- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Adapter-Conditioned Recovery Pruning (ACRP) for visual grounding. ACRP augments frozen DINOv3 and CLIP encoders with visual and textual recovery adapters. During joint training, the adapters are supervised to approximate compact signatures of candidate-removed attention-head and MLP responses, and the resulting recoverability signal is combined with task and structural criteria to allocate a global pruning budget. The model also includes multi-level visual fusion and an evidence-preserving token condenser. Experiments on four visual-grounding benchmarks, together with component and pruning ablations, report competitive accuracy with a 0.38% adapter update ratio relative to the pretrained encoders and approximately 40% physical backbone pruning.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important and practical problem. Standard PEFT reduces the number of updated parameters but generally leaves inference cost unchanged, whereas structured pruning improves deployment efficiency but may cause task-specific representation shifts. Coupling the two objectives is therefore well motivated.
- The experimental evaluation is broad and reasonably comprehensive. The method is evaluated on four public visual-grounding benchmarks and compared with visual-grounding, PEFT, and structured-pruning baselines. The paper also includes several components, pruning, recovery, and token-condensation ablations.
- The deployment-oriented reporting is relatively thorough. Beyond grounding accuracy, the paper reports parameter count, storage, GFLOPs, peak inference memory, and latency under multiple physical pruning ratios, providing a useful view of the accuracy–efficiency trade-off.
Critical weaknesses
- The efficiency and attribution claims are not fully supported. The 0.38% ratio excludes other trainable components, while heterogeneous backbones and insufficiently specified pruning baselines make it difficult to attribute the gains specifically to recovery-aware pruning.
- The recovery objective is only indirectly validated. The paper does not establish that its compact signature error correlates with downstream IoU degradation, and the relevant evidence is limited to one dataset and one random seed.
Questions for authors
- The reported 0.38% is clearly defined as adapter-only overhead. Could you also report the total trainable parameters and a module-wise breakdown, and clarify whether the comparison in Table 2 remains favorable under the complete trainable-parameter budget?
- Table 1 provides a useful overview, but the compared methods use different backbones. Could you provide the same backbone results for several representative baselines and report variation across multiple random seeds?