- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper analyzes the convergence of Adjoint Sampling (AS), focusing on stability, exploration of a missing mode, and correction of the relative weights of discovered modes. For Gaussian and 2-mixture Gaussian models, they show that AS can be unstable for Gaussian and exponential time is needed to sample a missing mode or adjust the relative weights for 2-mixture Gaussians. Numerical experiments extend the theory to more general target distributions.
Critical strengths
The authors tackle an interesting problem. I think the paper is well organized: it introduces the reader to the problem, focuses on the theory, and then presents experiments that both illustrate the theoretical results and extend beyond that. A nice choice by the authors is to begin with the Gaussian analysis, which is relatively easy to follow. The results themselves seem significant.
Critical weaknesses
I believe the introduction, especially the paragraph about AS, is too dense. As I wasn't familiar with the approach, I found that paragraph quite hard to read. I believe the paper would benefit from using the additional page provided by the camera-ready version to make parts of the text, especially Section 2, plainer and less compressed. Section 3 is also difficult to follow, as the theoretical results are listed with explanatory comments postponed after their statements.
There is also a typo in Eq. 2: the authors should have used instead of .
Questions for authors
-
How important are the equal component variances and the choice of means in the multimodal analysis? Would similar estimates hold for more general 2-component Gaussian mixtures?
-
Since higher dimensions and a large number of modes make the problem much harder, do you think the same theoretical analysis can be extended to such cases?
Author-Reviewer Discussion ends in 1 day, 12 hours
Dear authors and reviewers,
Thank you to the authors for their detailed responses and the revised manuscript. The discussion period closes in about a day and a half, so this is the last chance for a direct exchange before the reviewer-AC discussion starts on Nov 19.
Reviewer nbsd: I haven’t yet seen a reply from you. Please read the authors’ response and the revision, which address the points raised in your review, and let us know whether your concerns have been addressed. Please update your recommendation if your assessment has changed. Even a short acknowledgment helps.
Reviewer CWQv: thank you for engaging. The authors replied on Nov 16 to your latest comment and added new experiments. Please let us know whether these settle your remaining points, and if some do not, which ones, so that they can be discussed before the period ends.
Reviewer 1hFk: thank you for your reply. No further action is needed unless you wish to comment on the discussion.
Authors: please be ready to answer any follow-up questions in the time left, focusing on the points most likely to affect the decision. I encourage everyone to keep the exchange focused on the technical content of the paper.
Thank you all for keeping the discussion constructive and timely.
Your AC