Tracking States or Tracking Cosets? An Algebraic Account of Learned State Tracking

State tracking requires composing a sequence of updates, but accuracy alone does not reveal what a model has learned. We study neural networks trained to predict the running product of group elements. We identify quotient solutions in Transformers, where models recover the quotient class while predicting nearly uniformly among its members. The reciprocal of class size predicts partial accuracy without a fitted parameter, extending parity-based accounts to non-parity quotients. Our baseline Transformers’ predictions change little under prefix reordering beyond the exact-tracking frontier. We prove that, for finite groups under uniform i.i.d. full-group inputs, optimal order-blind exact accuracy converges to the reciprocal of abelianization class size as prefix length grows, consistent with the observed abelianization plateaus. Sequential updates permits more: any partition into right cosets of a subgroup, normal or not, survives sequential updates. In our census of standard Transformers, every recovered coset partition comes from a normal subgroup, whereas parameter-matched recurrent networks pass through both normal and non-normal right-coset stages during training. On $A_5$, we identify low-dimensional subspaces of the recurrent state that encode non-normal cosets. The coset mean vectors form dodecahedra in three-dimensional subspaces, and swapping the state components in these subspaces makes subsequent coset predictions follow the donor sequence. Our results connect partial accuracy, learning stages, and internal computation through the subgroup cosets that models learn to track.