- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents EonWeave, a memory-augmented framework for long-horizon video generation comprising three components: ARiSE that encourages reliance on historical evidence through selective condition perturbation, ReCAP that maintains a fixed-capacity scene atlas for preserving diverse observations, and RaDAR that retrieves and aligns historical patches with current queries to recovers previously observed subjects and scenes after prolonged absence.
Critical strengths
- The paper studies an important problem: recovering previously observed subjects and scenes after prolonged absence, which goes beyond maintaining short-term temporal continuity;
- The proposed framework systematically integrates reliability calibration, bounded memory, and historical retrieval and reports promising reconstruction results on two benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
- The evaluation does not directly establish revisitation consistency. General fidelity and consistency metrics do not show whether content is faithfully recovered after a long absence. A convincing metric would strengthen the claim.
- Tables 1 and 2 show that the headline PSNR gains of 3.037 dB (19.426 vs. 22.463) in single-shot generation and 5.773 dB (19.449 vs. 25.222) on Mira-World come from EonWeave-DMD rather than EonWeave Full. Figure 3 labels the results only as “EonWeave,” leaving the variant unclear. It's hard to follow the claims.
- In Table 3, w/o ARiSE also improves the drift metric from 0.337 to 0.312, so the claim that it improves rollout stability needs further explanation.
- The method relies on clean ground-truth memory during training but stores its own potentially flawed predictions at inference. This leaves a critical training–inference mismatch unaddressed: incorrect identities or scene states may be retained and repeatedly reinforced, yet the paper provides no analysis of this failure mode.
Questions for authors
- Why does removing ARiSE improve the reported drift metric?
- What are the runtime and memory costs relative to AR-HyDRA at matched resolution, rollout length, and sampling steps?
- Is the learned geometry weight monotonic with noise, and does the model actually shift reliance toward atlas evidence?