- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose Causal Mamba (CM) for estimating counterfactual outcomes over time, addressing two key challenges in longitudinal causal effect estimation: computational inefficiency in modeling temporal dependencies and information loss caused by over-balancing. Specifically, CM introduces a GCSI-Mamba backbone to efficiently capture cross-stream interactions and temporal dynamics, and the MTC module to mitigate over-balancing while preserving predictive information. Experimental results on synthetic, semi-synthetic, and real-world datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and computational efficiency of CM.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed CM method effectively combines cross-stream interactions and temporal modeling through GCSI-Mamba, while incorporating the MTC module to balance treatment-related information and preserve predictive information.
-
The authors conduct extensive experiments on synthetic, semi-synthetic, and real-world datasets, including comparisons with representative baselines, ablation studies, and efficiency analyses.
Critical weaknesses
-
CM focuses on multi-step counterfactual prediction, but Proposition 2 only establishes a risk bound for one-step counterfactual estimation, without providing theoretical guarantees for multi-step predictions.
-
Although MTC is designed to mitigate over-balancing, the experiments provide limited direct evidence that covariate reconstruction effectively preserves outcome-relevant information.
-
MTC reconstructs all covariates without distinguishing their relevance to treatment assignment and outcome prediction. However, preserving treatment-only information may weaken representation balancing and compromise counterfactual estimation accuracy.
-
The comparisons with recent methods are limited, and the improvements over some baselines are relatively small.
-
In the synthetic TG dataset, the covariate stream is absent and the reconstruction weight is set to zero. Therefore, the results on this dataset cannot directly validate the contribution of covariate reconstruction to mitigating over-balancing.
Questions for authors
See above weakness.