- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces NeuReL, a framework for neuron identity matching across activity records. NeuReL jointly uses geometric and activity relations to build population relation embeddings, and learns individual representations for each neuron. The matching score is computed by embedding similarity and temporal relation correction process. Experiments show that leveraging geometric and activity signals together improves matching accuracy over baselines using only geometric or activity signals.
Critical strengths
1.The problem is important in neuroscience and remains underexplored from a ML perspective. The authors evaluate under cross-animal matching for C.elegans and longitudinal matching for zebrafish, demonstrating the applicability of the method under distinct settings. 2.The idea of using population information for identifying the neuron is well-motivated, and embedding the geometric and activity relation as relation-conditioned attention is intuitive. 3.The authors compare against geometry-only and activity-only methods, as well as conduct correlation analysis and case studies, supporting the claim that activity and geometry information are complementary.
Critical weaknesses
1.Supervised learning requires massive human-labeled datasets, and the annotation may become noisier as we scale to animals with more neurons. However, the dependence on annotation quantity and quality is not sufficiently characterized in the paper. Controlled experiments on reduced and corrupted annotations could help to better understand the method’s practical reliability. 2.Missing atlas relations are treated as observed zero-valued relations. For example, there is a considerable portion of directed atlas entries on Kato that correspond to identity pairs that were never jointly annotated. These entries are assigned to zero but still contribute to the relation-discrepancy penalty. This conflates missing information with an observed relation and may penalize otherwise correct matches.
Questions for authors
1.For the C. elegans datasets, where canonical neuronal identities are available, how would NeuReL compare with a direct identity classifier using the same multimodal population encoder, followed by Hungarian assignment to enforce one-to-one correspondence? 2.How does performance change as the fraction of annotated training neurons decreases or incorrect correspondence labels are introduced? 3.Could the authors perform an ablation by masking out the unannotated pairs (see W2) and test whether the current zero-vector treatment introduces additional error?
Thank you for your clarification and additional experiments. I will maintain the original rating.