- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper, "IMLE-LLM: Latent-Conditioned Windowed Decoding for Faster Inference," introduces a post-hoc method to improve the inference speed of LLMs. The key idea of this study is to add a latent matrix that connects tokens and draws windows to accelerate decoding. The authors implement the proposed method on Qwen3-8B and have shown 3.44 times acceleration on the W=4 pattern, along with a mild degradation of performance by a few percent from the original Qwen3-8B. The authors also provide ablation studies regarding training hyperparameters and window size.
Critical strengths
I can see this paper has a chance to be a good paper for the following reasons:
- The idea of adding a latent matrix to an existing LLM to connect tokens is very impressive. Generally, these kinds of work requires from scrach training, but the proposed method does not require it.
- I think the performance that achieved by the proposed method is marginally above the acceptance criteria, even if it does not achieve state-of-the-art.
Critical weaknesses
However, I see several critical weaknesses that prevent me from giving acceptance scores:
- The authors cite many related papers, but the comparison to existing methods is too poor. The number of tables in Table 1 seems to be just a pick-up of existing papers, not a reproduction, and some of them are not Qwen3-8B. As the authors state in the related work and introduction, this area is dense, and there are many methods should be compared with the proposed method.
- The method has only been verified in Qwen3-8B; I think it is not difficult to implement the proposed method on another major LLM such as Gemma or Llama. Two LLM architectures should be a minimum criterion.
- The authors have validated the proposed method in non-reasoning mode; however, the accuracy degradation of reasoning mode on such method is very important and generally hindered. The authors should try the reasoning mode.
- I can see small statement regarding the compute cost of fine-tuning; however, this is not enough. The authors should conduct experiments to study the computing cost.
- The authors should also analyze the memory cost.
- The description of the fine-tuning in the main text is too abstract to understand the exact method. The appendix is very good for understanding the details. The authors should add some figures and statements to main text from appendix.
Questions for authors
The authors should add additional analysis: existing methods, different architectures, memory cost, and fine-tuining cost. My most important concern is about reasoning mode performance. Regarding details, see weakness.
5 comments
Reply from reviewer
Dear Authors
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. I appreciate the improvements, particularly the thinking-mode evaluation and expanded baseline comparisons.
However, the results remain mixed regarding thinking mode. While IMLE-LLM achieves a 3.46× speedup in thinking mode, it shows noticeable accuracy degradation on AIME 2024 and AIME 2025. Moreover, DFlash with the proposed IMLE objective achieves a higher speedup of 4.33× without sacrificing accuracy.
To clarify the practical advantages of the proposed method, I request two additional experiments:
- Per-benchmark speed–accuracy comparison against DFlash and DFlash with IMLE under matched thinking-mode settings.
- Accuracy versus reasoning length, to examine whether errors accumulate over longer reasoning sequences.
Although the revision substantially strengthens the paper, I remain unconvinced that the speed–accuracy trade-off is sufficiently competitive for challenging reasoning tasks. I therefore maintain my rating of Weak Rejection.
Best
Response to Reviewer qmwp, follow-up
Thank you for the follow-up. Both experiments are below and will go into the appendix.
"DFlash with the proposed IMLE objective achieves a higher speedup of 4.33× without sacrificing accuracy"
The 4.33× comes from the proposed objective. W = 4 is trained with it as one model, and DFlash's drafter is trained with it while Qwen3-8B checks every draft. With thinking, the drafter trained with our objective is faster than with DFlash's own loss on all six benchmarks, by 1.13× to 1.39× at block 16, and most on AIME. At block 32 this drafter is also faster than W = 4 on math and code, so we recommend it for exact output on hard reasoning. The final version will say in the abstract which decoder suits which use.
"Per-benchmark speed-accuracy comparison against DFlash and DFlash with IMLE under matched thinking-mode settings"
All rows use the Table G4 setting, and each speed-up is the mean of three timing runs that agree within 0.03×.
Table F1. Thinking mode on Qwen3-8B, per benchmark (speed-up at batch 1)
| Benchmark | Original accuracy | W = 4 accuracy | W = 4 | DFlash, retrained, block 16 | DFlash with our objective, block 16 | DFlash with our objective, block 32 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MATH-500 | 97.0 | 94.8 | 3.45× | 2.92× | 3.80× | 5.40× |
| AIME 2024 | 75.0 | 69.0 | 3.48× | 2.71× | 3.77× | 5.22× |
| AIME 2025 | 66.5 | 60.0 | 3.47× | 2.66× | 3.70× | 5.12× |
| GPQA-Diamond | 61.6 | 59.6 | 3.48× | 2.24× | 2.93× | 3.30× |
| LiveCodeBench | 51.5 | 48.1 | 3.35× | 2.68× | 3.59× | 4.97× |
| IFEval | 84.7 | 80.8 | 3.53× | 1.73× | 1.95× | 1.97× |
| Mean, batch 1 | 3.46× | 2.49× | 3.29× | 4.33× |
W = 4 is faster than the retrained DFlash on every benchmark, and faster than every drafter on GPQA-Diamond (3.48× against at most 3.30×) and IFEval (3.53× against at most 1.97×), where drafts are often rejected. It needs no drafter and adds 0.1 GiB of serving memory, where DFlash adds 2.0 GiB (Table G6, 4K answers).
"Accuracy versus reasoning length, to examine whether errors accumulate over longer reasoning sequences"
W = 4 keeps at least as large a share of the original's accuracy on long answers as on short ones. We sorted each benchmark's problems into thirds by the original's thinking length (without IFEval, whose thinking is short). Cells give original vs. W = 4 accuracy in %, with the kept share in parentheses.
Table F2. Accuracy versus reasoning length (thinking mode)
| Benchmark | Short third | Middle third | Long third |
|---|---|---|---|
| MATH-500 | 99.4 vs. 97.1 (97.7%) | 97.8 vs. 95.7 (97.9%) | 93.8 vs. 91.6 (97.7%) |
| AIME 2024 | 92.5 vs. 84.4 (91.2%) | 77.5 vs. 71.3 (92.0%) | 55.0 vs. 51.3 (93.3%) |
| AIME 2025 | 88.1 vs. 79.4 (90.1%) | 68.8 vs. 61.9 (90.0%) | 42.5 vs. 38.8 (91.3%) |
| GPQA-Diamond | 70.5 vs. 68.0 (96.5%) | 61.9 vs. 60.0 (96.9%) | 52.5 vs. 50.8 (96.8%) |
| LiveCodeBench | 74.7 vs. 69.8 (93.4%) | 51.3 vs. 47.7 (93.0%) | 28.6 vs. 26.9 (94.1%) |
| AIME 2024 and 2025 | 90.3 vs. 81.9 (90.7%) | 73.1 vs. 66.6 (91.1%) | 48.8 vs. 45.0 (92.2%) |
| Pooled, five benchmarks | 85.2 vs. 81.4 (95.5%) | 73.3 vs. 70.3 (95.9%) | 59.7 vs. 57.6 (96.5%) |
The AIME 2024 and 2025 row has 20 problems per third, and the five-benchmark row about 400, and its 95% intervals are at most ±1.5 points (paired bootstrap). Longer thinking also goes with harder problems, so across the five benchmarks we controlled for difficulty with the original's accuracy on each problem. The kept share then changes by +0.2 points per 10K tokens of thinking (95% interval −0.6 to 1.0). Within each AIME problem, where difficulty is fixed, we compared each model's 8 longest and 8 shortest samples. The original's longer samples are 17.3 points less accurate (62.1% against 79.4%), and W = 4's are 15.6 points less accurate (56.7% against 72.3%), so W = 4 keeps 91.1% and 91.3% in the two halves.
We also scored W = 4's AIME answers with Qwen3-8B. Under the speculative-sampling rule, it accepts 93.3% of their tokens in the first 4K tokens, and 92.9%, 93.2% and 93.0% from 4K to 8K, from 8K to 16K and beyond 16K. W = 4's AIME thinking is 1.03× as long as the original's, and 2.9% of them hit the 32,768-token budget, against 2.6%.
"noticeable accuracy degradation on AIME 2024 and AIME 2025" and "sufficiently competitive for challenging reasoning tasks"
W = 4 loses 6.0 points on AIME 2024 and 6.5 on AIME 2025, and the share it loses is about the same on the shortest and the longest problems (Table F2). When AIME answers must be exact, the drafter trained with our objective gives 5.22× and 5.12× at block 32 with no loss, and at block 16 it gives 3.77× and 3.70× against 2.71× and 2.66× for DFlash's own loss. With one model and no drafter, or on open-ended text, W = 4 is the faster choice.
The reviewer's requests have made the paper stronger, and we thank the reviewer for them. If these results answer the concern on reasoning, we would be grateful if the reviewer considered raising the score.
Response to Reviewer qmwp
Thank you for your review.
W3. "My most important concern is about reasoning mode performance"
W = 4 works in reasoning mode. We retrained it on Qwen3-8B's own thinking answers, with answers of up to 32,768 tokens. Over six tasks its accuracy is 94.3% of the original Qwen3-8B's, at 3.46× at batch 1 and 3.38× at batch 4 (Table G4 in the general response, Table 3 in Section 4.2). On MATH-500 and LiveCodeBench it gets 97.73% and 93.40% of the original, vs. 95.14% and 90.63% without thinking (Appendix B.3).
Speed on long answers is close to the speed without thinking (3.39× and 3.28× at batch 1 and 4). W = 4 has "no draft model and no verifier" (L291-294 of the submission). Long reasoning has no draft acceptance rate to pull down.
W1. "the comparison to existing methods is too poor"
We added EAGLE-3, I-DLM, Jacobi Forcing and K-Forcing to the comparison. Among the lossy decoders, W = 4 is the fastest at 3.39× and has the highest code retention, 92.93% (Tables G1 and G3, Table 2 in Section 4.2 and Table 11 in Appendix F). WeDLM, with its threshold raised to the 3.88 tokens per pass of W = 4, loses 13.91 points on the six-task mean at 3.19×, while W = 4 loses 5.16 points at 3.39× (Appendix F).
W1 (continued). "just a pick-up of existing papers, not a reproduction, and some of them are not Qwen3-8B"
Table 1 is our own measurement. Every speed cell is our timing (Appendix D.2), and every accuracy cell is our run of the released code and weights under one protocol and one grader (Section 4.1 of the revised PDF, Appendix C.1). Five cells, now in blue, had come from the baselines' papers, which score with other protocols (Kirchenbauer et al. score GSM8K few-shot with flexible answer extraction). The reruns change no speed-up. As an outside check, our 43.07 IFEval for the Magpie SFT base is within a single prompt of the Open LLM Leaderboard's independent strict score of 42.88 for the same model.
Nemotron-LD and Kirchenbauer et al. use other 8B bases, so Table 1 compares each with its own base. Kirchenbauer et al. get 91.28% of their base's math and 84.43% of its code at 2.41×, while W = 4 gets 95.65% and 92.93% of Qwen3-8B's at 3.39×.
W2. "Two LLM architectures should be a minimum criterion"
The submitted recipe and settings work on Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct, one of the two models the review suggests. W = 4 runs at 3.38× at batch 1 and gets 96.51% of math and 92.02% of code of the original (Table G5, Tables 14 and 15 in Appendix G.3). Llama has no QK-norm and 32 layers, not Qwen3-8B's 36. Its speed-up is still near Qwen3-8B's 3.39×.
W4 and W5. "study the computing cost" and "analyze the memory cost"
Fine-tuning W = 4 costs little more than DFlash's own drafter recipe, and serving it needs almost no extra memory. Fine-tuning takes 699.27 H100-hours and DFlash's recipe 632.46, each timed on one node of 8 H100 (Table G6, Table 5 in Appendix B.2). With BAdam, which trains one layer at a time, the W = 4 fine-tune peaks at 28.0 GiB per card, where full AdamW needs about 137.3 GiB (Appendix B.2). At serving, W = 4 adds 0.1 GiB to the original's 15.9 GiB at batch 1, and DFlash adds 2.0 GiB (Table G6, Table 10 in Appendix E.2).
W6. "The description of the fine-tuning in the main text is too abstract"
Section 3.2 now gives the five steps of one training round of Algorithm 1, and Figure 5 in Appendix A.1 shows the windows and the weight of each token.