- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper conducts an experimental comparisons to investigate the effectiveness of leveraging vision model pretrained on image data to apply into the time series forecasting tasks. It visits the numerical data representation in images as usually undirected topology, and reports that the undirected topology setting is insufficient for transferring vision model to time series tasks and justifies it via phase, cycle, and both reflections. It then conducts some numerical experiments to further explain such an observation.
Critical strengths
Well, this work visits a very specific potential issue of leveraging pre-trained vision-based models to conduct time series tasks. Its problem description is clear.
Critical weaknesses
It is more or less like proposing a problem with insufficient technical development, e.g., proposing new mechanisms, for addressing such a problem. It aims to prove the existence of such an issues. However, to many of the time-series foundational model researchers, this is quite some well known issues. Hence, this is more or less a technical analytical report rather than an original research article presenting new findings, new methods, or new results. Thus, I think it is off the standard of the bar of the top AI conference.
Questions for authors
Q1. Why this issue deserves a research space? What is the motivation or necessity of a discussion on leveraging Vision models for time series forecasting tasks? Maybe it is not a valuable topic we should explore unless we justify the significant advantages of Vision based models on conducting time series forecasting.
Q2. Besides this image data understanding or analysing issue of this vision model, it is more important to understand the clear advantages of leveraging vision representation against the numerical sequence values in time series modelling tasks. Some of the recent works have discussed some; yet, to me, not deep or decisive enough. If it is really effective to use image representation of time series, then the path of studying statistical numerical time series methods or even those LLMs leveraging numerical sequence will be ended in the end. Thus, the studying of vision based TS modeling needs a more stronger justifications in terms of theoretical perspective to win this competition.
Q3. This is more or less a positioning paper rather than a research article? I feel that it just presents the argument of the authors. However, I cannot see sufficient technological advancement in terms of TS forecasting methods.