- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DisPV is a paper on Parameterized Equation Discovery (PED): addressing "parameter-induced structural ambiguity"—where the same symbolic skeleton exhibits vastly different distributions under different parameters, or even becomes observationally aliased with an incorrect structure—it proposes the first pre-training framework specifically designed for PED. At its core is a dual-stream architecture: after encoding multi-environment data with a shared SetTransformer, the skeleton stream extracts environment-invariant symbolic structures via cross-environment contrastive learning, while the parameter stream in parallel regresses the instance-specific constants, explicitly disentangling the "universal skeleton" from the "instance parameters" at the representation level, followed by lightweight genetic programming refinement. Its main contributions are: formalizing the structural ambiguity challenge of PED, proposing this dual-stream pre-training framework, and achieving a state-of-the-art R2=0.900R2=0.900 on synthetic and physics-inspired benchmarks, while being over 10× faster at inference than search-based baselines.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a clear formulation of PED’s central challenge, parameter-induced structural ambiguity, distinguishing between distributional shift and structural aliasing through an illustrative underdamped oscillator example. It also highlights a key limitation of existing methods, including PySR, PhySO, and MSR, which enforce cross-environment consistency through optimization objectives but lack data-driven structural priors. Building on this insight, the authors introduce a pre-training framework specifically designed for PED, using a dual-stream architecture to explicitly disentangle structural skeletons from parameters at the representation level.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper reports the maximum R² across 10 independent runs (best-of-N), which systematically overestimates the reliability of the method and masks its variance. It is recommended to report the median / mean ± standard deviation together with the success rate.
- The manuscript contains many typos, such as
hyperapameter,candidatas,Montle Carlo,parameteriedetc.
Questions for authors
- The manuscript states that “Each experiment is repeated over 10 independent runs and the maximum are reported.” We wonder why only the maximum values are presented. Could the mean and variance also be provided?
I thank the authors for their rebuttal, which has addressed most of my concerns. However, given my limited expertise in this area, I do not feel sufficiently confident to make a further judgment. Therefore, I will maintain my original score.