- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies teacher-guided post-training for generative temporal video grounding. Its motivation is that token-level distillation does not explicitly align the student’s preferences over complete answers with their temporal localization quality. Geo-OPD combines three objectives: adaptive token-level distillation using two temperature views of the same frozen teacher on student-generated prefixes, imitation of a designated primary teacher answer, and listwise preference learning based on the IoU between teacher-proposed intervals and annotations. It also uses teacher reliability filtering and an offline teacher–student temporal discrepancy score to select training samples. The authors report improvements on three TimeLens-corrected benchmarks and use component ablations and candidate-ranking diagnostics to examine the contributions of the proposed objectives.
Critical strengths
The overall approach is clear, and using interval localization quality to guide the student’s answer preferences is reasonable. The teacher’s primary answer may not be the most accurate, so imitating it alone can leave useful information in other candidates unused. Learning from these quality differences is a useful aspect of the method.
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
- Prior work, including TimeLens (2026), Uncertainties in Temporal Boundary (2022), and Embracing Uncertainty (2021), has discussed errors and subjectivity in temporal boundary annotations. In Geo-OPD, small changes to the annotated boundaries may alter the IoU ranking of teacher candidates. Have the authors examined how stable these rankings are under plausible boundary perturbations?
- The authors explain that pointwise imitation anchors the primary answer’s absolute score, while the listwise objective constrains relative preferences among candidates. This explains the role of the pointwise term, but not why the teacher’s primary answer is chosen as its target. Table 5 shows that the primary answer is often not the highest-IoU candidate in the held-out proposal sets. How would grounding performance change if the pointwise term instead used the highest-IoU teacher candidate against the annotation for each training example, while keeping the candidate sets, other losses, and training budget unchanged?
General Response
Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,
Thank you for your careful reviews and constructive discussion. The reviewers highlighted the gap between token-level distillation and the localization quality of complete answers, the motivation for learning from multiple teacher proposals, and the evidence from component ablations and fixed-candidate ranking analyses. Geo-OPD addresses this gap by combining adaptive token guidance on student-generated prefixes with answer imitation and IoU-guided supervision over complete teacher proposals.
Key findings from the rebuttal
Discussion outcomes
We appreciate the reviewers' suggestions and ask the Area Chair to consider the controlled comparisons and these discussion outcomes when assessing the paper.
Sincerely, The authors of Paper #23628