- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DiffUnlearn, a method to generate perturbed training images to suppress learning of user-designated semantic categories while preserving non-target utility. It optimizes diffusion latents using image–text alignment, attention suppression, and visual fidelity losses under a pixel-level perturbation budget. Its main contribution is a diffusion-based approach to category-selective protection through unlearnable examples. The authors conduct experiments across multiple datasets and models, and the results support the method’s ability.
Critical strengths
-
The method provides a coherent approach to selectively inhibiting target-category learning while maintaining visual fidelity, giving the work methodological merit. The overall framework and individual components are rationally designed and logically clear.
-
The experiments evaluate both target-category learning suppression and non-target utility preservation across multiple datasets and models, with supporting ablation studies. This directly tests the selective protection capability and strengthens the evidence for the method’s effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
-
I find the specific task setting novel, and the method achieves promising results. However, its practical value remains my main concern. Users would typically want to protect a particular person, character, or IP rather than a broad semantic category. Could the authors clarify what concrete user need is addressed by making a designated category difficult to learn, and how this translates into a practical protection benefit?
-
The main components have precedents in related work, so I find the methodological novelty somewhat limited. The overall design appears to be an effective combination of existing ideas, but lacks deeper insights and analysis.
Questions for authors
-
As discussed in the critical weaknesses, the authors should first explain how the proposed framework can be applied in practical scenarios and what its key new design is. What evidence shows that its advantages go beyond a simple combination of existing components?
-
If the trainer (attacker) introduces additional clean images of the same target category from their own sources, could this undermine the claimed protection? Does the protection depend on the proportion of clean data?
-
The anonymous code currently appears insufficient to reproduce the results, and its settings do not fully match those reported in the paper.