- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces REVE, a training-free acceleration framework for instruction-based image editing. The method identifies edit and non-edit regions through agreement between predicted velocities and reference-image reconstruction velocities. At skipped timesteps, it reuses cached velocities in non-edit regions and applies first-order velocity extrapolation in edit regions, with an extrapolation weight that increases throughout denoising. Experiments on three editing models and two benchmarks report approximately 2.54–2.73× speedups while preserving output fidelity better than the evaluated acceleration baselines.
Critical strengths
- Clear motivation and practical design. The distinction between detail refinement in edit regions and preservation in non-edit regions provides a compelling motivation for region-dependent velocity approximation. The resulting method is simple, training-free, and compatible with existing editing models.
- Consistent results across models and benchmarks. Evaluation covers three editing backbones and two benchmarks using shared principal hyperparameters. REVE consistently improves fidelity to unaccelerated outputs over the reported acceleration baselines while achieving comparable or higher speedups.
- Informative mechanism-oriented ablations. The paper compares velocity reuse, global extrapolation, region-specific extrapolation, and time-weighted extrapolation. These results support the importance of restricting extrapolation to edit regions. Direction perturbation and extrapolation-order experiments provide additional evidence beyond a standard component ablation.
- Compatibility with adaptive skipping. Integration with TeaCache demonstrates that the proposed approximation strategy can complement an existing adaptive evaluation schedule, rather than being useful only under the default fixed schedule.
Critical weaknesses
- The contributions of region partitioning and velocity approximation are not fully disentangled. REVE adopts RegionE’s spatial acceleration and KV-caching framework while changing both region identification and skipped-step velocity approximation. The existing ablations primarily examine extrapolation choices. A controlled comparison that independently swaps the masks and approximation rules under identical evaluation schedules would more clearly establish the contribution of each proposed component.
- The quality–efficiency comparison is concentrated on individual operating points. The main tables demonstrate favorable results at the selected configurations, but do not establish performance across a broader range of acceleration strengths. Matched-latency comparisons and quality–latency curves would strengthen the claim. A simple reduced-step sampling baseline is also missing, despite being a natural alternative for reducing model evaluations.
- The proposed Detail Fidelity metric has limited specificity. DF measures agreement in mean gradient magnitude within the edit region. Different textures, misplaced edges, and some artifacts can have similar mean gradient magnitudes, so a lower DF does not necessarily indicate more accurate detail reconstruction. PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS provide useful complementary evidence, but the stronger claims about fine-detail preservation would benefit from localized perceptual evaluation or human assessment.
- Region-identification reliability and statistical uncertainty are insufficiently characterized. Mask visualizations and threshold sensitivity studies are useful, but quantitative localization accuracy and failure analysis remain limited. Some SC/PQ improvements over RegionE are small—for example, PQ increases by 0.019 on Step1X-Edit with GEdit-Bench—and no confidence intervals or repeated judging results are provided. This makes the robustness of the semantic and perceptual improvements harder to assess.
Questions for authors
- Under identical masks, evaluation schedules, and cache updates, how much improvement comes from the proposed velocity approximation? Conversely, what improvement comes from replacing only the region-partitioning criterion?
- Are matched-latency results or quality–latency curves available for REVE and RegionE? How does REVE compare with simply reducing the number of sampling steps at a similar computational budget?
- Are the subject-replacement samples used to select the mask threshold disjoint from the samples used for the final benchmark results? How are pseudo ground-truth edit masks constructed for global stylization, object movement, and object addition?
- Are the SC/PQ improvements stable under paired uncertainty analysis or repeated VLM evaluation? Is there supporting human evaluation of edit-region detail and non-edit-region preservation?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer W5Ca (Continued)
5. Stability of the SC/PQ improvements and human evaluation (W4, Q4). We compute paired bootstrap 95% confidence intervals of the per-sample SC and PQ differences between REVE and RegionE (Table 7, App. E).
| Model | Benchmark | ΔSC [95% CI] | ΔPQ [95% CI] |
|---|---|---|---|
| Step1X-Edit | GEdit-Bench | +0.051 [+0.000, +0.109] | +0.019 [−0.018, +0.054] |
| Step1X-Edit | GIE-Bench | +0.026 [−0.050, +0.101] | +0.034 [+0.011, +0.058] |
| Boogu-Image-0.1-Edit | GEdit-Bench | +0.022 [−0.026, +0.076] | +0.018 [−0.018, +0.053] |
| Boogu-Image-0.1-Edit | GIE-Bench | +0.026 [−0.013, +0.068] | +0.024 [+0.002, +0.045] |
| LongCat-Image-Edit | GEdit-Bench | +0.040 [−0.013, +0.096] | +0.051 [+0.015, +0.087] |
| LongCat-Image-Edit | GIE-Bench | +0.012 [−0.030, +0.050] | +0.027 [+0.007, +0.049] |
The mean differences are positive in all 12 settings, and the PQ improvement is statistically significant in 4 of 6 settings. The intervals are relatively wide because both methods remain close to the unaccelerated models and receive identical scores on most samples. Nevertheless, the consistent direction across all models and benchmarks indicates that the improvements are systematic rather than incidental.
We also conduct a human evaluation on Step1X-Edit with 66 GEdit-Bench samples, 6 from each of the 11 tasks (Table 14, App. L). Given the reference image and the instruction, 24 annotators rate the anonymized outputs of all six acceleration methods, shown in random order, on a five-point scale for fine detail within the edit region (Detail) and preservation of the non-edit region (Preservation).
| Method | Detail ↑ | Preservation ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| TaylorSeer | 3.682 | 3.521 |
| TeaCache | 3.672 | 3.639 |
| RAS | 3.232 | 3.593 |
| SpotEdit | 3.457 | 3.604 |
| RegionE | 3.819 | 3.665 |
| REVE (Ours) | 3.881 | 3.698 |
REVE receives the highest ratings for both edit-region detail and non-edit-region preservation.
6. Disjointness of threshold-selection samples (Q3). The subject-replace samples used to select τ are not disjoint from the evaluation set, since GEdit-Bench provides no separate validation split (App. G). However, the same τ = 0.82 is applied without retuning to GIE-Bench and to all three editing models.
7. Construction of pseudo ground-truth masks (Q3). We have clarified the construction of the pseudo ground-truth masks in App. C. For each instruction, the target phrase is extracted with Qwen3-VL, localized with GroundingDINO, and segmented with SAM2, with the image used for segmentation determined by the edit type. For global stylization, the edit affects the entire image, so no pseudo mask is constructed with these models. For object movement, the object is segmented in both the reference image and the unaccelerated edited image, and the union of the two segments covers both its original and new locations. For object addition, the added object appears only in the edited image and is therefore segmented in the unaccelerated edited image.
Thanks for rebuttal
I believe this paper presents an interesting technique for image editing, and experiments prove its effectiveness. According to authors' feedback and other reviewers' comments, I maintain my original score, which tends to accpet.
Thank You for Your Follow-up
Thank you for your follow-up and for recognizing the value of our work. Your constructive comments have helped us improve the paper. We sincerely appreciate your time and effort in reviewing our work.
Response to Reviewer W5Ca
We thank the reviewer for the detailed and constructive comments. All new results are included in the revised paper, with revisions highlighted in blue.
1. Disentangling region partitioning and velocity approximation (W1, Q1). We replace our region partitioning and velocity approximation with their RegionE counterparts, one at a time, on Step1X-Edit with GEdit-Bench (Table 3, Section 5.3). All variants share identical evaluation schedules, cache updates, and latency.
With identical masks (rows 1 and 3), our velocity approximation reduces DF from 0.070 to 0.046 and LPIPS from 0.056 to 0.049. With an identical approximation (rows 2 and 3), replacing only the partitioning criterion with ours raises SC from 8.188 to 8.238 and PQ from 8.026 to 8.050. The velocity approximation thus mainly improves detail fidelity, while the region partitioning mainly improves instruction following and perceptual quality.
2. Quality–latency curves and reduced-step sampling (W2, Q2). We provide quality–latency curves for REVE, RegionE, and the unaccelerated model with fewer sampling steps on a 330-sample subset of GEdit-Bench (Figure 5, Section 5.2). We vary the number of edit-region evaluations for REVE, the skipping threshold for RegionE, and the number of sampling steps for the unaccelerated model. REVE achieves lower DF and LPIPS than RegionE at all evaluated speedups, with comparable or higher SC and PQ, and its advantage grows as the speedup increases. Compared with reducing the sampling steps, although the 10-step baseline achieves slightly higher SC at a 2.80× speedup, REVE achieves higher PQ and reduces DF and LPIPS to about one third of those of the baseline, even at a higher speedup of 2.88×.
3. Specificity of DF (W3). We agree that DF does not verify whether details are reproduced at the correct locations, and we now state this in App. C. We therefore complement DF with PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS computed within the pseudo ground-truth edit region (Table 5, App. C), where LPIPS provides a localized perceptual evaluation.
REVE outperforms RegionE on all three metrics for all models and benchmarks, and it also receives the highest human rating for fine detail within the edit region (see point 5 below). These results indicate that the lower DF of REVE reflects more accurate detail reconstruction.
4. Localization accuracy and failure analysis of region identification (W4). We compare the masks of REVE and RegionE with pseudo ground-truth masks on local edits from the 330-sample subset of GEdit-Bench (Table 13, App. K).
REVE achieves higher precision at a slightly lower recall, indicating that its edit regions contain fewer tokens outside the edited content, and it improves IoU for all edit sizes. Our failure analysis identifies two main causes of deviation. First, the pseudo mask can be larger than the edited content; for example, when only one word on a menu is replaced, the pseudo mask covers the entire menu, whereas REVE marks only the replaced word. Second, the editing model can alter the entire image in response to a local instruction; in such cases, REVE correctly marks the changed regions, whereas the pseudo mask covers only the target object. These deviations therefore mainly reflect inaccurate pseudo masks or over-editing by the model rather than errors in region partitioning.