Mean queriesMean logical tokensUtilityF1 @ 29.628k
H4, κ = 048.714.19030.865k0.407348.41
H2, κ = 0.2547.823.92028.938k0.405347.76
H3, κ = 0.2547.823.99329.461k0.403448.55
H4, κ = 0.25 (selected)48.554.01529.628k0.410248.55

Backup penalty. On the Table 1 questions of the same setting, κ = 0.25 gains +1.10 F1 [0.25, 2.20] over κ = 0 at nearly equal cost (14.704k vs. 14.838k).

Lookahead depth. In the development grid, a replayed offset brings H3 to exactly 29.628k, where it rises from 47.82 at zero offset to 48.55 F1 and follows the same trajectories as H4; H2 reaches 47.76 at that cost. On the same test questions, with both fits sharing the 147 trees, ridge and penalty, H4 scores 58.07 F1 at its measured 14.020k tokens versus 57.34 for H2 interpolated to that cost, a paired gain of +0.73 [0.18, 1.63].

(Added to the revised paper: Appendix E.2, Table 8.)

Q1. Why does TraceAhead's advantage disappear at some token budgets in Figure 2?

The extra budget mainly lets the fixed stopping rules recover answers on paths they had stopped too early. TraceAhead already continues such paths at the middle budget, so Quality Threshold catches up as the budget grows.

Figure 2, same settingValue
F1 gap over Quality Threshold at the Table 1 operating points2.8
F1 gap over Quality Threshold at 20.9k matched tokens0.9
Questions extending an identical query-and-evidence prefix at the higher budget: Quality Threshold vs. TraceAhead59% vs. 44%
Quality Threshold's middle-to-high F1 gain that comes from these extensions1.43 of 2.45

In other words, Quality Threshold needs the larger budget to reach answers that TraceAhead already obtains at the middle budget. This is why the gap is 2.8 F1 at the Table 1 operating points and narrows to 0.9 F1 at 20.9k tokens, where TraceAhead still leads.

(Added to the revised paper: Section 5.3.)

Verifier prompt for W2

The key parts of the verifier prompt are below. The user message is followed by a newline and Current answer: {answer}; Appendix D.4 gives it verbatim.

Now you are an AI Strategic Verifier. Your primary goal is to evaluate the above answer, assess the viability of the current problem-solving plan, and decide the best course of action: declare success, continue with the current plan, or pivot to a new one.

[... Step 1: verification analysis against each constraint of the question; Step 2: decision rules for SUCCESS, CONTINUE and PIVOT; Step 3: trajectory summary and decision-specific details. Full text in Appendix D.4 ...]

### **Output Requirement**

Your final output must be a single JSON object with the following structure. Do not add any text before or after this JSON block.

```json
{
  "verification": "Verification analysis",
  "decision": "SUCCESS | CONTINUE | PIVOT",
  "justification": "A concise explanation for your strategic decision. Why is it a success, a dead end, or a correctable error?",
  "trajectory_summary": "The informative trajectory summary.",
  "details": "A JSON object containing the additional details required by Step 3. For a SUCCESS decision, this can be an empty object {}."
}
```

We hope these additions answer your questions. If they resolve your concerns, we would be grateful if you would consider strengthening your support for the paper.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Have we addressed your concerns?

Dear Reviewer kGb4,

We thank you again for your positive assessment and for taking the time and effort to help improve our paper. We believe your key concerns were a learned non-myopic baseline, the implementation details, ablations of κ and H, and TraceAhead's advantage across token budgets in Figure 2. We addressed each of them, with new experiments for the baseline and the ablations:

  • W1. Learned non-myopic baseline. We added direct return regression, which learns history-dependent continuation value from the same features. At matched cost, TraceAhead leads it by +2.21 F1 with DeepSeek v4.1 Flash and by +2.58 F1 with GLM-5.3 Flash.
  • W2. Implementation details. The revised paper now specifies all features, the verbatim verifier prompt and schema, the training counts per setting and the offset rule.
  • W3, Q2 & Q3. Ablations of κ and H. On the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions, the backup penalty adds +1.10 F1 over κ = 0 at nearly equal cost, and H4 adds +0.73 F1 over H2.
  • Q1. Figure 2. At the higher budget, Quality Threshold extends an existing search path on 59% of questions, versus 44% for TraceAhead, which already continues such paths at the middle budget. The gap therefore narrows from 2.8 to 0.9 F1 at 20.9k tokens, where TraceAhead still leads.

These additions are in Section 5.3, Section 5.6 (Table 3) and Appendices D.2–D.5, E.1 and E.2.

As the author–reviewer discussion is about to end, we would be grateful to know whether our response resolves your questions.

If it does, we hope you will consider strengthening your support for our paper.

Thank you,

Authors

Reviewer_4zb1OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a controller called TraceAhead, which bulids a non-myopic controller for a fixed LLM search actor. During training, it runs alternative actions from shared checkpoints, measures immediate answer gain minus query cost, and backs up future continuation value to earlier actions. At test time, it follows one path and chooses Stop, Continue, Deepen, or Pivot without branching. It is tested on MuSiQue, HotpotQA, 2WikiMultihopQA cross three different actors.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper has a clear problem formulation. It clearly defines search control, immediate value, continuation value, and the finite-horizon decision process. The connection between training-time branching and inference-time single-path control is easy to understand.

  2. The experiments cover multiple models and datasets. The ablations and cost-matched results show both performance gains and lower token usage.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty compared with prior learned search controllers. Learning when to continue searching and how to allocate search budget has been studied in related work, such as Adaptive Information Control for Search-Augmented LLM Reasoning[EMNLP2026] https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.01672. This paper does not compare with related works' methods.

  2. The controller is trained for each benchmark-actor pair. The paper does not show whether a controller can transfer to a new benchmark or an new actor.

Questions for authors
  1. As the training datasets are not very large, does the controller observe enough of the search history to make the process approximately Markovian? How does it distinguish states with similar surface features but different future search opportunities?

  2. The same as Weakness-2. The authors should test a shared controller or zero-shot/few-shot transfer performance.

  3. How to measure whether the train dataset is enough to get a good controller? The paper reports downstream task results and a suffix analysis, but does not clearly report the relationship between the controller performance and the training data. Please report these controller-level metrics and show how controller quality changes with the amount of branch data.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4zb1 (1/2)

Thank you for your review. We answer your questions with three new experiments. Fitted with DeepSeek v4.1 Flash and run zero-shot with GLM-5.3 Flash, TraceAhead beats transferred Myopic by +2.54 F1 [1.31, 3.79] at the Middle operating point and by +3.53 [2.50, 4.57] at High, at matched token use. Fitted on MuSiQue, it gains +1.54 F1 [0.52, 2.73] on 2Wiki at matched cost. With only 37 training trees, TraceAhead scores 1.10 F1 points [0.10, 2.08] above Myopic at matched cost.

W1. Novelty and comparison with DeepControl

We agree that deciding when to continue searching has been studied. The revised Section 2 now discusses the work you cite, Adaptive Information Control for Search-Augmented LLM Reasoning (DeepControl; Xiong et al., EMNLP 2026). In short, DeepControl trains the search LLM, whereas TraceAhead keeps the LLM frozen and learns a separate controller:

What is trainedWho decides at test time
DeepControlThe search LLM. Retrieval utility guides the actor during reinforcement learning.The trained actor, which controls retrieval autonomously
TraceAheadA separate controller. The actor stays frozen, and the controller learns from alternative search actions executed from the same checkpoint.The controller, which chooses when to stop and which direction to search; the frozen actor writes the queries along a single path

What TraceAhead adds is a value estimate for a frozen actor. It scores each action by its net value relative to stopping, including gains that appear only after further searches. It can therefore credit a query that reveals useful evidence before the answer changes. In the training branches, 189 of 1,029 eligible actions had nonpositive immediate net gain and a positive continuation among the sampled descendants (Figure 7).

TraceAhead is also lightweight. It trains only a linear controller with 393 coefficients on public history features, never updates the actor, and follows a single search path at test time without branch expansion. For MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash, collecting its 147 training trees took 5,880 logical model calls. This also determines where each method applies. DeepControl updates the actor with reinforcement learning and therefore needs an open-weight actor. TraceAhead needs only the actor's inputs and outputs: GPT-6 Luna is available only through an API, and in its three Table 1 settings TraceAhead has higher F1 than all three controls.

To isolate the effect of the controller, we compare learned controllers on the same frozen actor, corpus, branches and features. On MuSiQue at matched logical-token cost, TraceAhead leads independently tuned Myopic by +1.73 F1 [0.64, 3.18] and direct return regression by +2.21 [0.94, 3.73].

(Added to the revised paper: Section 2; Section 5.6, Table 3; Appendix E.1, Table 7.)

W2 & Q2. Zero-shot transfer across actors and benchmarks

A controller fitted in one setting transfers without refitting, and TraceAhead keeps its advantage over the equally transferred Myopic.

We fitted the five-query TraceAhead and Myopic controllers on the 147 branch trees of this setting and calibrated both on MuSiQue. The fitted parameters and source operating settings then stay fixed, with no target-side fitting or calibration. For actor transfer, we switch to GLM-5.3 Flash and evaluate on held-out MuSiQue questions; for benchmark transfer, we keep DeepSeek v4.1 Flash and evaluate on previously unused 2Wiki questions. Where the measured costs differ, Myopic is interpolated to TraceAhead's measured cost.

TransferPointTokensTraceAhead F1Myopic F1ΔF1 [95% CI]
DeepSeek v4.1 Flash → GLM-5.3 Flash (MuSiQue)Middle13.52k61.8159.28+2.54 [1.31, 3.79]
DeepSeek v4.1 Flash → GLM-5.3 Flash (MuSiQue)High16.45k65.7162.18+3.53 [2.50, 4.57]
MuSiQue → 2Wiki (DeepSeek v4.1 Flash)High16.43k78.4576.91+1.54 [0.52, 2.73]

(Added to the revised paper: Section 5.6, Table 3; Appendix E.4, Table 10.)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4zb1 (2/2)

Q1. Does the controller observe enough of the search history to make the process approximately Markovian? How does it distinguish states with similar surface features but different future search opportunities?

The controller does not rely on a Markov assumption about a latent search state. The decision process is defined over the full observable history (Eq. 5): the question, previous queries and evidence, the current answer, and route and verifier outputs. It is therefore Markov in that history by construction, and the only approximation lies in the compact feature summary that the heads read.

With limited training data, the controller is small: 393 coefficients over public history features. During fitting, the penalty Γ (Eq. 9) is larger in feature directions with little training support, so earlier actions are not credited with poorly supported continuations.

The summary can still separate states that look similar at the surface. It encodes not only the current answer but also the previous verdict, answer changes and retrieval novelty, so two checkpoints with the same current answer can receive different scores. We test directly whether the summary captures different future opportunities. In independent suffix executions, we force an action from a frozen checkpoint, measure the future net return after that action, and rank the predictions within each stage and action. The top predicted quintile has 8.9 [2.1, 16.8] F1 points more future net return than the bottom quintile (Figure 3). Q3 below measures the same property at the controller level.

Q3. How to measure whether the train dataset is enough to get a good controller?

We measure this with two controller-level metrics, value correlation with hindsight returns and stop/continue agreement with hindsight labels, together with matched-cost F1 against Myopic.

Learning curve. We fit both policies on nested subsets of 37, 74, 110 and 147 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash trees, sharing features, stage/action heads and ridge strength at each size. We replay both on held-out MuSiQue questions whose supporting passages do not overlap the fitting pool, averaging F1 at matched costs of 16k, 22k and 28k logical tokens. The first three rows average four fixed subsets per training size; the last row uses the full 147-tree fit.

Training treesTraceAhead F1Myopic F1ΔF1 [95% CI]Value correlation r [95% CI]
3746.6945.59+1.10 [0.10, 2.08]0.160 [0.126, 0.193]
7448.5547.22+1.33 [0.21, 2.39]0.203 [0.162, 0.243]
11049.0547.21+1.84 [0.58, 3.01]0.220 [0.175, 0.264]
14750.0148.54+1.47 [0.60, 2.88]0.239 [0.190, 0.287]

Controller quality improves steadily with branch data, and the advantage over Myopic is already present at 37 trees. With 37 trees, a quarter of the training data, TraceAhead improves over Myopic by 1.10 F1 [0.10, 2.08]. From 37 to 147 trees, its F1 rises by 3.33 [1.26, 4.88] and its value correlation by 0.079 [0.052, 0.107], including a further 0.019 [0.010, 0.029] from 110 to 147 trees.

Pearson r compares predicted action values with hindsight net returns on the recorded branches; intervals resample question groups sharing supporting passages 20,000 times and rematch cost in every draw. For scale, collecting the 147 trees used 5,880 logical model calls and 15.84M logical tokens.

Stop/continue agreement. On checkpoints from additional trees in the same setting, the hindsight label is Continue when a recorded continuation improves answer F1 by more than its extra query cost. At 12.090k tokens, TraceAhead agrees with this label on 80.47% of checkpoints, versus 75.64% for Myopic interpolated to the same cost. The paired gain is 4.83 pp [2.96, 6.80].

(Added to the revised paper: Section 5.5; Section 5.6, Table 3; Appendix E.3, Table 9.)

We hope these additions address your concerns. If they do, we would be grateful if you would consider updating your rating.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Have we addressed your concerns?

Dear Reviewer 4zb1,

We thank you again for taking the time and effort to help improve our paper. We believe your key concerns were novelty and the comparison with related methods such as DeepControl, transfer to a new actor or benchmark, whether the process is approximately Markovian, and whether the training data are sufficient. We addressed each of them, with new experiments for the comparison, transfer and training-data questions:

  • W1. Novelty and comparison with related methods. DeepControl (Xiong et al., EMNLP 2026) trains the search LLM, whereas TraceAhead learns a separate controller for a frozen actor, so it also applies to API-only actors such as GPT-6 Luna. To isolate the effect of the controller, we compare learned controllers on the same frozen actor and branch data. On the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions at matched cost, TraceAhead leads independently tuned Myopic by +1.73 F1 and direct return regression by +2.21 F1.
  • W2 & Q2. Transfer. Without refitting, a controller fitted with DeepSeek v4.1 Flash leads equally transferred Myopic with GLM-5.3 Flash by +2.54 F1 at the Middle operating point and +3.53 F1 at High, and a controller fitted on MuSiQue leads by +1.54 F1 on 2Wiki.
  • Q1. Markov property. The decision process is defined over the full observable history, and in independent suffix executions the controller's top predicted quintile has 8.9 F1 points more future net return than its bottom quintile.
  • Q3. Training data. With only 37 training trees, TraceAhead already leads Myopic by +1.10 F1, and its stop/continue agreement with hindsight labels is 80.47% versus 75.64% for Myopic.

These additions are in Section 2, Section 5.5, Section 5.6 (Table 3) and Appendices E.1, E.3 and E.4. As the author–reviewer discussion is about to end, we would be grateful for an opportunity to address any pending concerns you can point us to.

If these additions resolve your concerns, we would be very grateful if you would consider updating your rating.

Thank you,

Authors

Reviewer_GgXGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TraceAhead is a value-based controller for non-myopic control of LLM search agents. It learns history-dependent action values from branched training executions through regularized backward fitting, while keeping the LLM actor fixed and following a single search path at inference time. Across three multi-hop QA benchmarks and three LLM actors, it reports higher answer F1 than Myopic, SA Mean, and Quality Threshold at development-selected operating points with similar logical-token use. The gains over Myopic range from 0.4 to 8.2 F1 points.

Critical strengths
  1. The stop-relative formulation provides a clear basis for deciding both when to stop and where to search. By evaluating immediate answer improvement together with continuation value, it can credit an action that exposes useful evidence without improving the current answer. Branched training executions hold the preceding history fixed, while regularized backward fitting propagates later gains to earlier decisions. The resulting controller has 393 fitted mean coefficients and uses a fixed LLM actor; deployment follows a single search path without online branch expansion.

  2. The experiments cover three benchmarks and three LLM actors, with Myopic and SA Mean providing useful controls for continuation value. At the reported operating points with similar logical-token use, TraceAhead improves F1 over all three controls in all nine settings. On MuSiQue with GLM-5.3 Flash, it reaches 58.2 F1, versus 50.0 for Myopic, 52.6 for SA Mean, and 55.7 for Quality Threshold. The component comparisons support adaptive stopping across all three benchmarks. Independent suffix executions also show a pooled future net return difference of 8.9 F1 points between the highest and lowest prediction quintiles, with a 95 percent interval of 2.1 to 16.8. The paper also reports curve crossings at other costs and inconclusive intervals in two suffix strata.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The comparisons with Myopic and SA Mean support the use of continuation value, but the contribution of the backup penalty remains unclear. The development grid includes zero penalty and shorter horizons, yet their performance is not reported. Myopic also uses the ridge regularizer selected for Full. Sharing the regularizer is necessary for the matched linear decomposition, but a separate comparison with an independently selected ridge precision would show whether the gain persists when Myopic is tuned on its own.

  2. The public features summarize answer and evidence overlap, verifier uncertainty, and retrieval novelty. The paper gives dimensions of 33 and 60, but does not specify the complete feature mappings or the verifier output schema. These details are needed to reproduce the stage/action heads. The 147 complete training trees are reported for MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash; it is unclear whether the same training question count was used in the other settings.

Questions for authors
  1. For the MuSiQue development grid, what results were obtained with zero backup penalty and horizons H2 and H3 at comparable mean logical token use? Is a result available with the Myopic ridge precision selected independently?

  2. Please provide the complete public feature definitions, verifier prompt and output schema, and training and development question counts for each setting. The operating offsets are selected on development trajectories; what candidate offsets and selection criterion were used for Table 1?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer GgXG (1/2)

Thank you for your careful review. You asked for (i) the zero-penalty and shorter-horizon results from the development grid at comparable token use, (ii) Myopic with an independently selected ridge precision, and (iii) complete feature, verifier, count and offset details. In short, on the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions, the backup penalty adds +1.10 F1, H4 adds +0.73 F1 over H2, and TraceAhead still leads independently tuned Myopic by +1.73 F1.

W1 & Q1. Backup penalty, horizon, and independently tuned Myopic

Removing the backup penalty or shortening the horizon to H2 lowers F1 at comparable token use, and Myopic with its own ridge precision still trails TraceAhead. We first show the development grid used to select κ and H, then the matched-cost results on the Table 1 test questions.

Development grid. In the same setting, the grid is scored by five-fold task-level validation over the 147 training trees. Selection maximizes mean out-of-fold net utility, F1 − 0.025(Q − 1), with F1 on a 0–1 scale and Q the query count. Across 48 non-myopic configurations, α = 0.25, κ = 0.25 and H4 give the highest utility (0.4102). The last column reports replay F1 at the selected H4 cost of 29.628k tokens, using linear interpolation where needed.

Configuration (α = 0.25)F1 (zero offset)Mean queriesMean logical tokensUtilityF1 @ 29.628k
H4, κ = 048.714.19030.865k0.407348.41
H2, κ = 0.2547.823.92028.938k0.405347.76
H3, κ = 0.2547.823.99329.461k0.403448.55
H4, κ = 0.25 (selected)48.554.01529.628k0.410248.55

Zero backup penalty. On the Table 1 questions of the same setting, κ = 0.25 scores 60.62 F1 at 14.704k tokens versus 59.52 at 14.838k with κ = 0. That is a paired gain of +1.10 [0.25, 2.20].

Shorter horizons. In the development grid, a replayed offset brings H3 to exactly 29.628k, where it rises from 47.82 at zero offset to 48.55 F1 and follows the same trajectories as H4; H2 reaches 47.76 at that cost. On the same test questions, with both fits sharing the 147 trees, ridge and penalty, H4 scores 58.07 F1 at its measured 14.020k tokens versus 57.34 for H2 interpolated to that cost, a paired gain of +0.73 [0.18, 1.63].

Myopic with its own ridge precision. TraceAhead's gain persists when Myopic is tuned on its own. We refit Myopic with an independently selected ridge precision. At TraceAhead's 14.704k tokens on the same questions, TraceAhead scores 60.62 F1 versus 58.89 for independently tuned Myopic, a paired gain of +1.73 [0.64, 3.18].

(Added to the revised paper: Section 5.6, Table 3; Appendix E.1–E.2, Tables 7–8.)

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer GgXG (2/2)

W2 & Q2. Features, verifier, counts, and offsets

Thank you for asking for these details; the revised paper now specifies all of them. Below we give the complete feature definitions, the verifier interface, the number of training trees per setting, and the procedure that sets the operating offsets.

1. Public features

Tokenize text with [A-Za-z0-9]+, then lowercase and deduplicate. Let J denote Jaccard overlap, with J = 0 for two empty sets.

Feature groupInputs and transformations
Every checkpoint (12)Bias, four current-verdict indicators (SUCCESS, CONTINUE, PIVOT, UNKNOWN), an empty-answer indicator, J between the question and each of the answer, latest query, top title and top passage text, tanh(BM25/10), and min(c/8, 2). Here c counts “unresolved”, “missing”, “ambiguous”, “uncertain” and “not verified” in the raw verifier output.
After the first checkpoint (+9)Three previous-verdict indicators (SUCCESS, CONTINUE, PIVOT), an answer-change flag, J between current and previous answers, 1 − J for each of the query, top title and top passage text relative to the previous checkpoint, and tanh(ΔBM25/10), where ΔBM25 is current minus previous BM25. The answer-change flag compares stripped, lowercased strings.
Verifier interactionsMultiply each of the three known current-verdict indicators by each feature other than the bias and the current and previous verdict indicators. This gives 12 + 3 × 7 = 33 features at q1 and 21 + 3 × 13 = 60 thereafter.

2. Verifier

The actor receives the current conversation and the verifier prompt, followed by Current answer: {answer}. It returns one JSON object with keys verification, decision, justification, trajectory_summary and details. The decision is SUCCESS, CONTINUE or PIVOT. If JSON parsing fails, the parser checks for the quoted labels in that order and otherwise assigns UNKNOWN. Appendix D.4 reproduces the prompt verbatim. Its key parts are below; the user message is followed by a newline and Current answer: {answer}.

Now you are an AI Strategic Verifier. Your primary goal is to evaluate the above answer, assess the viability of the current problem-solving plan, and decide the best course of action: declare success, continue with the current plan, or pivot to a new one.

[... Step 1: verification analysis against each constraint of the question; Step 2: decision rules for SUCCESS, CONTINUE and PIVOT; Step 3: trajectory summary and decision-specific details. Full text in Appendix D.4 ...]

### **Output Requirement**

Your final output must be a single JSON object with the following structure. Do not add any text before or after this JSON block.

```json
{
  "verification": "Verification analysis",
  "decision": "SUCCESS | CONTINUE | PIVOT",
  "justification": "A concise explanation for your strategic decision. Why is it a success, a dead end, or a correctable error?",
  "trajectory_summary": "The informative trajectory summary.",
  "details": "A JSON object containing the additional details required by Step 3. For a SUCCESS decision, this can be an empty object {}."
}
```

3. Training and development questions

Each training question yields one branch tree. Every setting scheduled 150 training questions, and 138 to 150 of them produced complete trees (below). Development trajectories are the out-of-fold trajectories of the same trees, so their counts are identical.

Training questions (trees)DeepSeek v4.1 FlashGLM-5.3 FlashGPT-6 Luna
MuSiQue147150150
HotpotQA150150150
2Wiki138150150

Every Table 1 setting uses the selected H4 design (five-query cap, α = 0.25, κ = 0.25), refitted on its own training trees and calibrated on their out-of-fold trajectories. For MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash, this is the 147-tree fit.

4. Operating offsets for Table 1

Each Table 1 operating point is set on development trajectories in three steps.

  • Candidates. Non-Stop offsets from −0.30 to 0.20 in steps of 0.01, plus 0.5 and 1.5; Stop scores zero.
  • Selection criterion. On development trajectories, we sort the fixed-offset policies by mean logical tokens and take the two adjacent offsets whose costs bracket the cost target. Ties favor the offset closest to zero, then the lower offset.
  • Assignment. The higher-cost offset is assigned to the fraction (target − lower cost)/(upper cost − lower cost) of questions by a deterministic hash of the question ID, and it stays fixed throughout that question.

(Added to the revised paper: Appendix D.2–D.5, Table 6.)

We hope these results address your concerns. If they do, we would be grateful if you would consider updating your rating. We are happy to provide any further detail.

I appreciate the authors’ response and their answers to my questions. However, I still believe my initial overall rating reflects my assessment of the paper, and therefore I would like to keep it.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We thank all reviewers for their careful reading and concrete questions. We are encouraged that the reviewers found the formulation, which values continued search relative to stopping, clear (GgXG, 4zb1); appreciated that TraceAhead learns from branched training data yet runs as a small controller on a single search path with a fixed actor (GgXG, 4zb1, kGb4); and recognized its consistent gains over all three controls across the nine benchmark–actor settings (GgXG, kGb4).

The table below summarizes the new evidence. Brackets give paired 95% bootstrap intervals computed from unrounded means, and comparisons are at matched logical-token cost unless noted. Test questions are disjoint from the questions used for fitting and calibration.

QuestionReviewersNew evidence
Amount of branch data4zb1With 37 trees, TraceAhead leads Myopic by +1.10 [0.10, 2.08]. From 37 to 147 trees, its F1 rises by 3.33 [1.26, 4.88].
Backup penalty and horizonGgXG, kGb4On the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions, the backup penalty (κ = 0.25 vs. κ = 0) adds +1.10 F1 [0.25, 2.20] at similar cost, and H4 improves over H2 by +0.73 [0.18, 1.63]. In the development grid, κ = 0.25 and H4 have the highest out-of-fold net utility.
Budget behaviorkGb4At higher cost, Quality Threshold extends an existing search path on 59% of questions, versus 44% for TraceAhead.
Controller-level accuracy4zb1Stop/continue agreement with hindsight labels: 80.47% vs. 75.64% for Myopic, +4.83 pp [2.96, 6.80]
Independently tuned MyopicGgXGOn the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions, TraceAhead still leads by +1.73 F1 [0.64, 3.18].
Learned non-myopic baselinekGb4TraceAhead leads direct return regression by +2.21 [0.94, 3.73] (DeepSeek v4.1 Flash, Table 1 questions) and +2.58 [0.91, 4.61] (GLM-5.3 Flash).
Related work4zb1Mechanism comparison with DeepControl (Xiong et al., EMNLP 2026)
ReproducibilityGgXG, kGb4Complete features, verbatim verifier prompt and schema, training counts, offset grid and selection rule
Zero-shot transfer4zb1DeepSeek v4.1 Flash → GLM-5.3 Flash: +2.54 F1 [1.31, 3.79] at the Middle operating point and +3.53 [2.50, 4.57] at High, over equally transferred Myopic. MuSiQue → 2Wiki: +1.54 [0.52, 2.73].

All new results and details are marked in blue in the revised paper.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of the discussion

We thank the AC and the reviewers for their engagement. The reviewers found the formulation clear (GgXG, 4zb1); valued that TraceAhead learns from branched executions in training, yet needs neither actor fine-tuning nor branching at inference (GgXG, kGb4); and noted that it improves F1 over all three controls in all nine benchmark–actor settings (GgXG, kGb4). During the discussion, Reviewer 4zb1 stated that our responses addressed their main concerns and raised the rating.

The table below summarizes our responses. The new results are collected in Table 3 (Section 5.6) and Appendix E.

ConcernReviewersOur response
Backup penalty and horizonGgXG, kGb4On the Table 1 MuSiQue/DeepSeek v4.1 Flash questions, the backup penalty adds +1.10 F1 over κ = 0, and H4 improves over H2 by +0.73.
Learned baselinesGgXG, kGb4TraceAhead leads independently tuned Myopic by +1.73 F1, and direct return regression by +2.21 (DeepSeek v4.1 Flash) and +2.58 (GLM-5.3 Flash).
ReproducibilityGgXG, kGb4Complete features, verbatim verifier prompt and schema, training counts, offset grid and selection rule
Related work4zb1Unlike DeepControl, which trains the search LLM, TraceAhead keeps the actor fixed and learns a separate controller, so it also applies to API-only actors.
Zero-shot transfer4zb1Without refitting, TraceAhead leads equally transferred Myopic by +2.54 and +3.53 F1 with GLM-5.3 Flash, and by +1.54 on 2WikiMultihopQA.
Amount of branch data4zb1With 37 trees, a quarter of the training data, TraceAhead leads Myopic by +1.10 F1.
Budget behavior in Figure 2kGb4At higher cost, Quality Threshold extends an existing search path on 59% of questions, versus 44% for TraceAhead, which already continues such paths at the middle budget.

All new results and details are marked in blue in the revised paper.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.