- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a radiance field representation for noel view synthesis, based on tetrahedralization of space, where the vertices carry density and directionally-varying radiance. This allows for an efficient radiance estimation along any ray. Similar approaches exist (Radiance MEshes, RadiantFoam, SVRaster); the novelty here is in the reversible subdivision operations that automatically adapt the vertex density to important regions.
Critical strengths
Overall, this is a useful direction; alternative approaches to Gaussian splatting or NeRF could become very important if they are shown to be more robust and/or amenable to clean adaptiveness heuristics. The metrics reported are promising.
Critical weaknesses
The fundamental issue with the current version of the paper is that it shows very few visual results, and that it reports no results (visual or numerical) on real scenes reconstructed from photographs. It is impossible to judge the kinds of artifacts the method could lead to in more complex cases, from so few experimental data. In my opinion, the viability of the paper for publication completely depends on resolving these omissions. The writing could also be improved, but that is not the critical issue.
Questions for authors
Was real data (object or full scene) tested with this method?