- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Traditionally, in the multiple instance learning (MIL) field, especially for pathology image classification task, because of hundreds of millions pixels of pathology images, it is impossible to label each pixel by pathologists rather only give a slide-level classification label. So, this transforms WSI classification task to a weakly supervised classification task.
At the same time, to obtain the truly important region of the WSI, the researches usually use attention-based method calculate the attention score to focus high-score patch. But the previous research found these high-score region may not representing the diagnostic related region.
So, aiming at above question, this paper propose a hypothesis testing method to discriminate whether selected patches are obviously different with normal tissue or not, based ABMIL model.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
From the model designs, the proposed method lacks of evident motivation about reference patch selection and design. All section method mainly focus on how to perform statistical inference. But in my view, the selection of reference patches are truly important for the testing and the author only state they use adaptively choice method from a collected patch set.
-
The paper lacks of necessary experiments to support proposed model, such as, the main text only contain one experimental results. I thought the author should carefully revise the paper, perform more experimental designs and consider submit to other publications.
-
There are some statistical terminology, such as type I error in statistical hypothesis testing, these need to give some simplified background introduction or description. This will help other disciplinary reader understand this more clearly.
Questions for authors
Because of my previous review on weakness and negative score now, I thought at the stage, it is much more important for author to improve the manuscript to support proposed method rather than answer my question. So i don't have any question for authors at current stage.