- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studied "handoff" strategies between a capable model and an efficient model. It started by understanding how handoff works (what to hand off, and when to handoff). Then it labelled training data and trained a light handoff detector (AgentBaton) which pushes the accuracy-cost frontier for agentic tasks.
Critical strengths
- I applaud the overall narrative with empirical evidence backing up and motivating each step. It is a pleasure to read. Well executed!
- Section 4 (where AgentBaton training data is curated) is my favorite. And I learned something new about when an effective handoff opportunity arises.
- Empirical evidence (compared to query routing and the cost effective frontier) is strong.
Critical weaknesses
None.
Questions for authors
Clarification questions.
- The initial investigation around logfile vs. context transfer is quite nice. Have you considered explicit prompt the strong model to produce a handoff file (/handoff)? My hypothesis is capable model will produce a clear direction for efficient model to pick up and may improve accuracy.
- About training data curation: does the labels agree across different models / where human would switch to handoff? Human study of N(10) will be sufficient.
Just one minor confusion: why isn't "handoff" is in the title? That is all this paper about. "Model collaboration" had me mistaken the theme for multi-agent collaboration (where agents chat back and forth).
3 comments
My questions are answered. Thanks for your reply, additional experiments, and for conducting this research. Best of luck.
Thank you for your kind words! We would also like to thank you again for your recognition of our work and the valuable questions you raised, which have helped us improve our paper. Finally, we truly appreciate your time and effort in reviewing our paper and participating in the discussion. Have a nice day!
Thank you for the time and care devoted to reading our paper and for the encouraging feedback. We appreciate your recognition of the empirical motivation behind our design choices, the insights from our training-data curation, and the comparisons with query routing and the cost–accuracy frontier.
Thank you for the suggestion. We tested this at the original AgentBaton handoff point: GLM or Kimi uses the full context to generate a /handoff file summarizing progress, evidence, unresolved issues, and next steps. Qwen retains the full history and replayed workspace, with an additional prompt inviting it to read /handoff.
The above results show that adding /handoff does not consistently improve accuracy and increases cost in all four settings.
Although our annotation aims to identify the optimal handoff point, practical use does not require exact turn-level precision: a suitable handoff can occur after the observed task-progress patterns emerge. We also conducted a human-check case study on 40 samples, finding that human inspection agreed with the appropriateness of the annotated handoff point in 34 cases (85%).
Thank you for this question. Our initial idea was that this simple yet effective “single handoff” could itself be regarded as a form of model collaboration. However, we agree that, since this paper does not analyze many other forms of collaboration, including “handoff” in the title would better highlight its core theme.