- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces EvoHarnessBench, a benchmark measuring agents' adaptability to an evolving harness along 3 capability axes: tools, skills and specialist agents, along with its scalable construction pipeline. The benchmark evaluates both deployment robustness and self-evolving adaptation, measuring task performance, retention of previously acquired capabilities, and adaptation to newly introduced capabilities. Experiments across multiple agent systems and adaptation methods reveal harness-induced forgetting, inconsistent adaptation gains, and potential trade-offs between retention and adaptation.
Critical strengths
-
The paper introduces a diagnostic framework for evaluating agents under evolving harnesses, going beyond conventional static benchmarks to characterize how capability expansion affects task performance, retention, and adaptation. This provides a valuable diagnostic perspective on agent robustness and self-evolving capabilities.
-
The paper proposes an automated method to construct evolving harness benchmarks from existing agent benchmarks completely without LLM. By leveraging existing task annotations and deterministically deriving capability requirements from procedural and tool structures, the pipeline enables cost-effective, scalable and reproducible benchmark construction.
-
The paper presents extensive experiments across 3 harness evolution axes, multiple agent architectures, and diverse self-evolving adaptation methods. The evaluation includes detailed transfer analyses, ablation studies, and investigations of failure mechanisms, providing a thorough empirical characterization of agent behavior under harness evolution.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited validation of capability annotations. Although the deterministic construction pipeline is a strength, the reliability of the derived capability annotations is not sufficiently validated. In particular, skill annotations rely on heuristic matching between procedural content and task requirements, while specialist agents are constructed by grouping tools based on their associated entities. These annotations may not accurately reflect the capabilities actually required to solve each task. This raises concerns about the validity of the task-specific references and the interpretation of capability-related analyses.
Questions for authors
- Have the authors independently validated the accuracy of the automatically derived skill and agent annotations? How might annotation errors affect the reliability of the benchmark?
- How sensitive are the main findings to the frequency-based capability release order? Would alternative release schedules lead to similar forgetting and adaptation patterns?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer isCr: Part 2
Q1. “Have the authors independently validated the accuracy of the automatically derived skill and agent annotations? How might annotation errors affect the reliability of the benchmark?”
Thank you for this important question. Our deterministic construction is grounded in source-benchmark signals (Sec. 3.3): tool annotations are inherited directly, skills are matched to verifier-checked outcomes, and specialist agents are derived from tool-ownership mappings. Appendix F further validates specialist tool coverage and disjointness.
We acknowledge that annotation errors could be an influence factor, and we have clarified these limitations in Sections 3.1, 3.3, and 4 (Evaluation Setup). Importantly, final task success remains determined by the original executable verifiers, independently of the capability annotations. We will further assess annotation quality through the manual audit described in W1. Below we empirically demonstrate the quality of our constructed dataset.
Additional experiment on validity of our constructed skills. We evaluate SAS under four conditions: empty skills, retrievable stage-level oracle skills, shuffled direct injection, and matched task-specific oracle skill injection (Appendix J.1, Table J.2). Matched injection achieves the highest overall verifier score (65.6), outperforming empty skills (61.6), retrievable skills (64.3), and shuffled injection (61.5). The improvement is particularly notable on ITSM (54.3 vs. 47.1 with empty skills). These results suggest that directly providing task-matched skills can improve verifier-level performance, highlighting the importance of effective skill selection and utilization.
Table A. Verifier score (0–100) across SAS skill-access conditions, for EvoHarnessBench-EoG, with Codex-GPT-5.
| Condition | CSM | HR | ITSM | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Empty skills | 73.9 ± 3.6 | 62.6 ± 4.5 | 47.1 ± 4.8 | 61.6 ± 2.5 |
| Retrievable stage-level oracle skills | 76.7 ± 2.7 | 65.5 ± 1.9 | 49.6 ± 6.1 | 64.3 ± 2.6 |
| Shuffled direct injection | 74.3 ± 2.2 | 61.9 ± 2.2 | 48.0 ± 4.8 | 61.5 ± 1.7 |
| Matched direct injection | 78.5 ± 1.8 | 64.7 ± 2.9 | 54.3 ± 5.6 | 65.6 ± 1.1 |
Q2. “How sensitive are the main findings to the frequency-based capability release order? Would alternative release schedules lead to similar forgetting and adaptation patterns?”
Thank you for this suggestion. Our frequency-based core-to-tail release schedule (Sec. 3.2) provides a controlled approximation of real-world capability growth (Fig. 2). We intentionally adopt additive expansion, keeping previously released capabilities and task requirements unchanged to isolate harness-induced forgetting. We have explicitly acknowledged the limitations of the frequency-based release ordering in Section 3.2, including its coupling of stage, catalog size, and capability specialization. As discussed in Section 5 (Conclusion) in the revision, we leave alternative release schedules and non-monotonic capability changes for future work.
Appreciate your response. I prefer to maintain my rating.
Response to Reviewer isCr: Part 1
Thank you for your constructive review. We appreciate your recognition of our
"valuable diagnostic perspective on agent robustness and self-evolving capabilities", the"cost-effective, scalable and reproducible benchmark construction"without LLM involvement, and our"extensive experiments"across three harness evolution axes, agent architectures, and adaptation methods, providing a"thorough empirical characterization of agent behavior under harness evolution."We address your comments below.W1. “Limited validation of capability annotations. Although the deterministic construction pipeline is a strength, the reliability of the derived capability annotations is not sufficiently validated. In particular, skill annotations rely on heuristic matching between procedural content and task requirements, while specialist agents are constructed by grouping tools based on their associated entities. These annotations may not accurately reflect the capabilities actually required to solve each task. This raises concerns about the validity of the task-specific references and the interpretation of capability-related analyses.”
Thank you for raising this comment. We address annotation validity at three levels.
1. The annotations are grounded in source-benchmark information. Our deterministic pipeline preserves the original tasks, environments, and executable verifiers (
Sec. 3.2). Tool annotations come directly from the source benchmarks. Skills are extracted from procedural descriptions and matched to verifier-checked outcomes for EOG, or task specifications and software requirements for ALE (Sec. 3.3, Appendix E). Specialist agents are derived from tool-ownership mappings, with coverage and disjointness checked inAppendix F.For example, EOG-CSM task
task_20251210_183114_382_99ba2325_071a72abasks the agent to close a case and create a knowledge article documenting its resolution:This example shows a traceable link between annotations and task outcomes. As stated in
Section 3.3, the annotations identify relevant skills without claiming necessity, sufficiency, or uniqueness.2. Direct injection provides evidence that the task-specific matched skills are effective. We inject the matched skill content directly into the task prompt, removing the need for retrieval. The shuffled control supplies the same number of non-matching skills with approximately the same context length.
Table A. Verifier score (0–100) across SAS skill-access conditions, for EvoHarnessBench-EoG, with Codex-GPT-5.
Matched injection improves verifier score over shuffled injection in all three domains, by 4.04 points overall. This supports the relevance of the extracted skills and their task associations.
3. Low invocation does not imply invalid annotations. Our benchmark provides skills for on-demand retrieval, leaving the agent to decide whether to read them. An unread skill therefore provides no direct evidence about its usefulness. Invocation also varies across models and adaptation methods:
Fig. 5andAppendix J.1report 82% for task-specific GPT-5.5 Codex and 31% for task-specific GEPA, under their respective library denominators. Direct injection complements this analysis by removing the retrieval decision.Finally, we clarify that task-specific annotations define controlled references, not performance upper bounds. We will also report a sampled manual audit of skill associations and specialist-agent mappings in the camera-ready version.