W1. The geometric evaluation may not fully establish genuine 3D consistency.
A major concern is that the primary geometric evaluation relies on learned reconstruction and correspondence estimation, rather than independent ground-truth 3D geometry.
Specifically, the proposed token selection uses the TTT3R geometry model, while reconstruction-based evaluation relies on VGGT. Although these are different models, both rely on learned geometric priors and may exhibit correlated systematic biases.
Furthermore, lower reprojection or epipolar errors do not necessarily imply that the generated video follows the intended camera trajectory or reconstructs the correct underlying scene geometry.
For example, a model that produces smaller camera movements or more conservative viewpoint changes may achieve lower geometric errors without genuinely improving its ability to model complex 3D scenes.
The current evaluation does not sufficiently disentangle geometric consistency from camera-motion fidelity.
Additional evaluations of camera trajectory accuracy, independent geometric correctness, and human-perceived spatial consistency would substantially strengthen the central claims.
W2. Significant inference overhead despite the training-free formulation.
The training-free nature of Token Forcing is presented as an important practical advantage. However, Appendix E explicitly states that the proposed method approximately doubles video generation time under the reported experimental configuration.
This overhead arises from decoding intermediate predictions, executing the recurrent 3D reconstruction model, and performing additional generator passes to construct the injected KV features.
Although avoiding retraining is valuable, inference efficiency is itself a critical consideration in autoregressive and streaming video generation.
The paper does not provide a detailed runtime breakdown or comparisons under matched inference-time computational budgets.
For example, it remains unclear whether spending the same additional computation on more denoising steps, expanded temporal context, or alternative test-time refinement strategies could achieve comparable geometric improvements.
A systematic evaluation of the geometric-quality versus computational-cost trade-off is necessary to establish the practical benefit of Token Forcing.
W3. Limited generalization beyond static scenes.
SceneLongBench contains 100 static indoor and outdoor scenes in which only the camera moves. While this controlled setup is appropriate for evaluating cross-view reconstruction consistency, it covers only a restricted subset of long-video generation scenarios.
Real-world long videos frequently contain moving objects, dynamic occlusions, non-rigid deformations, object interactions, and evolving scene states.
In such cases, reconstruction confidence may reflect the difficulty of modeling dynamic content rather than the reliability of its consistency with historical geometry.
Consequently, the proposed token selection mechanism might preferentially preserve static background regions while underrepresenting moving objects or newly appearing scene elements.
Although the paper includes experiments on motion-rich prompts, these evaluations focus primarily on VBench scores and do not directly measure geometric consistency in dynamic scenes.
Therefore, the current results convincingly support the approach for static-scene camera-motion generation, but provide limited evidence for its general applicability to dynamic long-form video generation.
W4. Insufficient validation of token reliability and incomplete isolation of injection design choices.
The proposed method assumes that high reconstruction confidence and strong state attention identify tokens that are geometrically consistent with previously generated content.
However, high reconstruction confidence does not necessarily imply correctness or historical consistency, particularly when a geometry model confidently predicts an incorrect structure.
Similarly, the correspondence between state attention and actual geometric consistency is not directly established.
The ablations in Figure 6 show that confidence-only selection already achieves most of the benefits. Adding state attention provides relatively modest further improvements, such as reducing EPI from 7.57 to 7.52 and RPT from 5.35 to 5.22.
This raises questions about the independent contribution of the attention-based selection signal.
Furthermore, comparisons of injection configurations do not fully isolate noise-level alignment from changes in injection location, stage coverage, or the amount of additional context. As acknowledged in Section 4.3, the two-stage injection setting also uses a larger total token budget than either single-stage variant.
More carefully controlled ablations, including matched token budgets, deliberately mismatched noise levels, and direct analysis of the geometric errors of selected tokens, would provide stronger evidence for the proposed design.
W5. Limited statistical analysis and lack of human perceptual evaluation.
Although Token Forcing improves several geometric metrics, the improvements are not uniform across all settings.
For instance, under outdoor TI2V generation, EPI increases from 4.95 to 5.03, while the average VBench score decreases from 86.21 to 85.41.
Furthermore, the gains on motion-rich prompts are relatively small. At 60 seconds, the average VBench score increases only from 85.72 to 85.84 over Causal Forcing.
The paper does not report confidence intervals, standard deviations, or statistical significance tests for these results. The component ablations are also conducted on only 20 randomly sampled scenes with a fixed seed.
Without additional statistical analysis, it is difficult to determine how consistently the smaller improvements would generalize across different prompts and sampling seeds.
Moreover, the paper lacks systematic human evaluation to establish whether the improvements in reconstruction-based metrics translate into perceptually meaningful gains in geometric consistency.
A pairwise human GSB evaluation assessing structural consistency, natural motion, and overall video quality would strengthen the empirical conclusions.
Response to Reviewer LsnC
We thank the reviewer for the meaningful and constructive feedback. We address each concern below.
At each of the first two denoising stages (D0 and D1), we select tokens from the clean image decoded from the generator’s intermediate prediction. We compared these selected tokens with an equal-sized set of lowest-scoring tokens (Bottom-k) from the same prediction. We evaluated ten 60-second videos and included only tokens with valid historical matches. For each token, we used VGGT to project its estimated 3D point into the matched historical views and measured its 2D reprojection error.
Selected tokens have lower mean reprojection error than Bottom-k at both stages, by 7.5% at D0 and 7.4% at D1. This confirms that selected tokens do have measurably lower cross-view error, so our confidence score is positively associated with geometric reliability rather than being an unrelated certainty signal.
We followed the setup of the ablation study in Figure 6 and used both confidence and attention for token selection in all settings. In the Absent setting, we omitted the input from previous video blocks. In the Reset setting, we reset the TTT3R state to zero before each token selection step. Absent and Reset produce identical inputs to the token selector, so we report a single result for both. In the Shuffled setting, we shuffled the historical frames before passing them to TTT3R. In the Default setting, we processed the frames in chronological order and retained the TTT3R state across video blocks.
The default setting performed best across all six metrics.
For all methods in Table 1 of the main paper, here we report VGGT-estimated camera rotation speed and angular span alongside VBench Dynamic Degree (DD). Angular span is the maximum angle between viewing directions within an evaluation window.
Our proposed method, Token Forcing, preserves camera motion and achieves the highest DD.