- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
VGSSC addresses monocular indoor semantic scene completion using a surface-aware Voxel–Gaussian representation. It encodes signed voxel-to-surface depth offsets as learnable tokens, initializes Gaussians from image and voxel features, and transfers refined Gaussian information back to a voxel decoder. Training-free probability fusion extends the model to online prediction. Experiments on Occ-ScanNet and EmbodiedOcc-ScanNet include component ablations and backbone and efficiency comparisons.
Critical strengths
- Using the predicted surface as a common reference gives the hybrid representation a clear rationale. Distance tokens distinguish voxels sharing image features, while Gaussians incorporate voxel context and return locally aggregated information to the voxel field.
- The reported improvements are substantial. Removing distance encoding or Gaussian assistance reduces single-frame mIoU by 1.76 and 2.00 points, supporting the usefulness of both components.
Critical weaknesses
- The central fusion mechanism remains underspecified. Equation (7) does not explain the fusion architecture, and Appendix A.2 does not fully specify how support-weight gating combines the feature and semantic streams. Gaussian anchor count and sampling, and the online observation-weight function, also remain unclear. These omissions affect reproduction of the core method and online results.
- The distance-encoding comparison is difficult to assess because the Continuous Offset implementation and Fixed Scale value are unspecified. The unexplained geometric IoU drop for Continuous Offset further weakens the evidence supporting the discrete-token design, although it does not establish an experimental error.
Questions for authors
- Could you provide the complete fusion architecture, including support-weight gating, and specify the Gaussian anchor count and sampling strategy?
- How are the Continuous Offset and Fixed Scale baselines implemented? Please confirm and explain the Continuous Offset result of 56.54 IoU / 56.20 mIoU, compared with 64.80 / 55.40 without distance encoding.
- What is the exact formula for the online observation weight , including confidence estimation and free-space/behind-surface weighting?
- Since VGSSC without Gaussian assistance already achieves 55.16 mIoU, compared with 51.88 for GPOcc, could the authors clarify whether the improvements are evaluated under matched backbone, pretraining, and depth supervision settings?
If the authors can address most of my concerns, I would be willing to raise my score.