- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
I find this an interesting and practically relevant research direction. Prior work has already demonstrated benefits from combining unimodal information with cross-modal interactions, providing empirical support for the general approach. My main concern is therefore not whether the direction is worthwhile, but how much new understanding this paper adds. The predictor composition and training objective are closely related to existing methods, and the methodological novelty appears limited. The grade-specific observations are useful, but the current analysis does not yet establish a new mechanism or principle beyond what is already understood about ensemble training. At present, I view the paper more as a valuable application and validation of established ideas than as a sufficiently developed novel contribution.
Critical strengths
Table 2 and Figures 1, 3, and 4 show that a multimodal model with higher overall accuracy can recognize fewer moderate-to-severe cases than a physiology-only predictor. The grade-specific recall and paired prediction changes make this discrepancy concrete. This is a useful contribution because it shows why an apparent improvement in overall performance may not reflect improvement across disease grades. The analysis provides more insight than another aggregate accuracy comparison alone.
Critical weaknesses
- Figure 2 appear to have been prepared with insufficient care, and the overall workflow is not clearly illustrated. CBF’s three-predictor design and combined individual–ensemble supervision have close precedents. The paper currently reads more as an application of established ensemble ideas to fatty liver grading than as a new severity-modeling mechanism or a new empirical principle. My concern is not whether the direction is effective, but how far this study advances the existing understanding.
- The ablation confounds collaborative supervision with additional fine-tuning, and does not test whether class reweighting or simple output correction produces comparable gains. It therefore remains unclear whether the improvement in moderate-to-severe recall reflects better multimodal cooperation, additional optimization, or a shift in class-prediction preferences.
Questions for authors
- Please compare CBF with I2M2 using the same encoders, initialization checkpoints, and fine-tuning budget. An additional product-aggregation variant with the same individual-branch supervision as CBF would separate the effects of aggregation and auxiliary supervision. This would establish whether the benefit comes from CBF’s specific training configuration or from the existing three-predictor framework, rather than relying only on a descriptive distinction from prior work. The difference between I2M2’s product aggregation and CBF’s probability averaging should be preserved and explicitly documented.
- Starting from identical checkpoints, compare individual-branch cross-entropy only, averaged-prediction cross-entropy only, and full CBF. Match optimization steps and selection rules, and control the overall loss scale and tuning budget. Also report continued fine-tuning of the joint predictor alone. The key question is whether CBF consistently outperforms these additionally trained controls—not merely a frozen average—and whether both loss terms are necessary.