acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Learning Latent Algebraic Structure from Ambiguous Set Observations

Abstract

We study when statistically learnable latent structure can also be recovered efficiently, and how membership queries change the answer. An unknown support has small additive doubling and is observed through a fixed set satisfying . We seek one linear subspace such that every compatible support is covered by few -cosets and satisfies . For every , polynomially many uniform samples suffice statistically, with cost polynomial in the doubling constant and proportional to ; this radius dependence is sharp. Under a specified hardness assumption for learning parities with noise (search-LPN), however, no polynomial-time sample-only learner achieves even constant covering cost, including when the latent support is unique. At fixed structural parameters and the same constant covering budget, adding exact membership queries to permits polynomial-time recovery. The general query learner constructs a short structural list and uses fresh samples to select one common output through a majority-coverage rule. Persistent structured cores make this candidate construction possible. At doubling one, a complementary distinction appears at : coarse recovery remains polynomial time, while exact recovery requires exponentially many accesses in the worst case when latent cardinality is unknown.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
algorithmic additive combinatorics, finite-field subspace learning, LPN hardness, membership query learning, small doubling sets

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_77oDOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

Given a hidden set A⊂F2nA\subset \mathbb{F}_2^n with ∣A+A∣≤K∣A∣|A+A|\le K|A|, say an adversary has access to only noisy observations of AA, say BB's such that ∣A△B∣≤η∣A∣|A\triangle B|\le \eta |A|. The authors consider the problem of finding a single subspace VV such that AA is covered by a few cosets of VV. As ∣A∩B∣/∣B∣≥1/(1+η)>1/2|A\cap B|/|B|\ge 1/(1+\eta)>1/2 for every compatible AA, any union of cosets covering half of BB hits each AA in at least (1−η)∣A∣/2(1-\eta)|A|/2 points. Ruzsa covering lemma then turns that into a cover of AA. Thm 1 and 3 follow this protocol to show positive results by using only uniform samples from BB, and when membership queries are additionally allowed. Thm 2 is a negative result that no polynomial-time learner can achieve constant covering cost.

Critical strengths

S1: The idea of using a persistent BSG core (at α\sqrt{\alpha} retained factor and α−4\alpha^{-4} doubling) is a nice one. It allows the authors to support deterministic membership tests and exact uniform sampling. Perhaps this idea can be used in other problems as well.

Critical weaknesses

W1: I think the paper is missing an important citation

  • Srinivasan Arunachalam and Arkopal Dutt. 2026. Learning Stabilizer Structure of Quantum States. STOC 2026. My main concern is that the novelty of the proof pipeline (what is new in this work) is not properly stated. The above work follows the same structure of sampling, BSG Test to get a small doubling set, apply algorithmic PFR and repeat.
Questions for authors

Clarification Requests

  • See W1 above.

Suggestions

  • I think the authors can take a look at this concurrent work to improve their complexity bounds (around Theorem 23 where they use PFR).
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to 77oD Part 1: Persistent cores–contribution and prior work

Thank you very much for identifying the relevant BSG–PFR precedent and for recognizing the potential usefulness of the persistent core. Your comment helped us sharpen the distinction between an established algorithmic route and the quantitative primitive developed here. We should have cited Arunachalam–Dutt [1] in the original submission. We have added the citation and revised the contribution discussion to make both the connection and the additional guarantees explicit. Section and theorem references refer to the revised manuscript.

1. The quantitative contribution [W1 and Q1 (clarification request): what is new in the proof pipeline].

Our compiler operates on a general finite support S⊆F2nS\subseteq\mathbb F_2^n through uniform samples and membership queries, without enumerating SS. Under the premise E(S)≥α∣S∣3E(S)\ge\alpha|S|^3, it constructs, with high probability, a finite record DD defining a core with $ |Y_D|\ge c\sqrt\alpha\,|S|,\ |Y_D+Y_D|\le C\alpha^{-4}|Y_D|. $

The same record supports deterministic membership evaluation and independent uniform samples from YDY_D, conditional on the finite sampling blocks succeeding. The theorem includes separate soundness and completeness guarantees and worst-case resource bounds, allowing the core to be used repeatedly after an adaptive history.

We turn the sharp retained-mass guarantee of Reiher–Schoen [3] into an algorithm for an implicitly accessed support. It constructs a reusable core with the membership, sampling, and error guarantees required by the learner.

These bounds determine the peeling depth. Writing ε=1−η\varepsilon=1-\eta, the shared corruption budget gives a residual-energy threshold α⋆=Θ(ε/K)\alpha_\star=\Theta(\varepsilon/K). On the joint success event, each extracted core retains an Ω(ε/K)\Omega(\sqrt{\varepsilon/K}) fraction of its residual. Peeling continues only while that residual has constant density in BB, giving at most O(K/ε)O(\sqrt{K/\varepsilon}) rounds. PFR processes the same core that is subsequently removed.

The accompanying Lean 4 package machine-checks the compiler’s soundness and completeness, exact sampling from its fixed output core, and explicit finite resource bounds, with a map to the corresponding statements in the paper.

2. Relation to the earlier algorithms [W1: attribution and technical distinction].

Arunachalam–Dutt [1] develop implicit BSG access from Bell-difference sampling and combine it with PFR and algebraic recovery. Their analysis adapts the structured-sandwich approach of Tulsiani–Wolf [2] to the nonuniform distribution arising in quantum learning. This is a direct precedent for the overall BSG–PFR route.

Our theorem applies to any finite support satisfying the energy premise, given uniform samples and membership queries. Structured sandwiches provide precedents for fixed-set access; our theorem supplies the stated mass, doubling, and resource bounds for the general energy inputs arising in residual peeling.

Revision: The revised introduction and Section 6 now make this comparison where the construction is introduced. Appendix M.4 gives the fuller account of the access models and guarantees.

3. What the construction enables beyond a core cover [W1: significance of the contribution].

The final learning objective concerns every latent support compatible with one corrupted observation. Peeling and lifting first produce a list that serves each compatible support, possibly through different entries. A fresh-sample coverage rule then selects one entry whose covering guarantee holds simultaneously for all of them.

This common-output construction also supports the matched access comparison: at the same constant quotient-covering budget, samples suffice statistically, polynomial-time passive learning is hard under the specified search-LPN assumption, and membership queries permit polynomial-time recovery at fixed structural parameters. The comparison holds even when the latent support is unique.

References

[1] Srinivasan Arunachalam and Arkopal Dutt. Learning Stabilizer Structure of Quantum States. STOC, 2026.

[2] Madhur Tulsiani and Julia Wolf. Quadratic Goldreich–Levin Theorems. SIAM Journal on Computing, 2014.

[3] Christian Reiher and Tomasz Schoen. Note on the Theorem of Balog, Szemerédi, and Gowers. Combinatorica, 2024.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to 77oD Part 2: Improved complexity using polynomial-time PFR

Your recommendation of the newer PFR algorithm led to a substantive improvement: incorporating Arunachalam, Dutt, Grewal, and Gupte [1] strengthens the moderate-corruption learner from FPT dependence on KK to polynomial dependence on both nn and KK. We also updated the full-range bound and recalculated input-sample usage.

1. Improved learning bounds [Q2 (suggestion of improved complexity)].

For η≤crob/K\eta\le c_{\mathrm{rob}}/\sqrt K, the submitted bound was Frob(K)poly⁡(n,log⁡(1/ρ))F_{\mathrm{rob}}(K)\operatorname{poly}(n,\log(1/\rho)). Samples, membership queries, and time now all satisfy

$ \operatorname{poly}(n,K,\log(1/\rho)), $

where ρ\rho is the failure probability. The output retains the simultaneous guarantee for all compatible supports, with polynomial covering cost in KK.

One core suffices in this regime. Its doubling is O(K4)O(K^4) and its construction and membership costs are polynomial in n,Kn,K. Applying the new PFR theorem therefore makes the full composition polynomial.

For arbitrary η<1\eta < 1, let κ=K/(1−η)\kappa=K/(1-\eta) and Λ=1+n+log⁡κ+log⁡(1/ρ)\Lambda=1+n+\log\kappa+\log(1/\rho). The revised bound is $ \text{queries and time}\le(\kappa\Lambda)^{O(\sqrt\kappa)}, $ with polynomial sample complexity in n,K,(1−η)−1,log⁡(1/ρ)n,K,(1-\eta)^{-1},\log(1/\rho). The remaining XP dependence comes from recursively evaluating residual predicates over O(κ)O(\sqrt\kappa) peels.

Revision: Theorem 4 states the improved bounds, with updated resource analyses in Appendices E and G. The matched passive/query separation already holds with the original PFR routine; the replacement improves the parameter dependence of the positive algorithm.

2. The interface needed for the replacement.

Revision: We replaced the previous size-oblivious PFR construction in Appendix C with the imported polynomial-time theorem and the finite sampling interface needed by our learner.

Theorem 1.2 of [1] takes membership queries and independent uniform samples without the input set's cardinality. Section 6 and Algorithm 4 of [1] impose predetermined time, sample, and query budgets. Our Theorem 24 records this fixed-input interface.

Our Proposition 25 establishes the adaptive invocation: conditioning on the past fixes a valid small-doubling core and its deterministic predicate. Conditional on finite rejection success, the samples have the exact product law; fresh PFR randomness then gives the conditional guarantee. The outer analysis charges core-membership evaluations to the observed-set oracle.

3. Input samples are counted separately from time.

For core doubling LL, failure budget δ\delta, and u=log⁡(2/δ)u=\log(2/\delta), Appendix C derives the predetermined bound $ s_{\mathrm{PFR}}(n,L,\delta)\le\left\lceil C_s(1+L)^{a_s}\bigl[(n+1)\log(n+2)+u\bigr]u\right\rceil $ for absolute constants Cs,asC_s,a_s. At fixed LL and constant confidence, this is O(nlog⁡(n+2))O(n\log(n+2)) input samples.

The count includes samples consumed by constructed density oracles, with finite extraction caps before repetition. Appendix C gives the stage-by-stage accounting for Algorithm 4 of [1]; Appendices E and G propagate these costs through the full-range and moderate-corruption learners.

Thank you again for your comments.

Reference

[1] Srinivasan Arunachalam, Arkopal Dutt, Sabee Grewal, and Aparna Gupte. Marton's Conjecture in Polynomial Time. arXiv:2609.20771, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to 77oD on our response

Thank you again for your insightful suggestions, which helped us clarify the contribution and improve the complexity bounds. Our responses and revised manuscript are now available. We would be grateful to hear whether these address your concerns about the relation to prior work, and would greatly value any further questions or suggestions.

Reviewer_NbznOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
3(+2)
Presentation
2(+1)
Soundness
3(+2)
Read review
Paper summary

The paper shows a separation between statistical learnability and efficient sample-only learning, even when the latent support is uniquely identifiable. They have been able to overcome this barrier using membership queries. Even though the result is interesting, I found the paper to be extremely hard to read. The paper combines several results on statistical learning, the LPN-based lower bound, query-assisted learning, the persistent-core construction, and exact recovery. But since the connection between these ideas has not been clearly established, I found it very difficult to verify the proofs.

I had to struggle a lot to understand the main ideas. Also, I don't think the paper established why this result would be interesting for people other than those working in additive combinatorics and theoretical computer science. I would raise my score if the paper outlined the main ideas more clearly and explained why the results matter to the machine learning community.

Critical strengths
  • The paper shows a separation between statistical learnability and efficient sample-only learning, even when the latent support is uniquely identifiable.
  • I appreciate that the authors explicitly describe how AI tools were used in preparing the work.
Critical weaknesses
  • I found the main ideas hard to follow since the paper did not make an effort to set up the connection between the results it used from different areas.

  • Readability The paper is technically very dense. A proper outline would make the rest of the paper easier to follow. I think focus on the sample-only hardness result and its contrast with membership-query access.

  • Significance I think the results may interest researchers in theoretical computer science and additive combinatorics. I am doubtful about the appeal of this result to the broader ICLR community. The authors should explain why the results are interesting to the broader ML community. As written, the paper may be a better fit for a theory venue such as ITCS or SODA.

Questions for authors
  1. Can you give a concrete learning application of the real-valued example in Appendix O? What does the learner observe, what does VV represent, and what does a guarantee that holds for every compatible support let the learner do that recovering one support would not?
  2. Theorem 1 already matches the sample-only lower bound and the membership-query upper bound at Q⋆Q_\star. Can you state the value of Q⋆Q_\star directly in the theorem? Does the same separation hold when several latent supports are compatible with the observations?
  3. What guarantee does the persistent-core construction provide that the standard algorithmic PFR or BSG guarantees do not imply? Can you give a small example where a standard routine meets its own guarantee, yet its output causes a later step of the learner to fail?
7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Nbzn Part 1: Main message, matched separation, and readability

Thank you very much for asking us to make the computational comparison explicit and to explain what the common target delivers in a concrete learning problem. Your insightful questions helped us consolidate the separation at one covering budget into a single theorem, develop a real-valued missing-mode example with a recovery guarantee, and explain why core membership and sampling must remain consistent. The central comparison is at the same structural quality: samples suffice statistically, efficient sample-only learning is conditionally hard, and membership queries enable polynomial-time recovery.

To support verification of the main technical construction, we also provide machine-checked Lean 4 proofs of the persistent BSG compiler’s correctness and finite resource guarantees in the supplementary material.

Our response has three parts. Part 1 states the matched computational separation and explains how the results fit together. Part 2 gives a real-valued learning problem and shows what the common target delivers. Part 3 explains the persistent-core requirement and the construction of one common output. Section and theorem numbers refer to the revised manuscript.

1. The same objective and budget [Q2: matched separation; W1: main message].

Let IK,η(B)\mathcal I_{K,\eta}(B) contain the nonempty supports AA satisfying ∣A+A∣≤K∣A∣|A+A|\le K|A| and ∣A△B∣≤η∣A∣|A\triangle B|\le\eta|A|. The loss qA(V)q_A(V) is the number of VV-cosets meeting AA, with value +∞+\infty if ∣V∣>∣A∣|V| > |A|.

Fix K=1K=1, η=1/4\eta=1/4, and the absolute integer Q⋆Q_\star below. All three statements concern the same task: on every BB with a nonempty identification set, output one VV satisfying qA(V)≤Q⋆q_A(V)\le Q_\star for every compatible AA, with probability at least 2/32/3.

  • Statistical sufficiency: an exhaustive learner succeeds using O(n)O(n) uniform samples.
  • Passive hardness: under the specified search-LPN assumption, no randomized polynomial-time sample-only learner achieves this guarantee.
  • Query-assisted recovery: uniform samples and membership queries to BB achieve it in polynomial time.

The common budget is Q_\star=\left\lceil\max\left\\{1,\frac83p(1),C(4/3)^{5/2}P_{\mathrm{PFR}}\\!\left(C'(4/3)^4\right)\right\\}\right\rceil.

Here pp and PPFRP_{\mathrm{PFR}} are the clean existential and algorithmic covering polynomials, and C,C′C,C' are the absolute constants in the query bound. Both upper bounds meet this budget. The lower bound applies at the same Q⋆Q_\star, assuming search-LPN hardness for a uniformly random secret at noise rate [32(1+⌊log⁡2Q⋆⌋)]−1[32(1+\lfloor\log_2Q_\star\rfloor)]^{-1}.

The general query algorithm has XP dependence on the structural parameters; fixing them at K=1,η=1/4K=1,\eta=1/4 makes its complexity polynomial in nn. Every nonempty identification set in this comparison is a singleton. The computational obstruction therefore remains after latent ambiguity disappears.

2. How the results fit together [W1: main message; W2: readability].

Samples select a common hypothesis; queries construct a short candidate family. The shared deletion–insertion budget makes a strict majority of BB genuine under every compatible explanation. A few cosets covering half of BB therefore intersect every explanation substantially. Small doubling turns this overlap into a cover of the whole latent support.

Samples test coverage. The statistical learner searches exhaustively over descriptions; the query learner generates candidates from structured cores. The persistent compiler supplies consistent access to those cores. This separates the selection argument from the computational task of producing candidates.

Exact recovery gives a complementary comparison at K=1,η=1/3K=1,\eta=1/3: coarse recovery remains polynomial time with queries, while exact reconstruction requires exponentially many accesses in the worst case when latent cardinality is unknown.

3. Exposition changes [W2: readability].

Revision:

The introduction now states the comparison before introducing BSG and PFR and explains covering cost through affine direction recovery. We revised the original results table (Table 1); its passive-hardness row explicitly names Q⋆Q_\star.

Theorem 1 consolidates the results into one matched separation, with the parameter matching in Section 2. Section 3 brings the common selection principle forward to explain both positive results. We also added end-to-end pseudocode for the query learner (Algorithm 1, Section 5), showing how residual testing, core extraction, PFR, and final selection fit together. Section 6 explains the persistent interface. The new real-valued example and its proofs in Appendix O address Q1.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Nbzn Part 2: A real-valued learning problem with missing modes

A concrete problem outside the finite-field setting is learning shared variation when an entire mode may be missing from the observation. The recovered structure supports detection of a subsequently encountered shifted mode, although the training observation cannot determine whether that mode exists.

1. Observation and ambiguity [Q1: concrete learning problem; W3: broader significance].

Consider real-valued feature vectors with baseline support C=μ+tv:t=0,…,m−1⊂RdC=\\{\mu+tv:t=0,\ldots,m-1\\}\subset\mathbb R^d, where v≠0v\ne0 and m>18m > 18. The learner receives uniform samples from a fixed support BB satisfying ∣B△C∣≤m/3|B\triangle C|\le m/3, allowing both missing baseline points and inserted points.

The latent support may be CC, or it may be Aw=C∪(C+w)A_w=C\cup(C+w) for an unknown w∉span⁡(v)w\notin\operatorname{span}(v). Both explanations are compatible with the same BB at K=3,η=2/3K=3,\eta=2/3: the shifted support satisfies ∣Aw+Aw∣<3∣Aw∣|A_w+A_w| < 3|A_w| and ∣Aw△B∣≤4m/3=(2/3)∣Aw∣|A_w\triangle B|\le4m/3=(2/3)|A_w|.

Even complete knowledge of BB therefore cannot determine whether the shifted mode exists or locate its offset.

2. What is learned and why the common guarantee forces it [Q1: meaning of the subspace and its guarantee].

Our real-valued learner returns an affine flat F=z+VF=z+V covering at least half of BB. Simultaneously for every compatible support AA, it guarantees dim⁡V≤affdim⁡(A)\dim V\le\operatorname{affdim}(A) and NV(A)≤2K/(1−η)\mathcal N_V(A)\le2K/(1-\eta), where NV(A)\mathcal N_V(A) counts the translates of VV meeting AA.

For this example, the covering bound is 1818. Compatibility of the baseline CC forces dim⁡V≤1\dim V\le1. If VV does not contain vv, all m>18m > 18 baseline points occupy distinct cosets, contradicting the bound. Hence V=span⁡(v)V=\operatorname{span}(v). Moreover, at least three quarters of BB belong to CC, so a parallel flat other than the baseline line cannot cover half of BB. The output is therefore F=μ+span⁡(v)F=\mu+\operatorname{span}(v).

For any 0<ρ<10 < \rho < 1, the learner obtains this guarantee with probability at least 1−ρ1-\rho, using T=O(d+log⁡(1/ρ))T=O(d+\log(1/\rho)) samples. For this family, it can be implemented in O(dT3)O(dT^3) arithmetic operations by testing sample points and lines through sample pairs. The learner selects a minimum-dimensional flat passing an empirical coverage test; uniform convergence controls its true coverage.

3. A downstream use: detecting a previously unobserved mode [Q1: what common recovery delivers; W3: learning relevance].

After learning FF, use the score s(x)=dist⁡(x,F)s(x)=\operatorname{dist}(x,F). Then $ s(\mu+tv)=0,\ s(\mu+tv+w)=\operatorname{dist}(w,\operatorname{span}(v)) > 0. $

Thus baseline variation does not trigger the detector, while a transverse mode encountered later does. Equivalently, projection onto V⊥V^\perp removes the shared variation and preserves the shifted response.

Choosing one compatible explanation does not by itself ensure this property. Using the full affine direction space of AwA_w gives V~=span⁡(v,w)\widetilde V=\operatorname{span}(v,w), which also removes the transverse shift and violates the dimension constraint imposed by the compatible baseline CC. Requiring one output to serve every explanation instead forces V=span⁡(v)V=\operatorname{span}(v), as shown above. The detection guarantee is exact for noiseless test points; tolerance to measurement noise depends on the transverse separation.

This gives a concrete role for the common target: a usable representation can be learned even when the latent support itself cannot be identified. The finite-field theorem separately establishes the computational role of membership access.

Revision: We added the real-valued missing-mode example to the introduction and its proofs to Appendix O. Proposition 53 gives the common affine guarantee; Corollary 54 proves recovery of the baseline line and the polynomial-arithmetic implementation. The appendix also explains the resulting detection rule.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Nbzn Part 3: Why consistent core access is needed

Membership and sampling must refer to the same realized core throughout subsequent computation. PFR needs a consistent input set, and peeling needs a fixed set to remove. The example below shows the failure when those accesses disagree.

1. A concrete failure of nonpersistent access [Q3: why the interface is needed].

In F2×F2m×F2m\mathbb F_2\times\mathbb F_2^m\times\mathbb F_2^m, take Y0=(0,u,0):u∈F2mY_0=\\{(0,u,0):u\in\mathbb F_2^m\\} and Y1=(1,0,w):w∈F2mY_1=\\{(1,0,w):w\in\mathbb F_2^m\\}, and let S=Y0⊔Y1S=Y_0\sqcup Y_1. Each core has half the mass of SS and doubling one; also E(S)≥∣S∣3/4E(S)\ge|S|^3/4.

Suppose membership is fixed to Y0Y_0, but each sampling request reruns an extractor that chooses either core equally. Its sample law is 12UY0+12UY1=US\tfrac12U_{Y_0}+\tfrac12U_{Y_1}=U_S.

Half the samples lie outside the declared input set, violating PFR's input requirements. Taking the union does not repair the guarantee: for N=2mN=2^m, ∣S+S∣=N2+2N−1|S+S|=N^2+2N-1, so its doubling grows with NN. Rerandomizing which core is deleted during peeling likewise allows removed points to reappear.

2. The compiler guarantee [Q3: required property; W2: technical clarity].

Our compiler returns a record DD defining one deterministic set YDY_D. Membership evaluations reuse DD, and finite rejection blocks give independent uniform samples from that same set conditional on success. Peeling removes precisely YDY_D.

For general inputs with E(S)≥α∣S∣3E(S)\ge\alpha|S|^3, the compiler returns, with high probability, a core satisfying $ |Y_D|\ge c\sqrt\alpha\,|S|,\ |Y_D+Y_D|\le C\alpha^{-4}|Y_D|, $ with finite worst-case resource bounds. Soundness controls invalid returned cores; completeness justifies stopping on extraction failure outside its allocated bad event. Sampling exhaustion and reported PFR failure instead count as algorithmic failures.

The key requirement is enough retained mass with reusable core access. Our compiler realizes the sharp mass scale of Reiher–Schoen [1] for general implicitly accessed energy inputs with the guarantees above. At α=Θ((1−η)/K)\alpha=\Theta((1-\eta)/K), this bounds peeling by O(K/(1−η))O(\sqrt{K/(1-\eta)}) rounds. Structured-sandwich constructions provide precedents for fixed-set access [2, 3]; our quantitative bounds make it usable throughout residual peeling.

Machine-checked compiler guarantees. The supplementary Lean 4 formalization verifies the compiler itself: its soundness without an energy promise, completeness under the energy condition, and exact conditional product sampling from the same core used by membership queries. It also verifies explicit finite sample, query, and record-size bounds. We rebuilt the proofs from source and checked them with Lean’s kernel, without admitted proof steps. The package maps these guarantees to Theorems 6 and 16, Proposition 23, and Table 2 and provides reproduction instructions.

3. From candidates to one common output [W1: connection between results; W2: construction].

Peeling and lifting produce a list with ∀A,∃i(A):qA(Vi)≤Q\forall A\\,\exists i(A):q_A(V_i)\le Q, where qAq_A includes covering cost and the size constraint. Fresh samples test each candidate's best union of at most QQ cosets.

Let ε=1−η\varepsilon=1-\eta. Use an empirical threshold of 1/2+ε/81/2+\varepsilon/8 and a uniform estimation error at most ε/8\varepsilon/8. For every compatible AA, its serving subspace admits a union of at most QQ cosets containing AA, whose true BB-coverage is at least 1/(1+η)≥1/2+ε/41/(1+\eta)\ge1/2+\varepsilon/4. The empirical best union has at least as much empirical coverage, so that entry passes. Conversely, every passing union has true BB-coverage at least 1/21/2. Selecting a passing entry of minimum dimension enforces the size constraint for every compatible support.

For the selected union ZZ, write d=∣A∖B∣d=|A\setminus B| and o=∣B∖A∣o=|B\setminus A|. Then, for every compatible AA, $ |A\cap B\cap Z|\ge |B|/2-o=\frac{|A|-d-o}{2}\ge\frac{\varepsilon|A|}{2}. $

One selected coset contains a slice of size at least ε∣A∣/(2Q)\varepsilon|A|/(2Q). Its translates by representatives of the distinct VV-cosets meeting AA are disjoint subsets of A+AA+A, giving qA(V)≤2KQ/εq_A(V)\le2KQ/\varepsilon simultaneously for all AA.

Revision: Section 6 adds the two-core consistency example. Section 3 brings common selection forward; Algorithm 1 in Section 5 shows how core extraction, PFR, and selection compose.

Thank you again for your feedback.

References

[1] Christian Reiher and Tomasz Schoen. Note on the Theorem of Balog, Szemerédi, and Gowers. Combinatorica, 2024.

[2] Madhur Tulsiani and Julia Wolf. Quadratic Goldreich–Levin Theorems. SIAM Journal on Computing, 2014.

[3] Srinivasan Arunachalam, Arkopal Dutt, Sabee Grewal, and Aparna Gupte. Marton’s Conjecture in Polynomial Time. arXiv:2609.20771, 2026. See Lemma 7.2.

Reviewer_CnowOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2(+1)
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to learn a common algebraic structure that is valid for all possible true sets from observational data containing missing values, errors, and multiple potential explanations. Its core contribution is proving that, using random samples alone, the problem is statistically learnable but computationally hard under the LPN assumption, whereas adding active membership queries enables efficient learning. It proposes the Persistent Structured-Core Compiler to achieve this result, while also revealing the complexity gap between coarse structure learning and exact recovery.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper studies a meaningful theoretical problem: how to learn a common structure that works for all possible explanations when the observed data is incomplete or corrupted.

  2. It also compares different ways of accessing data and shows an interesting gap between what can be learned from samples and what can be learned efficiently. In particular, it highlights how allowing active queries can make learning much easier.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Although the paper studies a meaningful theoretical problem, it relies on strong algebraic assumptions. The paper does not clearly explain how this learning objective relates to real machine learning problems or how the learned structure could help with prediction or downstream tasks. Its broader significance remains unclear.

  2. The paper uses complex algorithms and extensive technical analysis to combine existing mathematical tools in a new setting. While it provides some new results, it is not entirely clear how much these results go beyond prior work or how important the additional contributions are.

Questions for authors

See W1 and W2 above.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Cnow Part 1: Learning shared directions for downstream tasks

Thank you very much for asking how the learned common structure can support a downstream task. In the real-valued example below, the recovered direction enables detection of a previously unobserved mode and comparison after removing shared within-mode variation. Both uses follow from an explicit recovery guarantee, although the complete latent support cannot be identified.

1. Learning a shared direction despite a missing mode [W1: assumptions and learning problem].

In the finite-field model, the small-doubling prior includes affine supports and unions of parallel cosets, modeling modes that share directions of variation. The following real-valued example makes that assumption and its consequences explicit.

Consider feature vectors with baseline support C=μ+tv:t=0,…,m−1⊂RdC=\\{\mu+tv:t=0,\ldots,m-1\\}\subset\mathbb R^d, where v≠0v\ne0 and m>18m > 18. The learner receives uniform samples from a fixed observed support BB with ∣B△C∣≤m/3|B\triangle C|\le m/3, allowing both deletions and inserted points.

The latent support may be CC, or it may include an entirely unobserved shifted mode: Aw=C∪(C+w)A_w=C\cup(C+w), where w∉span⁡(v)w\notin\operatorname{span}(v). The same BB is compatible with both explanations at K=3,η=2/3K=3,\eta=2/3. In particular, ∣Aw+Aw∣<3∣Aw∣|A_w+A_w| < 3|A_w| and ∣Aw△B∣≤(2/3)∣Aw∣|A_w\triangle B|\le(2/3)|A_w|. Even complete knowledge of BB cannot determine whether the shifted mode exists or locate ww.

Nevertheless, the common-structure learner recovers the baseline affine line F=μ+span⁡(v)F=\mu+\operatorname{span}(v) with probability at least 1−ρ1-\rho, using T=O(d+log⁡(1/ρ))T=O(d+\log(1/\rho)) samples and O(dT3)O(dT^3) arithmetic operations.

Here ρ\rho is the failure probability. The guarantee has a short structural explanation. In the real-valued formulation, the learner selects an affine flat F=z+VF=z+V covering at least half of BB, with dim⁡V≤affdim⁡(A)\dim V\le\operatorname{affdim}(A) and NV(A)≤2K/(1−η)\mathcal N_V(A)\le2K/(1-\eta) for every compatible support; NV(A)\mathcal N_V(A) counts the translates of VV meeting AA. Here that bound is 1818. Compatibility of CC forces dim⁡V≤1\dim V\le1, and any direction not containing vv would put its m>18m > 18 points in distinct cosets. Thus V=span⁡(v)V=\operatorname{span}(v). The shared corruption budget also gives ∣B∩C∣≥3∣B∣/4|B\cap C|\ge3|B|/4. Any other parallel line is disjoint from CC and contains at most ∣B∣/4|B|/4 observed points. Since FF covers at least half of BB, it must be μ+span⁡(v)\mu+\operatorname{span}(v).

2. Downstream task: novel-mode detection [W1: how the learned structure helps].

After learning FF, define s(x)=dist⁡(x,F)s(x)=\operatorname{dist}(x,F). Then $ s(\mu+tv)=0,\ s(\mu+tv+w)=\operatorname{dist}(w,\operatorname{span}(v)) > 0. $

Within-mode variation does not change the baseline score, while a transverse mode encountered later produces a positive score. The detector does not need to reconstruct that missing mode during training.

The detection guarantee is exact for noiseless test points; tolerance to measurement noise depends on the transverse separation.

3. A second use: comparison after removing shared variation [W1: downstream representation].

The same recovered direction also supplies a comparison rule. Let W=PV⊥W=P_{V^\perp} and define dV(x,y)=∣W(x−y)∣d_V(x,y)=\\|W(x-y)\\|. For later observations x=μ+tv+wix=\mu+tv+w_i and y=μ+sv+wjy=\mu+sv+w_j, dV(x,y)=∣W(wi−wj)∣.d_V(x,y)=\\|W(w_i-w_j)\\|.

The comparison is independent of the within-mode coordinates t,st,s. Observations from the same translated mode have distance zero; modes with distinct transverse offsets remain distinguishable. This supports matching or grouping by transverse mode without interference from variation along vv.

These tasks use the direction shared across compatible explanations. Learning it suffices to remove within-mode variation and detect transverse changes, without deciding which unobserved modes exist.

Revision: We added the missing-mode example to the introduction and the common affine guarantee and recovery proof to Appendix O (Proposition 53 and Corollary 54). The appendix explains the detection interpretation; the comparison rule above follows from the same recovered direction.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Cnow Part 2: Contributions beyond the BSG–PFR pipeline

The contribution is a separation at the same learning objective and quality, supported by a common-output selection rule and a quantitative core algorithm. Below we explain why these results require more than applying existing BSG and PFR routines.

1. Hardness for coarse recovery [W2: new learning results].

The objective is one subspace VV covering every compatible support AA by at most QQ cosets, with ∣V∣≤∣A∣|V|\le|A|. Theorem 1 fixes K=1K=1, η=1/4\eta=1/4, and one absolute budget Q⋆Q_\star. For success probability 2/32/3 on every valid observation:

  • O(n)O(n) samples suffice with exhaustive computation;
  • no randomized polynomial-time sample-only learner succeeds under the specified search-LPN assumption;
  • samples and membership queries to BB suffice in polynomial time.

The assumption is search-LPN hardness for a uniformly random secret at noise rate [32(1+⌊log⁡2Q⋆⌋)]−1[32(1+\lfloor\log_2Q_\star\rfloor)]^{-1}. Every nonempty identification set here is a singleton: the obstruction persists without latent ambiguity.

Prior work connects finite-field subspace learning to LPN [1]. But a single parity graph has a secret-independent two-coset cover: F2d×0\mathbb F_2^d\times\\{0\\} satisfies the size constraint and budget two for every secret. Exact parity-recovery hardness therefore does not directly give hardness of our coarse target.

With k=1+⌊log⁡2Q⋆⌋k=1+\lfloor\log_2Q_\star\rfloor, our blocked construction decodes each output meeting budget Q⋆Q_\star into O(kQ⋆2)O(kQ_\star^2) candidate secrets, including the true secret. Fresh LPN samples identify it. A frozen noise table realizes one fixed corrupted support, matching the observation model.

2. Selecting one common output [W2: positive learning guarantee].

PFR on extracted cores supplies a list serving each compatible support, potentially through different entries. Our selection rule turns this into one common hypothesis.

Fresh samples test each entry's best union of at most QQ cosets. On a uniform concentration event, every support's serving entry passes, while every passing union covers at least half of BB. Minimum-dimension selection enforces the size constraint for all supports. The shared corruption budget gives ∣A∩B∩Z∣≥ε∣A∣/2|A\cap B\cap Z|\ge\varepsilon|A|/2 for the selected union, where ε=1−η\varepsilon=1-\eta. Small doubling then yields $ \forall A\in\mathcal I_{K,\eta}(B):\ q_A(V_\star)\le2KQ/\varepsilon. $

Here IK,η(B)\mathcal I_{K,\eta}(B) is the compatible-support class and qAq_A includes covering cost and the size constraint. The statistical learner searches exhaustively for candidates; queries construct a short list for the same selector.

3. Quantitative candidate construction [W2: algorithmic contribution].

Tulsiani–Wolf [2] and Arunachalam–Dutt [3] provide algorithmic BSG precedents. Given uniform samples and membership access to a general support with E(S)≥α∣S∣3E(S)\ge\alpha|S|^3, our compiler constructs, with high probability, a fixed core satisfying $ |Y_D|\ge c\sqrt\alpha\,|S|,\ |Y_D+Y_D|\le C\alpha^{-4}|Y_D|. $

Its record supports deterministic membership and independent uniform samples conditional on finite sampling success, with separate soundness/completeness and worst-case resource bounds.

This realizes the sharp retained-mass scale of Reiher–Schoen [4] for an implicit support. At residual threshold α⋆=Θ((1−η)/K)\alpha_\star=\Theta((1-\eta)/K), the mass bound limits peeling to O(K/(1−η))O(\sqrt{K/(1-\eta)}) rounds. Fixed-core access supports subsequent PFR calls and residual updates.

Revision: Theorem 1 brings the matched separation into one statement, and Section 3 presents the common selection argument separately from candidate construction. Section 6 and Appendix M clarify the compiler’s quantitative guarantees and their relation to prior BSG–PFR algorithms.

Thank you again for your feedback.

References

[1] A. Chen, A. De, and A. Vijayaraghavan. Learning a Mixture of Two Subspaces over Finite Fields. ALT, 2021.

[2] M. Tulsiani and J. Wolf. Quadratic Goldreich–Levin Theorems. SIAM Journal on Computing, 2014.

[3] S. Arunachalam and A. Dutt. Learning Stabilizer Structure of Quantum States. STOC, 2026.

[4] C. Reiher and T. Schoen. Note on the Theorem of Balog, Szemerédi, and Gowers. Combinatorica, 2024.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to Cnow on our response

Thank you again for your questions about learning relevance and the technical contribution. We have addressed both in our responses and revised manuscript. When you have an opportunity, we would be grateful to hear whether our explanations resolve your concerns. We would greatly value the chance to discuss any points that remain unclear or unconvincing.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of revisions and discussion

We thank the Area Chair for considering our paper and the reviewers for helping us sharpen it. The central learning question is whether, from incomplete observations, one can efficiently find a representation that remains valid across different explanations of the data. Three points from the discussion clarify both the result and its significance.

1. The separation holds at the same quality, even on ambiguous inputs (Nbzn, Cnow).

Both reviewers highlighted the distinction between statistical learnability and efficient recovery. In response to Nbzn’s questions, Theorem 1 now gives the covering budget explicitly. At K=1K=1, the learner must find one subspace, no larger than any compatible support, that covers each such support with at most two cosets. With exhaustive computation, O(n)O(n) uniform samples suffice. Under the stated search-LPN assumption, no polynomial-time sample-only learner attains the same guarantee, whereas adding membership queries to the same observed set permits polynomial-time recovery. The separation holds when the support is unique (η=1/4\eta=1/4) and, as the new Appendix J.3 proves, even when the learner is promised two compatible supports (η=7/16\eta=7/16).

2. A faster query learner and a clearer account of what it adds (77oD, Nbzn).

The revised introduction separates two steps: samples test how much of the observation a proposed cover captures; the general query algorithm uses structured cores to build a short list of candidates. 77oD noted the potential usefulness of these cores and pointed us to relevant prior work. Appendix M.4 now distinguishes the established BSG–PFR approach from our compiler’s guarantees: it retains enough mass to bound the number of extraction rounds and provides membership and uniform sampling for the same extracted core. Following 77oD’s suggestion, the moderate-corruption learner now uses time, samples, and queries polynomial in both nn and KK. The Lean 4 supplement verifies the compiler’s soundness, completeness, and finite resource bounds.

3. What the learned representation lets us do (Cnow, Nbzn, 77oD).

Cnow and Nbzn asked for a concrete downstream use of the learned structure, and 77oD encouraged us in the follow-up discussion to make its significance for ML clearer. In the revised paper’s two-sensor example, the learner sees readings under varying load but is given neither the baseline slope nor mode labels. It recovers the baseline direction. For baseline readings (t,2t)(t,2t), the residual x2−2x1x_2-2x_1 is zero at every load tt. If a new mode shifts the second reading by b≠0b\ne0, the residual is exactly bb. Removing every direction in the two-mode explanation would erase that signal; requiring the representation to work for the baseline explanation as well preserves it. The training data cannot establish whether a second mode exists, yet they suffice to learn what variation to ignore and what change to flag.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.