- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
-
This paper studies part semantic segmentation using only image-level object labels and part-presence labels, without pixel-level part annotations.
-
It constructs part-specific visual prototypes by comparing relative similarities among parts within the same object.
-
A shared orthogonal transformation aligns pretrained part-text embeddings with visual prototypes while preserving their pairwise semantic relations.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a practical problem of learning part segmentation without part-level spatial annotations.
-
The proposed method combines relative part competition and orthogonal mapping in a simple and straightforward framework.
-
The ablation studies separately demonstrate the effectiveness of relative scoring and the additional benefits of orthogonal constraints.
Critical weaknesses
-
Both relative similarity-based selection and orthogonal mapping (2016) build on established techniques, limiting the methodological novelty. Furthermore, it remains unclear whether the improvement from orthogonal mapping comes from preserving relational structure or simply restricting the flexibility of the transformation.
-
The method assumes that the relational structure of pretrained part-text embeddings is consistent with the underlying visual part structure. Since orthogonal mapping strictly preserves these relations, it may struggle to correct mismatches between the two representation spaces.
-
The improvements on ADE-234 are relatively limited. The mIoU remains low at 6.38, while mACC decreases from 20.06 to 15.82 compared with Talk2DINO-Part. Further analysis would help explain this behavior. In addition, it is unclear whether the approximately 1-point mIoU improvement is statistically meaningful.
-
The adaptation procedure of Talk2DINO-Part, including its training objectives and learnable parameters, is not sufficiently described. Given the substantial performance gap between Talk2DINO-Part and Absolute + Linear (12.38 mIoU), despite using the same backbone and supervision, further clarification would help establish a more transparent basis for comparison.
Questions for authors
I would appreciate it if the authors could address the concerns raised in the weaknesses above.