acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Selective Shortcut Value Learning for Long-Horizon Offline Goal-Conditioned RL

Abstract

One source of difficulty in long-horizon offline goal-conditioned reinforcement learning (GCRL) is that sparse rewards must propagate through many Bellman updates before primitive actions become well separated in value. We introduce Selective Shortcut Value Learning (SSVL), which shortens this propagation directly in primitive action-value learning using stopped trajectory segments and a single-discount shortcut continuation. A frozen shortcut-aligned reference selectively compresses segment rewards, while an auxiliary Shortcut Value Consistency (SVC) loss helps the separately learned IQL state value preserve shortcut relations; both are used only during training, and deployment remains a single primitive goal-conditioned policy. We analyze how shorter propagation strengthens progress-state separation and separately characterize the logged-continuation conditions under which shortcut regression targets preserve primitive-action preference. Across diverse state-based and visual OGBench tasks, SSVL is competitive with strong offline GCRL methods, including hierarchical approaches.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Offline Reinforcement Learning, Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning, Long-Horizon Reinforcement Learning, Temporal Abstraction, Value Learning, Implicit Q-Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 32%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.50 over 4 reviews, above 68% of the others.
Reviewer_yhNGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Selective Shortcut Value Learning (SSVL) for long-horizon offline goal-conditioned reinforcement learning. The method introduces single-discount shortcut targets into primitive action-value learning, uses a frozen reference value function to selectively compress segment rewards, and adds a Shortcut Value Consistency (SVC) loss to regularize state-value learning. Experiments on state-based and visual OGBench tasks show competitive results against several existing methods. However, the methodological novelty is somewhat limited, and the theoretical analysis and experimental evidence do not fully establish the necessity and general effectiveness of the proposed components.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a relevant problem in long-horizon offline GCRL, where sparse rewards make value propagation and primitive-action selection difficult.
  2. SSVL retains a single primitive goal-conditioned policy at inference without requiring hierarchical planning or subgoal prediction.
  3. The method achieves promising results on several OGBench tasks, particularly state-based manipulation and visual AntMaze navigation. The paper also includes useful ablations of its main components.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological novelty relative to existing temporal abstraction methods is limited. The main idea of replacing the conventional multi-step discount factor \gamma^kwith a single discount factor \gamma is closely related to the temporal abstraction mechanism used in OTA (Ahn et al., 2025). The main distinction appears to be applying shortcut supervision to primitive action-value learning rather than the high-level state-value learning used by OTA. Although this change introduces a different credit-assignment setting, the underlying shortcut propagation mechanism remains largely the same. The authors should clarify what new learning principle is introduced beyond transferring existing temporal abstraction to the primitive-action critic, and whether the performance gains can be attributed to this modification alone.
  2. The theoretical results rely on restrictive assumptions and provide limited guarantees for the proposed algorithm. Proposition 3.1 establishes improved normalized value separation on an idealized fixed-length chain, but this setting does not capture the stochastic transitions and heterogeneous trajectory continuations encountered in offline RL. More importantly, Theorem 3.4 relies on Assumption 3.3, which requires the logged continuation to preserve a positive preference margin between primitive actions. This is precisely the property that may fail in long-horizon offline datasets. The theorem therefore provides a conditional target-ordering guarantee rather than demonstrating that SSVL can generally recover correct primitive-action preferences. The authors should discuss how frequently these assumptions are satisfied in the evaluated datasets and provide empirical evidence connecting the theoretical conditions to actual policy performance.
  3. The proposed selective reward compression has limited independent contribution in the reported ablations. In Figure 2(a), replacing exact k-step propagation with single-discount continuation already improves success from 41.5 to 86.1. The matched Flat OTA-style variant achieves 88.3, while selective SSVL without SVC reaches 91.2. These results indicate that most of the improvement comes from the existing single-discount shortcut mechanism, whereas the additional benefit of selective reward compression is relatively modest in this experiment. Although Figure 2(b) shows benefits from a shortcut-aligned reference on another task, it does not fully establish the general necessity of selective compression. The authors should provide broader comparisons between uniform shortcut targets and selective targets to clarify the independent contribution of the proposed selection mechanism.
  4. The consistency objective is not fully consistent with the selective critic target. Eq. 30 imposes the unit-reward shortcut relation (V\left(s_t,g\right)=-1+\gamma V\left(s_t^+,g\right))on all sampled nonterminal shortcut edges. However, Eqs. 27–28 use different reward targets depending on whether a segment is accepted or rejected by the reference gate. For rejected segments, the critic retains the accumulated segment reward, while SVC still enforces the unit-reward relation. This creates a mismatch between the supervision applied to the critic and the state-value function. The authors acknowledge that SVC is auxiliary, but do not sufficiently analyze whether these potentially conflicting objectives introduce bias or instability. A comparison with a consistency loss constructed from the same selective targets would help justify the current design.
  5. The experimental results are inconsistent across tasks, and the limitations of shortcut learning are not sufficiently investigated. Table 1 shows substantial performance differences across environments. For example, SSVL achieves only 23 on AntMaze large-stitch compared with OTA's 84, and 24 on Visual Cube double-noisy compared with OTA's 65. Similarly, SSVL obtains 67 on HumanoidMaze giant-navigate, substantially below OTA's 92. These failures are particularly relevant because the method targets long-horizon goal-conditioned learning. Although the authors discuss possible limitations in primitive-action supervision, the explanation remains speculative. The paper should provide more direct analysis of whether these failures arise from incorrect shortcut action ordering, unreliable logged continuations, or the selective reference mechanism.
Questions for authors

The paper presents a practical extension of shortcut-based value learning to primitive-action policies and reports promising results on several challenging tasks. However, the central propagation mechanism is closely related to existing temporal abstraction methods, particularly OTA, and the additional contributions from selective reward compression and value consistency are not consistently established. The theoretical analysis provides conditional action-ordering results but does not directly guarantee improved policy learning under realistic offline data distributions. Given the limited methodological novelty and the substantial performance degradation on several long-horizon tasks, the current evidence is not sufficient to fully support the paper's main contribution claims.

Reviewer_A4nKOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Selective Shortcut Value Learning (SSVL) for long-horizon offline goal-conditioned reinforcement learning. The method combines single-discount shortcut targets, reference-selective reward compression, and an auxiliary Shortcut Value Consistency (SVC) loss, while retaining a primitive goal-conditioned policy at deployment. Results on OGBench are competitive across several settings. However, the contributions of individual components across task families and the empirical relevance of the action-ordering analysis remain insufficiently established.

Critical strengths
  • The method requires neither subgoal prediction nor planning at deployment.

  • Controlled navigation experiments provide clear evidence for the benefits of single-discount continuation.

  • The paper carefully distinguishes target-ordering guarantees from learned-policy performance and explicitly discusses the limitations imposed by logged continuation.

Critical weaknesses
  • The source of the gains at (K=1) is unclear. Table 4 specifies (K=1) for cube-double-play-v0, where neither multi-step discount compression nor selective reward compression changes the target. Nevertheless, SSVL substantially outperforms the reported GCIQL baseline on this task. A matched GCIQL+SVC comparison, controlling for architecture, policy learning, and training configuration, would help determine whether these gains arise from SVC or other implementation differences.

  • Component attribution is concentrated on navigation tasks. In Table 6, where SVC is disabled, single-discount continuation accounts for the largest improvement on antmaze-large-navigate-v0, with selectivity providing a smaller additional gain. The other navigation diagnostics offer useful evidence for selectivity and SVC, but do not establish how consistently these benefits extend to manipulation and visual tasks. Matched comparisons between uniform and selective shortcut targets, both with and without SVC, would clarify the contribution of each component across task families.

  • The action-ordering explanation lacks direct empirical validation. Assumption 3.3 requires better primitive actions to retain an advantage in the probability of favorable shortcut outcomes under logged continuation. Accurate reference estimation alone does not establish this alignment. Although the paper appropriately acknowledges this limitation, its reference and gate diagnostics do not directly test the required action-level relationship. Measurements of action-ranking agreement across different continuation qualities and shortcut lengths would strengthen the connection between the theoretical analysis and observed performance.

Questions for authors
  • What explains the gains on tasks using (K=1), and how does SSVL compare with a matched GCIQL+SVC baseline?

  • How does full SSVL compare with uniform shortcut targets combined with SVC across navigation, manipulation, and visual tasks?

  • Under what empirical conditions does Assumption 3.3 hold or fail, particularly as logged-continuation quality and shortcut length vary?

1 comment

Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments, which substantially address my main concerns. The representation controls make the experimental interpretation more credible, but also narrow the evidence attributable to shortcut learning, since much of the improvement at K=1 comes from representation choices. The new cross-task ablations and action-ordering analyses strengthen the remaining evidence. Overall, I will maintain my score.

Reviewer_q3ddOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2(+1)
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work proposes a goal-conditioned value learning method based on "shortcut Bellman propagation". Instead of standard Bellman propagation, which attenuates the reward signal exponentially with the discount factor, shortcut propagation treats a K-step segment as a single propagation step. The authors argue that this reduces the effective horizon of the MDP and helps preserve the relative ordering of value estimations. They also provide some theoretical analysis about why this shortcut value may improve long-horizon learning while preserving the ordering induced by the original Q value. Experiments on continuous control environments (OGBench) show that their proposed algorithm, SSVL, performs competitively with existing GCRL algorithms.

Critical strengths

[S1] Benchmark performance While the experiment in Section 5 is not comprehensive, it shows some notable strength: SSVL is comparable to strong hierarchical GCRL algorithms such as HIQL and OTA in maze navigation tasks, where non-hierarchical methods generally perform poorly. Also, it clearly outperforms both hierarchical and non-hierarchical methods in manipulation tasks (e.g. Cube, Scene).


[S2] Motivation The motivation behind the shortcut Bellman propagation is reasonable. Exponential attenuation of the reward signal is the fundamental challenge of long-horizon GCRL, and this paper directly addresses the challenge by introducing SSVL.

Critical weaknesses

[W1] Overstated or redundant theoretical analysis

[W1-1] Theorem 3.4 relies on a strong assumption that presupposes the central alignment property.

Assumption 3.3 directly assumes that a better primitive action has a sufficiently higher probability of producing favorable shortcut progress under the logged continuation. However, whether shortcut outcomes preserve information about primitive-action preferences is precisely the central theoretical challenge identified by the paper. Given this assumption, Theorem 3.4 largely follows from an algebraic decomposition of the shortcut target and elementary estimation-error bounds. Furthermore, the resulting guarantee still requires the potentially negative endpoint-value margin BKB_K to be sufficiently large relative to the error. Consequently, the theorem provides limited insight into why the proposed method should preserve primitive-action preferences in practice.

[W1-2] Proposition 3.2 is essentially an algebraic identity.

The proposition states that the uniform shortcut target preserves primitive-action preferences if and only if BK>0B_K>0. However, BKB_K is defined as exactly the difference between the expected shortcut targets for two actions, after canceling their common reward term. Thus, the proposition essentially restates that the shortcut target preserves action ordering when its expected action gap has the correct sign. It does not establish any substantive relationship between BKB_K and the optimal primitive-action values Qγ⋆Q_\gamma^\star, nor does it characterize when the required condition should hold.

[W1-3] Obscure and unnecessarily complicated notations

Many of the results in Section 3 present relatively simple insights that could be explained in a few lines, but instead introduce unnecessarily complicated notation and mathematical objects. For instance, Proposition 3.1 introduces an additional function Uξ,cU_{\xi,c} rather than directly comparing how value ordering attenuate under shortcut and exact propagation. Proposition 3.2 devotes nearly half a page to introducing new notation for what ultimately amounts to the simple identity ΔK=BK\Delta_K = B_K, while Theorem 3.4 introduces yet another collection of notation to establish its result. I acknowledge that some of these definitions help avoid repetitive expressions in the derivations. However, given the limited contribution of the theoretical results discussed above, the amount of additional notation seems difficult to justify. This not only makes it harder for readers to grasp the central ideas of the paper, but may also overstate the theoretical contributions relative to what the results actually establish.


[W2] Lack of rigorous definitions for central theoretical quantities

Several key quantities are introduced without precise mathematical definitions. In particular, V(K)V^{(K)} is described merely as "the population value entering the K-shortcut target," without specifying the Bellman operator, policy, or optimization objective that defines it. Similarly, Vref(K)V_{\mathrm{ref}}^{(K)} is introduced as a population reference without a rigorous characterization. The relationships among these quantities, their learned approximations, and the original optimal value function Qγ⋆Q_\gamma^\star remain unclear. This makes it difficult to interpret the theoretical results or understand how they relate to the proposed algorithm.


[W3] Limited empirical analysis

Appendix E.2 reports trajectory order consistency and geometric progress precision, but neither directly verifies the action-conditioned acceptance gap required by Assumption 3.3. More fundamentally, although the paper attributes its improvements to stronger value separation and more robust action ordering, it does not directly evaluate whether the learned shortcut values achieve better progress ordering or primitive-action ranking than conventional Bellman backups. The reported policy-performance improvements are encouraging, but they do not establish the proposed theoretical explanation. I strongly encourage the authors to add direct comparisons with baseline methods (e.g. IVL, IQL, OTA) on order consistency or action ordering.

Questions for authors

[Q1] Does SSVL improve the quality of the learned value function?

Is there empirical evidence that the value functions learned by SSVL exhibit better trajectory order consistency or action ordering (primitive preference) than those learned by baseline methods (e.g., GCIQL, GCIVL, or OTA)? While Appendix E.2 evaluates the trajectory order consistency of the frozen reference, it does not directly compare the quality of the downstream learned values against baseline methods.

[Q2] How does SSVL interact with value-function architectures?

Prior studies [1–4] have highlighted the importance of architectural inductive bias in learning goal-conditioned value functions, particularly in long-horizon sparse-reward environments. An important practical question is whether the proposed SSVL objective remains effective when combined with the structured value-function architectures proposed in these works (e.g., metric- or quasimetric-based parameterizations). To what extent are the benefits of SSVL complementary to those of architectural inductive biases, and can the SSVL objective alone compensate for differences in value-function architectures?

[Q3] Is there empirical evidence supporting Assumption 3.3?

Appendix E.2 provides indirect evidence that the frozen reference identifies segments exhibiting goal progress. However, these diagnostics do not directly establish the action-conditioned alignment between primitive action preferences and shortcut preference required by Assumption 3.3. Could the authors provide more direct empirical evidence for this assumption, for instance, by measuring whether better primitive actions systematically have higher gate acceptance probabilities under logged continuations?

References

[1] Wang et al. "Optimal Goal-Reaching Reinforcement Learning via Quasimetric Learning." ICML 2023.

[2] Liu et al. "Metric Residual Network for Sample Efficient Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning." AAAI 2023.

[3] Myers et al. "Offline Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning with Quasimetric Representations." NeurIPS 2025.

[4] Kang et al. "Latent Representation Alignment for Offline Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning." ICML 2026.

1 comment

Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns.

The revised manuscript substantially improves the clarity of the theoretical definitions. In particular, the explicit definition of the shortcut Bellman operator and the population reference value, as well as the reclassification of Proposition 3.2 as an observation, address several of my concerns.

I also find the additional experiments valuable. The experiments in C1 provide direct empirical evidence supporting the proposed motivation, and the analysis in C2 offers empirical support for Assumption 3.3. The architectural ablations are also informative and adequately address my question about structured value function parameterizations.

Given these improvements, I am raising my rating from weak reject to weak accept.

However, I still have concerns about the theoretical presentation, which I strongly encourage the authors to address in the final version.

To clarify, my original concern was not that Theorem 3.4 involves circular reasoning, but rather that its substantive theoretical contribution is limited relative to the complexity and length of its presentation. The theorem relies heavily on Assumption 3.3, and its main conclusion follows rather directly by translating this assumption into an additional shortcut-target margin, together with elementary estimation-error bounds. In my view, the more important insight is that the assumed alignment holds on average in the evaluated tasks, as demonstrated by the new C2 experiments, rather than the algebraic consequences of this assumption. I believe the theoretical presentation should better reflect this distinction.

In particular, I would encourage the authors to:

  • Present the VexactV_{\mathrm{exact}} versus VshV_{\mathrm{sh}} comparison in Section 3.1 directly, keeping the general algebraic derivations in the appendix.
  • Further simplify Sections 3.2–3.3 around the central action-margin decomposition, rather than introducing extensive notation for relatively straightforward identities.
  • More clearly distinguish the motivating observations, assumptions, and conditional guarantees, so that the scope of the theoretical contributions is immediately apparent.

Finally, I strongly recommend incorporating the new C1/C2 experiments and the architectural ablations into the final manuscript. In particular, the C2 experiments should include sufficient details about how good/bad logged actions are labeled and matched, since these choices may materially affect the observed alignment.

Overall, the rebuttal has meaningfully strengthened the empirical support for the proposed method and addressed several of my concerns. My remaining reservation is primarily about the presentation and framing of the theoretical contributions, which I hope will be improved in the final version.

Reviewer_dmgVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Selective Shortcut Value Learning (SSVL) for long-horizon offline goal-conditioned RL. It uses single-discount trajectory shortcuts, selective reward compression, and an auxiliary state-value consistency loss. The paper analyzes value separation and action preference preservation, and evaluates SSVL on OGBench.

Critical strengths
  1. SSVL offers an interesting way to shorten value propagation while retaining a flat policy, with strong results on several tasks.
  2. The theory carefully distinguishes value separation from action preference preservation and accounts for logged continuations.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Action ordering is not directly validated. The guarantee depends on an alignment assumption whose prevalence in offline datasets is unclear.
  2. The interaction between objectives is underexplored. SVC imposes a unit-cost relation even on segments whose critic targets retain accumulated rewards. It is unclear when these objectives compete and how this affects policy learning.
Questions for authors
  1. How often does the required alignment hold in practice? Can the authors directly evaluate action ordering, especially on tasks where SSVL underperforms?
  2. How do SVC and the selective critic targets interact on gate-rejected segments?
  3. Do the gaps against OTA on stitching and visual manipulation persist under matched protocols?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.