- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CoREL addresses medication recommendation when hospitals differ in prescribing practices. It assumes that each medication's prescription logit is the sum of a shared patient-dependent score and a hospital-specific intercept. Training compares patients from the same hospital with discordant medication labels, conditioning out that intercept. A GRU-based EHR encoder learns the shared scores. Then subsequent global and shrinkage-based local intercept calibration recovers hospital-conditioned predictions. Greedy inference-time refinement discourages known drug-drug interactions. Experiments shows CoREL generally improves recommendation accuracy and reduces DDI rates in multi-institutional settings.
Critical strengths
- Practical motivation: Figure 1 shows substantial hospital variation in prescribing therapeutically related medications. CoREL addresses this by removing a medication-specific intercept for within-hospital comparisons, while retaining useful local practice information in later calibration
- The paper provides enough details for reproducibility.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited technical novelty and missing relevant baselines. CoREL combines a shared scorer and hospital-specific intercepts (Eq 1), a standard pairwise logistic loss (Eq 5), and intercept calibration with shrinkage toward a global reference. The baselines also omit TEMPT [1], which directly addresses multi-center medication recommendation on eICU through shared pretraining and hospital-specific prompt tuning. [1] A Contrastive Pretrain Model with Prompt Tuning for Multi-center Medication Recommendation. Liu et al, TOIS 2025
- Insufficient validation of the claimed separation. The paper lacks controlled evidence that the learned scores separate patient evidence from institutional tendencies beyond the additive-intercept assumption in Eq 1. In particular, recovery of the two components and robustness to institution-by-patient interactions remain untested. Prescription-based prediction metrics cannot independently establish this separation. Appendix B.1 also leaves the prediction-time feature cutoff unclear, so whether current-encounter diagnoses and procedures precede the target medications requires clarification.
Questions for authors
- What is the main technical advance over conditional pairwise learning followed by regularized intercept calibration?
- How does CoREL compare with TEMPT under matched inputs and data splits?
- Can controlled experiments assess component recovery and robustness to institution-by-patient interactions?
- When is the recommendation made, and how are current-encounter inputs restricted to information available at that time?