- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper discusses a question: when more inference computation is available, should an inverse solver refine one reconstruction longer or explore alternatives? Their answer is to design a global-before-local (GBL) inference, which advances multiple candidates, selects a subset, and completes the retained candidates with the same solver.
Critical strengths
- The question of whether a generative inverse solver should choose longer refinement or broader search is analyzed quite clearly. The paper demonstrates that the optimal strategy varies depending on the task, offering valuable insights for future work.
- The designs of method are reasonable. By optimizing the sampling strategy, this method achieves improvements over Flower and FlowDPS on some settings.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors may have overlooked the impact of guidance strength of generative inverse solvers on reconstruction performance. For a baseline, a hyperparameter such as FlowDPS and FLOWER can be used to adjust the strength of its data consistency, which has a significant impact on the results. In this paper, the number of steps in the baseline methods was adjusted to facilitate a fair comparison. However, maintaining the original default guidance strength under these modified settings may not be appropriate. Furthermore, the authors utilized a set of development images to select strategies for the test set and train GBL-P. In practice, methods such as FlowDPS and FLOWER could also leverage such development images to determine the optimal guidance strength for that specific dataset. Consequently, the above factors may make the comparison unfair.
- In a real-world setting, the limitations of this method are as follows: (1) The approach relies on development cohorts to determine the strategy applied to all images in the test set. However, in practical scenarios, the development cohorts may differ, and the optimal configuration for each individual image might also vary. (2) Most of the results in this paper focus on strategies optimized for PSNR. However, the balance between fidelity and perceptual is also an issue worth considering.
- The readability of the experimental section could be improved. Many of the settings and terms introduced (e.g., single predictor and predictor ensemble in Table 3) are unexplained. The figures and tables follow the logical flow of the explanation, but they lack a direct comparison between the baseline and the two proposed models across all settings.
Questions for authors
- Please provide a table directly comparing the baseline with the two proposed models across all settings (on at least one dataset).
- Please specify the guidance strength used for your methods and the baseline.
- Please provide a table comparing the performance of the baseline method (Flower or FlowDPS) and the two models proposed in this paper as the guidance strength varies.
Dear Reviewer 6u5E,
Thank you for your detailed review and helpful suggestions. We have added direct comparisons, tested guidance sensitivity and independent tuning, and clarified the experimental settings.
W3+Q1. Direct Comparison and Experimental Clarity
GBL-P achieves higher mean PSNR than both GBL-M and the single-path baseline on AFHQ-Cat central and irregular inpainting under the same 548 solver-update budget. On central inpainting, the single path, GBL-M, and GBL-P achieve 13.87, 14.46, and 14.86 dB, respectively. On irregular inpainting, their PSNR values are 15.22, 15.11, and 15.80 dB. On phase retrieval, GBL-M has slightly higher PSNR than GBL-P. Table 4 provides the direct comparison across all three settings, including LPIPS. We also clarified the predictor settings in Table 3 and Appendix B.2: the single predictor uses 64 training images, while the ensemble averages five predictors, each trained on four of five image-level folds of 192 training images.
W1+Q2–Q3. Guidance Strength and Fairness
GBL-P's PSNR advantage over the single-path baseline on AFHQ-Cat central inpainting remains across the tested guidance strengths and after independent tuning. Our main comparisons use the same guidance settings for GBL and the single path: FlowDPS uses three corrections per update with η=15, and FLOWER uses likelihood weight B=1 with an Armijo line search, as specified in Section 5.1.
We further tested three FlowDPS guidance strengths on AFHQ-Cat central inpainting, generating new trajectories and training a separate GBL-P predictor for each strength.
PSNR (dB) on 128 held-out images. Note that Table 5 (in the revised manuscript) also reports LPIPS.
GBL-P improves mean PSNR over Single548 by 0.90–1.06 dB across these strengths. When GBL-P and Single548 select guidance independently using the same 64 development images, both choose η=30 (FlowDPS guidance step size). For GBL-P, each development image is evaluated using a predictor trained without that image. GBL-P then achieves a 1.046 dB gain, improving PSNR on 97 of 128 images. The CelebA phase-retrieval gain also remains 3.680 dB after independent guidance selection. These results are detailed in Appendices D.6–D.7 and Table 21.
W2. Generalization and Perceptual Quality
We extended the evaluation to examine when broader search is useful and how PSNR and perceptual quality may differ. In CelebA central inpainting with independently selected guidance, GBL-P achieves the lowest LPIPS, while the single path retains the highest PSNR, as shown in Table 20. We also added a super-resolution experiment in Section 5.5, where development results correctly predict that single-path inference will outperform GBL-P on separate held-out images. Adapting the candidate count and selection time to individual images and changes in data distributions remains future work.
Thanks,
Authors