- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ST-Prune dynamically selects spatiotemporal training samples using prediction error heterogeneity, applies stationarity-aware reweighting, and finishes with full-data training. Experiments report favorable accuracy-runtime trade-offs across multiple datasets, architectures, and model scales.
Critical strengths
The scoring rule addresses a limitation of average loss pruning: localized forecasting errors can be obscured by otherwise easy predictions.
Evaluation across datasets, backbones, optimizers, and a family of foundation models provides useful evidence of practical applicability.
Critical weaknesses
The claimed unbiasedness is unsupported: the weights in Eqs. (5)–(6) do not generally correct the stated inclusion probabilities. Appendix C.2 also disclaims the guarantee asserted in Section 4.2.
Full data annealing produces the largest ablation benefit, but equivalent treatment of the baselines is unclear. Comparisons using fixed epochs therefore leave the pruning-specific contribution and time-to-target advantage insufficiently established.
Questions for authors
Please reconcile the unbiasedness claim with Appendix C.2 and specify the actual sampling probabilities and weighted training objective.
Do random pruning and InfoBatch receive identical full data annealing, and does ST-Prune remain faster at reaching matched validation accuracy?