- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper researchs open-world semantic-level object-goal search for aerial agents. The authors propose "AerialWAM," a semantic-object reconstructor that generates a goal image based on current observations and language instructions. This goal image then serves as a condition for a subsequent world action model, which outputs the corresponding actions required to search for the target. The model is trained in three stages, respectively optimizing the object-image reconstruction, world action model, and the full closed-loop system. Experiments are conducted in two simulation scenes from AerialDojo-200K. The authors claim that their model outperforms the VLM-based baselines.
Critical strengths
This paper integrates a generated target representations into the online, closed-loop decision-making process for open-world object-goal search tasks. The model updates the goal image (which provides the world action model with visual information about the next action output) using real-time observations from the surrounding environment and language instructions. This mechanism allows the world action model to directly understand the target obeject, enabling more effective search planning.
Critical weaknesses
-
The effectiveness of the "semantic-object reconstructor" proposed in the paper lacks validation of experiments. The paper lacks ablation experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of the semantic-object reconstructor. For instance, authors could conduct a simple comparative experiment by testing the "world action model" with and without the "goal image" generated by the semantic-object reconstructor as an input. Furthermore, when the target object is not present in the model's input observations, do the goal images outputed by the semantic-object reconstructor align with the actual target object? If they do not align, does this lead the subsequent world action model to generate incorrect actions?
-
Benchmark coverage is limited, and there is a lack of baselines for agent systems. The evaluation is limited to two island scenarios within AerialDojo-200K. Testing should be expanded to more AerialDojo scenarios or external benchmarks (such as UAV-ON[1]). Furthermore, please add some relevant agent baselines (e.g., AOA-F[1] and APEX[2]). Comparing a world-action model trained specifically for certain tasks against a basic VLM controller does not constitute a fair comparison.
-
The results reported in Tables 1 through Table 4 require further clarification, and the corresponding supporting records should be provided. In some cases, the reported percentages do not align with the stated number of test trials. For example, Claude’s success rate (SR) on the NIsland_0 Base task is reported as 5.88%; however, this figure cannot be derived from an integer number of successful trials out of 295 total trials. (17/295 is approximately 5.76%, while 18/295 is approximately 6.10%.) Besides, in the case of Grok, the episode counts for out-of-distribution (OOD) cannot even be reconciled with a common integer denominator of 334 or less. Could the authors provide the exact inputs, prompts, history, and output formats used in these benchmarks, as well as the specific episode IDs and episode counts?
[1] Xiao J, Sun Y, Shao Y, et al. UAV-ON: A Benchmark for Open-World Object Goal Navigation with Aerial Agents[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2508.00288, 2025.
[2] Zhang D, Chen P, Xia X, et al. APEX: A Decoupled Memory-based Explorer for Asynchronous Aerial Object Goal Navigation[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.00551, 2026.
Questions for authors
-
When the target is invisible and its semantic description is ambiguous, what evidence shows that the reconstructed object image matches the actual target? Could you provide some visual examples?
-
See 1, 2 and 3 in the Weakness.