acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Ms. Forcing: Efficient Streaming Video Generation with Multi-Scale Patchification and Attention

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Streaming video diffusion models have made substantial progress toward interactive and dynamic world simulation, but the nested autoregressive and denoising loops of conventional next-frame generation hinder real-time deployment. Recent rolling-window methods pipeline denoising across multiple consecutive frames at different noise levels, improving throughput and long-horizon stability. However, they tokenize every state at the same fine spatial granularity, leaving substantial noise-dependent redundancy in the joint denoising window. We propose Ms. Forcing, which adapts spatial granularity to each state's noise level for efficient streaming video generation. Its Multi-Scale Patchification (MSP) assigns coarser patches to noisier states, reducing the active-window token count by 45%, while Multi-Scale Self-Attention (MSSA) matches the density of visible non-sink keys and values to each query scale to further reduce attention cost. Fixing both schedules by window position preserves a static, hardware-friendly computation graph in Ms. Forcing. We further reduce the training–inference mismatch in rolling-window DMD through Homogeneous-Noise-Level DMD (H-DMD), which assembles each fake video from clean predictions sharing the same source noise level. The multi-scale design helps offset the additional training cost of backpropagating through overlapping windows. We include both quantitative and qualitative experiments to show that Ms. Forcing reaches 22.84 FPS on a single H200 GPU, 39.7% faster than Rolling Forcing, while significantly improving VBench scores in both short video and long video generation settings.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Streaming Video Generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_boMnOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper accelerates rolling video diffusion through Multi-Scale Patchification (MSP), which assigns larger patches to noisier states, and Multi-Scale Self-Attention (MSSA), which subsamples keys and values according to query scale. Homogeneous-Noise-Level DMD (H-DMD) assembles training videos from a shared window position. On Wan2.1-1.3B, the model reports 22.84 FPS on one H200, 39.7% faster than Rolling Forcing.

Critical strengths
  1. Technical design. Using different spatial scales for states at different noise levels is a reasonable design choice for rolling diffusion. MSP reduces the number of tokens, and MSSA reduces the attention cost.

  2. Practical value. At 832 × 480 resolution, the reported throughput increases from 16.35 to 22.84 FPS on a single H200, a 39.7% improvement over Rolling Forcing. This is a substantial gain for streaming generation.

  3. Experimental evaluation. The paper evaluates five-second videos on 946 prompts with five seeds and 60-second videos on 128 prompts. The ablations report how successive components affect speed, quality, and motion.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty. The assembly in Eq. (8) already appears in Rolling Forcing, Section 3.4, Eq. (4), which also discusses the heterogeneous-noise mismatch. MSP's projections, LoRA, residual branch, and teacher warm-up closely resemble DDiT, while the related FlexiDiT is omitted. These precedents weaken the claimed originality of H-DMD and MSP's adaptation modules. The new contribution rests mainly on mixed-scale rolling windows and query-dependent KV sampling, but their advantage over adaptations of these prior methods is not tested.

  2. Experimental limitations. The reported quality gains vary across settings. On five-second videos, the full model slightly improves the VBench quality score over Rolling Forcing (83.63 to 83.92), although adding MSSA lowers this score relative to H-DMD+MSP (84.61 to 83.92). On 60-second videos, imaging quality is somewhat lower than Rolling Forcing (70.66 to 69.04), while the reported drift decreases (2.227 to 1.700). This indicates smaller fluctuations in segment-level quality; the effect on gradual quality deterioration is less clear. Quality-versus-time curves would help assess how visual fidelity develops during longer rollouts.

  3. Methodological concerns. The cumulative ablations change both architecture and training. MSP introduces adapters and an additional 6K-pair warm-up, while H-DMD changes video assembly and which rolling windows receive gradients. These comparisons do not clearly separate the proposed mechanisms from the effects of additional adaptation and different gradient coverage. Comparisons with matched training budgets, alternative patch schedules at the same token budget, and head-only DMD would help establish what accounts for the quality gains.

Questions for authors
  1. How does H-DMD differ from Rolling Forcing Eq. (4), and which MSP components are new relative to DDiT and FlexiDiT? Can comparisons with adaptations of these methods to the same rolling-window setting clarify the added value of the proposed integration?

  2. How do the authors interpret the short-video quality decrease after adding MSSA and the lower long-video imaging-quality score relative to Rolling Forcing? Could quality-versus-time curves clarify whether reduced drift also reflects better preservation of visual quality during longer rollouts?

  3. Can controls with the same adapters, token budget, and warm-up budget test whether noise-matched patch scheduling accounts for the quality gains? How does H-DMD compare with head-only assembly when gradient coverage and training budgets are matched?

Reviewer_2vNeOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces Ms. Forcing, an efficient streaming video generation framework built on Rolling Forcing. Multi-Scale Patchification assigns coarser spatial patches to noisier states in the rolling denoising window, while Multi-Scale Self-Attention subsamples visible non-sink keys and values according to the query scale. The paper also proposes Homogeneous-Noise-Level DMD, which constructs each supervised fake sequence from clean predictions sharing the same source noise level across consecutive windows. Compared with Rolling Forcing, the method reports faster generation, competitive short-video quality, and a lower 60-second drift score.

Critical strengths
  1. A well-motivated approach to reducing active-window computation. The deterministic relationship between noise level and rolling-window position makes a fixed coarse-to-fine schedule intuitive and reasonable.

  2. A meaningful improvement over Rolling Forcing. The work extends Rolling Forcing by reducing redundant computation within the denoising window and refining the construction of distillation samples. The reported acceleration, together with competitive generation quality, makes this a useful and practical improvement to the existing framework.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The final MSSA configuration needs a clearer quality-efficiency analysis. In Table 1, adding MSSA to MSP raises throughput from 21.93 to 22.84 FPS, while the total VBench score falls from 83.89 to 83.36 and the quality score falls from 84.61 to 83.92. Table 2 also shows a lower total score and dynamic degree than the MSP variant, although the drift score improves. These results may represent a useful tradeoff, but do not establish when the full configuration is preferable to MSP alone.
Questions for authors
  1. Under what compute or latency constraints is MSSA preferable to MSP alone? Could the authors provide quality-throughput comparisons across several compression settings to clarify this tradeoff?
Reviewer_S1rdOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces "Ms. Forcing," a method designed to improve the computational efficiency of rolling-window streaming video diffusion. The approach consists of three components: Multi-Scale Patchification (MSP), which assigns different patch sizes based on the noise level corresponding to a window's position; Multi-Scale Self-Attention (MSSA), which adjusts the spatial density of non-sink Key/Value pairs according to the scale of the query; and Homogeneous-Noise-Level DMD (H-DMD), which selects clean predictions from the same spatial location across consecutive windows to construct training video sequences with a consistent source noise level.

The authors evaluated the method using the Wan2.1-T2V-1.3B model at an 832×480832\times480 resolution, conducting experiments on five-second and sixty-second videos, alongside cumulative ablation studies. The full model achieves 22.84 FPS on a single H200 GPU—a 39.7% improvement over the 16.35 FPS attained by "Rolling Forcing"—while maintaining competitive VBench scores. The experiments demonstrate a favorable trade-off between efficiency and quality, though the quality gains contributed by individual components vary.

Critical strengths

Achieve clear gains in inference acceleration. Compared to the baseline "Rolling Forcing" approach, throughput increases from 16.35 FPS to 22.84 FPS, while maintaining comparable generation quality.

The multi-scale design based on a rolling-window structure is coherent. MSP leverages a fixed correspondence between window positions and noise levels to allocate spatial computational resources. MSSA further aligns the spatial density of queries with that of the context, all while preserving the full attention sink. The use of a fixed schedule avoids input-dependent routing, which is well-justified from an implementation perspective. Furthermore, the cumulative ablation studies presented in the paper illustrate both the benefits and the costs associated with these components.

Critical weaknesses

Limited methodological novelty.

The novelty of H-DMD is not clearly established. Eq. (4) in Rolling Forcing already describes selecting clean predictions at a shared position across consecutive rolling windows. The surrounding text discusses both the homogeneous source-noise property and the computational cost of this construction. After accounting for the indexing convention, Eq. (8) in the present paper uses the same sequence-assembly rule.

Several MSP components also have clear precedents in DDiT, including patch-specific projections, LoRA, and a latent residual branch. The contribution therefore appears to lie primarily in mixed-scale processing within rolling windows, MSSA, and a more efficient implementation of an existing training construction. The paper should distinguish these contributions from the existing ingredients and clarify what, if anything, H-DMD adds to the assembly scheme already described in RF.

Insufficient isolation of design gains and validation of system efficiency.

(a) The cumulative ablations do not compare alternative patch allocations with the same token budget. They therefore do not isolate the benefit of matching spatial granularity to noise level from the benefit of reducing computation more generally.

(b) An appropriately trained or adapted smaller-T baseline would help determine whether the proposed method offers a better balance between efficiency and quality than simply reducing the number of denoising steps. This comparison should account for the associated change in the joint denoising context.

(c) The paper does not clearly specify whether the reported FPS includes VAE decoding, KV-cache updates, and pipeline warm-up. The claim of substantially lower training costs than RF is also unsupported by direct measurements such as GPU-hours, step time, or peak memory.

(d) According to the described training setups, the H-DMD comparison appears to change both the sequence-assembly scheme and the use of auxiliary Self-Forcing updates. Without separating these changes and controlling the training budget, the reported gains cannot be attributed specifically to homogeneous assembly.

(e) The long-video Drift metric is the temporal standard deviation of segment-wise imaging-quality scores. It measures variability rather than degradation over time and needs to be interpreted alongside motion dynamics and mean quality. The current results do not adequately distinguish legitimate content variation from degradation. Quality trajectories over time, or comparisons at similar motion levels, would provide stronger support for the stability claim.

Questions for authors

Please address the concerns raised in the weaknesses above, particularly the distinction between H-DMD and RF Eq. (4), the attribution of the reported gains, and the evidence supporting the training and inference efficiency claims. Clarifications on these points could affect my assessment.

Reviewer_Ac8mOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Ms. Forcing speeds up Rolling Forcing by using larger spatial patches for high-noise video chunks and letting coarse queries attend to fewer spatial keys and values. For distillation, H-DMD assembles each training video from clean predictions made at the same noise level across video latent chunks. The experimental results show that both generation quality and inference speed are improved.

Critical strengths

The noise level of each chunk is known from its position in the rolling window. The authors use this to spend fewer tokens on chunks that are still far from being emitted. This reduces the token computation for current window. With H-DMD, adding MSP raises throughput from 16.35 to 21.93 FPS.

Critical weaknesses
  • The paper shows how to make the rolling window cheaper, but leaves open how much the current chunk benefits from attending to noisy future chunks. Table 1 includes other causal models but omits Causal Forcing++ (https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15141), which uses the same backbone and supports causal generation with a KV cache and only one or two steps after the first latent frame. Without a matched comparison, it is unclear when the rolling window offers a better tradeoff between quality and speed.
  • The evidence for H-DMD does not establish that it fixes the visual artifacts that motivate it. During 60-second video generation, dynamic degree rises from 33.67 to 51.80, but quality drift worsens from 2.227 to 3.041. More motion does not necessarily mean more natural motion. Figure 4 compares complete methods, so it is difficult to tell whether H-DMD itself reduces abrupt changes in sharpness or camera motion.
Questions for authors
  1. How does 60-second video quality change if the noisiest future chunk is still denoised, but the current chunk cannot attend to it? Separately, have you tested 8×8 instead of 4×4 patches at just the highest noise level?
  2. How does Ms. Forcing compare with 1- or 2-step Causal Forcing++ in short-video quality, first-frame latency, and sustained FPS? For 60-second generation, how do sustained FPS and quality drift compare with a causal KV-cache baseline configured for that duration?
  3. With MSP and MSSA held fixed, can you show paired videos from the same prompts using the original DMD and H-DMD? In particular, are changes in sharpness or camera motion at chunk boundaries visibly reduced?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.