- Rating
- 2(−1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces EvoDriveVLA, a novel distillation framework for end-to-end autonomous driving (E2D-AD).
Specifically, the paper designs self-anchored visual distillation to impose visual anchoring constraints on trajectory-guided key regions, enhancing perceptual capabilities.
In addition, the paper proposes future-informed trajectory distillation to enable the student to internalize the oracle teacher’s future-aware insights, which also enable coarse-to-fine trajectory refinement.
However, the paper lack the comparison with existing coarse-to-fine methods and the complete ablation studies.
Critical strengths
This paper introduces EvoDriveVLA, a novel distillation framework for end-to-end autonomous driving (E2D-AD).
Specifically, the paper design self-anchored visual distillation to impose visual anchoring constraints on trajectory-guided key regions, enhancing perceptual capabilities.
In addition, the paper propose future-informed trajectory distillation to enable the student to internalize the oracle teacher’s future-aware insights, which also enable coarse-to-fine trajectory refinement.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient comparison with existing coarse-to-fine methods. One of the core contributions of this paper is coarse-to-fine trajectory refinement. What are the differences between the proposed method and existing coarse-to-fine methods [1]? The authors should provide experimental comparisons. And discuss these differences in the Introduction or Related Work section.
-
Limited comparisons with recent methods. The authors should include more comparisons with methods [1][2][3][4] published in 2026 in Tables 1 and 2.
-
Lack of evaluation in interactive closed-loop environments. The authors should evaluate the proposed model on closed-loop benchmarks such as Bench2Drive or HUGSIM, since NAVSIM and nuScenes are both open-loop benchmarks.
-
Lack of comparisons with newer VLM backbones. In Table 2, the authors should adopt the latest Qwen3.5 or Qwen3.8 models as baselines to strengthen the conclusions of the paper.
-
Insufficient ablation studies. The authors should conduct the ablation experiments in Table 3 on additional datasets, as the current results do not clearly demonstrate the effectiveness of each proposed module.
[1] WAM-Flow: Parallel Coarse-to-Fine Motion Planning via Discrete Flow Matching for Autonomous Driving
[2] Recogdrive: A reinforced cognitive framework for end-to-end autonomous driving
[3] WAM-Diff: A masked diffusion vla framework with moe and online reinforcement learning for autonomous driving
[4] Wa-jepa: Rethinking the video jepa paradigm for world-action modeling in autonomous driving
Questions for authors
Are the images in Figure 1 and Figure 2 AI-generated? Regardless, please refine the color scheme.
17 comments
A Sincere Request to Reconsider the Rating Change
May I sincerely ask why the rating was lowered from 3 to 2 before our rebuttal, without an accompanying explanation? This unexpected change has been deeply discouraging, particularly because we do not understand what prompted it.
We have worked hard to address your concerns and provide additional evidence. Could you please consider our rebuttal and reconsider restoring your original rating of 3? If concerns remain, we would be grateful for the opportunity to address them.
Thank you sincerely for your time and consideration.
The driving score (DS) of EvoDriveVLA on Bench2Drive makes me somewhat skeptical of this approach, even though the work achieved promising results in open-loop evaluations on NAVSIM.
Thank you for the constructive review and for recognizing the contributions of our self-anchored visual distillation and future-informed trajectory distillation. We address your concerns below.
Q1. Differences from existing coarse-to-fine methods.
WAM-Flow uses coarse-to-fine refinement as part of its inference-time planning procedure through parallel discrete flow matching. In contrast, our refinement is performed exclusively by the privileged teacher during training to construct stronger distillation targets. The student does not perform coarse-to-fine refinement at inference, and its inference procedure remains unchanged.
These mechanisms therefore serve different purposes: inference-time trajectory generation versus training-time supervision construction. A direct module-level comparison would not isolate the same functionality, although system-level benchmark comparisons remain useful. We will clarify this distinction in the Introduction and Related Work of the camera-ready version.
Q2. Comparisons with recent methods.
Thank you for bringing these recent works to our attention. We will expand the discussion and comparison to include WAM-Flow, RecogDrive, WAM-Diff, and WA-JEPA in the camera-ready version. We will incorporate their reported results into Tables 1 and 2 where the datasets, evaluation protocols, and input settings are comparable, and explicitly identify differences in experimental settings.
Q3. Evaluation in interactive closed-loop environments.
NAVSIM evaluates trajectories using non-reactive simulation and simulation-based driving metrics, going beyond trajectory-displacement evaluation alone. Nevertheless, we agree that this does not substitute for fully interactive closed-loop evaluation.
Importantly, Appendix G, Table 11 already reports additional closed-loop results on Bench2Drive:
These results demonstrate improvements in both closed-loop Driving Score and Success Rate. We will make this evaluation more prominent and clarify the distinction between NAVSIM's non-reactive evaluation and interactive closed-loop evaluation.
Q4–Q5. Validation on a newer backbone and additional ablations.
Following your suggestions, we further evaluated our framework on Qwen3.5-4B, including separate ablations of visual and language-model distillation:
The complete framework reduces average L2 from 0.54 to 0.51 m and three-second collision rate from 0.42% to 0.33%, demonstrating effectiveness on a newer backbone. The ablations further distinguish the branches' contributions: visual distillation improves collision rates at all three horizons, while LLM distillation primarily improves trajectory accuracy. Their combination achieves the lowest average L2, although visual distillation alone performs better on some collision metrics. These experiments extend our branch-level ablations across backbones; the NAVSIM and Bench2Drive results additionally support effectiveness across benchmarks, although they do not constitute full component-wise ablations on additional datasets.
Figures 1 and 2.
Neither Figure 1 nor Figure 2 is AI-generated. Thank you for the suggestion regarding their appearance. We will refine the color scheme to improve readability and visual consistency in the camera-ready version.
We hope these clarifications and additional results address your concerns, and we would appreciate your consideration of raising your score.