- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes VideoRISE, a "control layer" for black-box video prompt inversion
Critical strengths
(1) The paper studies a practical problem: recovering an editable prompt for a target video when the generator is only accessible as a black box
(2) The framework is modular and attempts to report generator calls, VLM calls, runtime, and monetary cost, which is useful for evaluating query-intensive methods
Critical weaknesses
(1) Why does Section 4 claim to report -values, Wilcoxon tests, 95% bootstrap intervals, sweeps over and , tier escalation frequencies, and trajectory/failure figures when none of them exist in the paper? Maybe I miss some parts?
(2) Scores computed from different metric subsets are not necessarily comparable, yet the exact reevaluation and checkpoint-update policy is not given. Table 4 even presents “Fixed evaluation” as an ablation, further confusing what “fixed” means.
(3) The source of the 60 target videos is unclear, even though it matters whether they are real videos or outputs of the same Wan
(4) Videorise is essentially an existing VLM prompt optimizer wrapped with best-so-far retention, rollback, and patience-based early stopping. These are standard search practices. Moreover, the main search-only baseline removes checkpoint recovery, making it unnecessarily weak: any reasonable optimizer should return its best observed candidate rather than its final mutation.
Questions for authors
See above, and one more question: why the figure 3/4/5 are so blurred and the framework figure 1/2 look strange? Can author elaborate more on this issue?