- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes QMORE, a hybrid quantum–classical framework for image–text retrieval. It introduces a shared variational quantum encoder with lightweight modality-specific adapters to improve parameter efficiency.They also use a rank-fusion strategy to enhance retrieval robustness. Moreover, authors test their method on three datasets including SVO Probes, Captioned CIFAR-10, and Flickr30K, which shows the clear improvement over the classical baselines and parameter-matched quantum. And the robustness is further tested under simulated quantum hardware noise.
Critical strengths
1.The paper identifies two practical challenges in quantum multimodal retrieval: parameter redundancy across modalities and performance variability across independent training runs. The overall framework is clearly motivated, and its components are logically connected to the identified challenges. 2.The authors conduct experiments on three datasets, including SVO Probes, Captioned CIFAR-10, and Flickr30k, demonstrating consistent improvements over parameter-matched quantum and classical baselines. The paper also includes parameter-scaling comparisons, component ablation studies, and evaluations of different ensemble strategies. These experiments provide useful evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed framework and help distinguish the contributions of its individual components.
Critical weaknesses
1.The experiments mainly compare against lightweight, parameter-matched baselines without directly evaluating established image–text retrieval models such as CLIP. Furthermore, retrieval is evaluated within 200-candidate subsets rather than standard full-gallery settings, limiting the practical significance and comparability of the reported results. 2.Insufficient evidence of quantum-specific advantages. When applying the same diversity-aware fusion strategy, QMORE improves Flickr30k R@1 only from 13.5% to 14.4% over the strongest classical baseline. Moreover, the noise robustness experiments rely entirely on simulation rather than actual quantum hardware, leaving the practical benefits of the quantum encoder insufficiently established.
Questions for authors
1.In Table 4, QMORE achieves 14.4% R@1 on Flickr30k, compared to 13.5% for the shared classical baseline using the same accuracy–diversity fusion strategy. Could the authors provide additional experiments with stronger parameter-matched classical architectures to better demonstrate that the improvements originate from the quantum encoder rather than parameter sharing or ensemble fusion? 2. The experiments evaluate retrieval within subsets of 200 image–text pairs rather than using a standard full-gallery retrieval setting. Could the authors investigate whether the reported improvements remain consistent with larger candidate pools?