- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed a decomposition-based method for time series modelling. The paper applys multiple decomposition approaches prior to backbone model to extract and expose more feature for the model to dymanically select. In particular, the framework uses Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) and the Hilbert transform to break the input down into Intrinsic Mode Functions (IMFs) and extract instantaneous frequency and amplitude. IMF guide a learnable mask. This mask dynamically splits the time series into a primary component designed to capture structural dynamics and a residual component containing noise. Then, A standard, task-specific backbone model processes the primary component to generate a base prediction and a lightweight residual-aware correction (RC) module processes the residual to recover any structural dynamics that the decomposition stage missed. However, the paper presentation is not very clear and hard to follow, notation system is a bit messy. Technical component such as time-aware mask and loss function needs more details.
Critical strengths
Removing noise can also remove useful information, so keeping the residual and using it to improve the prediction is a reasonable idea.
The framework works with existing models. It can be added to different backbones without changing their internal architecture, which makes it potentially useful in practice.
The paper tests several backbones across forecasting, classification, and anomaly detection, and includes ablations to examine the contributions of decomposition and residual correction.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main idea seems fairly incremental. It combines existing EMD and Hilbert analysis with a simple gate and residual correction. Since the mask is trained through task losses, it is unclear whether it actually separates noise from useful signals or simply divides the input between two models. Comparisons with simpler IMF weights and clearer evidence of noise removal would help.
-
The correction module is basically a standard reservoir RNN with fixed internal weights and a trainable output layer. Its residual awareness mainly comes from taking the residual as input. The experiments show that this choice can work, but it is still unclear what is new about the module.
-
The losses need a clearer explanation. In Eq 12, the correction and fused losses have the same value, but the detach operation changes where gradients flow. Please clarify which components each loss updates, especially whether the correction loss also trains the mask.
-
Table 6 is not clear what "Raw" model is. The context in Qualitative analysis only said backbone.
-
Over comlicated notatino system. I can see many footnote in equation, and some variable dimensionality is not consistent. Some presentation problems:
-
The notation changes between sections.The main text uses for the number of variables and for the number of classes, but the appendix uses for variables instead. Keeping this consistent would make the paper easier to follow.
-
Some window details are unclear. How are the window boundaries rounded, and what happens near the start and end of the sequence? These details should be explained.
-
The two residuals are easy to mix up. One is what remains after EMD, and the other is what the mask sends to the residual branch. It would help to explain directly how both fit into the final decomposition.
Questions for authors
The time-aware mask uses features with clear signal-processing meanings, but its training objective only rewards better task performance. This does not necessarily teach it to distinguish noise from useful dynamics. can the authors show stronger evidence that the learned mask actually supports the proposed denoising interpretation?
Many of my concerns still remain. I will keep my original judgment