acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Statistical Inference for Structurally Constrained Nonlinear Regression

Abstract

A fundamental challenge in using deep neural networks (DNNs) is to obtain valid prediction uncertainty quantification while retaining their flexibility. Two central goals are to construct confidence intervals for the mean regression function and prediction intervals for future observations. The former quantifies uncertainty about the underlying relationship, while the latter accounts for observational noise. Existing approaches address aspects of these goals, but valid uncertainty quantification under structural constraints remains challenging, particularly when the noise distribution is unknown. Building on Extended Fiducial Inference (EFI), we develop a framework for nonlinear regression with deep neural networks, where structural constraints are imposed to restrict the admissible function class while an unknown noise distribution is accommodated. Under the assumption that the structurally constrained function class admits a locally identifiable low-dimensional representation, we establish theoretical guarantees for inference in dense, over-parameterized neural networks without requiring sparse parameterizations. Simulation studies show near-nominal coverage for both confidence and prediction intervals across a range of constrained nonlinear regression settings, including differential equations, monotonicity, and periodicity, under Gaussian and non-Gaussian noise.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
Extended Fiducial Inference, structural constraints, nonlinear regression, flexible noise modeling, uncertainty quantification

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_J3AXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an Extended Fiducial Inference (EFI) framework for structurally constrained nonlinear regression with unknown and non-Gaussian observation noise. The key idea is to use a hypernetwork to map individual observation and noise variables to the parameters of another (regression) network, which enables the construction of confidence and prediction intervals. Under a low-dimensional representation assumption, the authors establish the theoretical guarantee and experiments on synthetic regression problems shows competitive accuracy and near-nominal coverage.

Critical strengths

The motivation for uncertainty quantification in structurally constrained nonlinear regression is important and well justified.

Critical weaknesses

W1. My biggest concern is the methodological novelty. It seems to me the proposed method combines existing EFI for PINNs with nonparametric-error EFI method, so the methodological contribution looks somewhat incremental.

W2. Another central concern is related to Assumption 4.1, which requires the constrained function class to admit a low-dimensional representation, which seems to be a relatively strong assumption. How this can be justified for general structural constraints, e.g periodicity and monotonicity. If the assumption does not hold, to what extent can the theoretical results still justify the proposed uncertainty quantification?

Questions for authors

Q1. Please follow the ICLR format requirement for abstract, single paragraph. The keywords part should be deleted.

Q2. Discussion with probabilistic function regression methods is kind-of limited. e.g. Gaussian Process Regression (GPR), Deep GPs, and Neural Processes. In particular, GPR can also incorporate differential constraints and provide uncertainty estimates . The authors could at least include a controlled comparison with GPR .

1 comment

Response to W1

Our contribution is to identify and formalize how structural restrictions can connect dense nonlinear models to flexible-noise inference through a low-dimensional representation. Please see our Shared Response on Methodological Novelty for the distinction from prior EFI work and the supporting evidence.

Response to W2

A sufficient condition for Assumption 4.1 is a linear differential structural restriction Lf=r\mathcal Lf=r with dim⁡ker⁡(L)=q<n\dim\ker(\mathcal L)=q < n. For example, the continuous 1-D Poisson equation with fixed forcing gives u(x)=u0(x)+ϕ1+ϕ2xu(x)=u_0(x)+\phi_1+\phi_2x, with q=2q=2, where u0u_0 is a particular solution.

Weaker restrictions such as periodicity and monotonicity may leave a high-dimensional admissible class, for which we have not established Assumption 4.1. Here, the narrow neck provides a learned low-rank approximation in parameter space. When dh<qd_h < q, the proposed method quantifies the uncertainty of θ\theta in a low-dimensional space. Note that uncertainty of θ\theta can still be correctly quantified within this restricted function class, provided that the w\mathbf{w}-network is sufficiently expressive. The periodic experiment demonstrates near-nominal coverage, while the monotonic ablation (Table E.6) shows only a small change in CI coverage as dhd_h increases from 4 to 16, with similar interval widths.

Assumption 4.1 restricts the flexibility of the regression function so that inference with an unspecified noise distribution can be justified under the applicable reduced-model EFI conditions. Without sufficient restrictions, the regression function can absorb observational noise, and the theoretical UQ guarantees no longer follow.

Revision note: We have expanded the discussion of Assumption 4.1 and low-rank approximation in Remarks 4.2–4.3 of the revised manuscript.

Response to Q1

Thank you for pointing this out. We have revised the abstract to a single paragraph and removed the keywords section.

Response to Q2

We added two GP comparisons incorporating the same structural information: a periodic GP with a Matérn-3/2 kernel on a sine–cosine embedding of the known period, and a Poisson operator GP with a Matérn-5/2 kernel following [1] (Table 2).

Under Gaussian noise, both GPs and EFI perform well, with narrower CIs for the periodic GP. GP can provide efficient inference when the chosen kernel captures the regression function well and the noise assumption is appropriate. Under bimodal noise, the GPs retain near-nominal CI coverage, but their Gaussian-likelihood PIs over-cover. EFI achieves lower MSE and narrower CIs and PIs, with coverage close to nominal. These GP baselines encode structure through tailored kernels and use a Gaussian likelihood. EFI accommodates structural constraints and an unspecified noise distribution within the same inferential framework.

[1] Maziar Raissi, Paris Perdikaris, and George Em Karniadakis. Machine learning of linear differential equations using Gaussian processes. Journal of Computational Physics, 348:683–693, 2017.

Table 2. GP versus EFI: means over 100 replications.

ExperimentMethodMSE95% CI cov.CI width90% PI cov.PI width
Periodic: GaussianGP+Periodic Kernel0.00050.94020.07890.89530.3350
EFI0.00050.94120.12210.89260.3492
Periodic: bimodalGP+Periodic Kernel0.00850.94910.36960.97752.0923
EFI0.00410.94020.29720.91031.7617
Poisson: GaussianOperator GP0.00020.96650.06540.90500.3322
EFI (ηstr=0.5\eta_{\mathrm{str}}=0.5)0.00030.94700.06680.89360.3240
Poisson: bimodalOperator GP0.00840.95130.34380.97532.0846
EFI (ηstr=1\eta_{\mathrm{str}}=1)0.00450.95450.29250.89571.7269

Revision note: We have expanded the related discussion in Section 1 and added GP comparisons in Section 5, with detailed results and implementation settings in Appendices D and G.

Reviewer_SDqbOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper develops an extended fiducial inference (EFI) framework for nonlinear regression with structural constraints and an unknown noise distribution. It combines a narrow-neck network for learning the inverse map with kernel density estimation of the errors, providing confidence intervals for the regression function and prediction intervals for future observations. Under a locally identifiable, low-dimensional representation of the constrained function class, the theory transfers applicable EFI uncertainty statements from the reduced model. The main experiments consider a Poisson equation, periodic regression, and five-dimensional regression with interactions.

Critical strengths
  • The paper addresses a useful problem: inference for flexible regression models when structural information is available but the noise distribution is unknown. Providing both confidence intervals for the regression function and prediction intervals for future responses makes the framework relevant to scientific modeling.

  • The experiments evaluate coverage together with interval width over 100 independent replications. The results under bimodal noise are particularly encouraging. In Table 2, EFI achieves approximately 94% coverage for nominal 95% confidence intervals, with an average width of 0.30, compared with 0.66 and 0.83 for the reported classical smoothers at similar coverage.

Critical weaknesses
  • I find the additional theoretical contribution relatively modest. Assumption 4.1 already posits an exact, locally identifiable low-dimensional representation, and Theorem 4.3 and Corollary 4.4 formalize feasibility equivalence and the conditional transfer of EFI uncertainty statements. This provides a useful interpretation, but establishing when the constrained function class and learned inverse map satisfy the required conditions remains largely open. This limits the new theoretical support provided for the implemented procedure.

  • The methodological contribution is primarily an integration and extension of existing EFI constructions. Combining the narrow-neck architecture of Shih et al. (2025) with the noise-distribution updates of Wang and Liang (2026) is useful, and the experiments provide encouraging evidence. However, the extent of the advance beyond these ingredients is less firmly established. The comparison with classical smoothers in Table 2 offers only partial evidence: as acknowledged in the paper, these baselines do not use the known periodicity, so the interval-width improvement also reflects access to structural information.

Questions for authors
  • For the periodic and five-dimensional examples, can the authors specify the low-dimensional representation underlying Assumption 4.1, or clarify whether these examples primarily provide empirical evidence beyond the settings where the assumption has been verified?

  • Does the EFI invariance result reviewed in Appendix C.2 also apply to the full energy in Eq. (7), including the structural constraint term? A brief explanation of the relevant conditions would help connect Algorithm 1 to Corollary 4.4.

  • What are the main technical challenges in extending the constructions of Shih et al. (2025) and Wang and Liang (2026) to dense, structurally constrained regression with an unknown noise distribution, and how does the present work address them?

  • If available, could the authors provide results for a classical smoother that incorporates the same known periodicity as EFI in Table 2? This comparison would help assess the source of the interval-width improvement.

5 comments

Response to W1 and Q1

For linear structural restrictions Lf=r\mathcal Lf=r, dim⁡ker⁡(L)=q<n\dim\ker(\mathcal L)=q < n is a sufficient condition for an identifiable function-level representation. With a particular solution f0f_0 and a basis ψ1,…,ψq\psi_1,\ldots,\psi_q of ker⁡(L)\ker(\mathcal L), every admissible function has the unique representation

f(x)=f0(x)+∑j=1qϕjψj(x).f(x)=f_0(x)+\sum_{j=1}^{q}\phi_j\psi_j(x).

In the 5-D example, the constraints ∂j2f=0\partial_j^2f=0 for j=1,2,4,5j=1,2,4,5 and ∂33f=0\partial_3^3f=0, imposed throughout the domain, restrict the admissible class to polynomials of degree at most one in four coordinates and at most two in the third. Thus, q=24×3=48<n=500q=2^4\times3=48 < n=500. The neck width dh=16d_h=16 controls a learned low-rank approximation in parameter space rather than the dimension of the full admissible class; this configuration achieves near-nominal coverage.

Periodicity, like monotonicity, may leave a high-dimensional admissible class, for which we have not established Assumption 4.1. Here, the narrow neck provides a learned low-rank approximation in parameter space. When dh<qd_h < q, the proposed method quantifies the uncertainty of θ\theta in a low-dimensional space. Note that uncertainty of θ\theta can still be correctly quantified within this restricted function class, provided that the w\mathbf{w}-network is sufficiently expressive. The periodic experiment demonstrates near-nominal coverage, while the monotonic ablation (Table E.6) shows only a small change in CI coverage as dhd_h increases from 4 to 16, with similar interval widths.

Revision note: We have added a sufficient condition and clarified the approximation used in practice in Remarks 4.2–4.3 of the revised manuscript.

Response to Q2

Yes, the EFI result reviewed in Appendix C.2 also applies to the full energy in Eq. (7) of the original submission (Eq. (8) in the revised manuscript). For clarity, we use Un(z)U_n(\boldsymbol{z}) to denote the energy function without constraints, and use U~n(z)\widetilde{U}_n(\boldsymbol{z}) to denote the energy function including the structural constraints. In particular, following tubular decomposition in Liang et al. (2025), we can write

z=s+Nst,\boldsymbol{z}=\boldsymbol{s}+N_{\boldsymbol{s}} \boldsymbol{t},

where s∈Zn(p)\boldsymbol s\in\mathcal Z_n^{(p)} lies on a maximal-dimensional manifold in the zero-energy set

Zn={z:U~n(z)=0}.\mathcal{Z}_n=\lbrace\boldsymbol{z}: \widetilde{U}_n(\boldsymbol{z})=0\rbrace.

The columns of NsN_{\boldsymbol s} form an orthonormal basis for its normal space, and t∈Rn−p\boldsymbol t\in\mathbb R^{n-p} gives the normal coordinates. In Eq. (C.15), we use the normal Hessian of the full energy:

∇t2U~n(z).\nabla^2_{\boldsymbol{t}}\widetilde{U}_n(\boldsymbol{z}).

The key requirement is joint compatibility: the data-generating equations, structural restrictions, and consensus relations must admit a common zero-energy solution. The remaining assumptions are the regularity conditions underlying Appendix C.2, including three continuous derivatives of U~n(z)\widetilde U_n(\boldsymbol z) on regular chart supports, smooth regular manifolds, positive-definite normal Hessians, and continuity of tail control for the baseline density π0(z)\pi_0(z).

This explanation connects the full energy used in Algorithm 1 with the latent fiducial law underlying the uncertainty transfer in Corollary 4.4 of the original submission (Corollary 4.5 in the revised manuscript).

Response to W2 and Q3 — Methodological novelty

Extending compatible EFI constructions to dense constrained models still requires inferential justification and validation. Please see our Shared Response on Methodological Novelty.

Response to W2 and Q4 — Periodicity-aware comparison

We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We added a cyclic cubic spline incorporating the same known period, P=0.5P=0.5, with REML-selected smoothing (Table 1). Both methods perform well under Gaussian noise, with comparable estimation accuracy and coverage and narrower CIs for the cyclic spline. Under bimodal noise, the cyclic spline remains less accurate and produces wider CIs than EFI at similar coverage, despite incorporating the same known periodicity. These results support EFI's ability to remain robust and efficient in interval estimation when the noise distribution is unspecified.

Table 1. Means over 100 replications; spline PIs use split conformal.

NoiseMethodMSE95% CI cov.CI width90% PI cov.PI width
GaussianOrdinary spline0.00100.94500.11410.89730.3519
Cyclic spline0.00050.93550.07870.89500.3416
EFI0.00050.94120.12210.89260.3492
BimodalOrdinary spline0.03470.94680.65960.89211.8829
Cyclic spline0.01000.93550.36980.89871.7925
EFI0.00410.94020.29720.91031.7617

Revision note: We have added the cyclic spline comparison to Section 5.2 and Appendix D of the revised manuscript.

Thank you for the detailed response. The cyclic spline comparison addresses my concern about Table 2. EFI still gives narrower CIs at similar coverage under bimodal noise when both methods use the same period. The explanation of the 5-D example and its coverage results also helped, and I now understand that the periodic example provides empirical support in a setting where Assumption 4.1 has not been verified.

I have one remaining question about Q2. I understand that (C.15) uses the normal Hessian of the full energy. For the energy in (C.4), the curvature factor cancels upon normalization, so (C.15) simplifies to (C.16). Does the same simplification hold for the energy in Eq. (7) of the original submission, which includes the structural constraint term?

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to follow-up: part 1

1. When does the curvature factor cancel in (C.15)?

The key issue is whether the normal-Hessian determinant is constant on the maximal-dimensional regular part of Zn\mathcal Z_n. Write Zn=⋃ℓ=1LZn,ℓ\mathcal Z_n=\bigcup_{\ell=1}^{L}\mathcal Z_{n,\ell} as a finite union of disjoint closed C3C^3 embedded zero-energy manifold components, possibly with smooth boundary. Let k<nk<n be the largest dimension among these components, and write dℓ=dim⁡(Zn,ℓ)d_\ell=\dim(\mathcal Z_{n,\ell}). Define

:=\bigcup_{d_\ell=k} \left(\mathcal Z_{n,\ell}\setminus\partial\mathcal Z_{n,\ell}\right).$$ If the determinant is constant, the curvature factor cancels upon normalization. Let $\nu$ be its intrinsic $k$-dimensional measure and $r=n-k$. For ${\boldsymbol{s}}\in\mathcal Z_n^{\mathrm{reg}}$, write ${\boldsymbol{z}}={\boldsymbol{s}}+N_{{\boldsymbol{s}}}{\boldsymbol{t}}$, where $N_{{\boldsymbol{s}}}$ is an orthonormal normal frame at ${\boldsymbol{s}}$. - **Unknown scale.** Let $\widehat\sigma({\boldsymbol{s}})$ denote the compatible scale output of the fitted inverse map. Then $$\det\left[\left.\nabla_{{\boldsymbol{t}}}^2 \widetilde U_{{\boldsymbol{w}}}({\boldsymbol{s}}+N_{{\boldsymbol{s}}}{\boldsymbol{t}})\right|_{{\boldsymbol{t}}=\boldsymbol{0}}\right] =\lbrace2\widehat\sigma({\boldsymbol{s}})^2\rbrace^r,$$ $$\left\lbrace\det\left[\left.\nabla_{{\boldsymbol{t}}}^2 \widetilde U_{{\boldsymbol{w}}}({\boldsymbol{s}}+N_{{\boldsymbol{s}}}{\boldsymbol{t}})\right|_{{\boldsymbol{t}}=\boldsymbol{0}}\right]\right\rbrace^{-1/2} =2^{-r/2}\widehat\sigma({\boldsymbol{s}})^{-r}.$$ If $\widehat\sigma({\boldsymbol{s}})$ varies with ${\boldsymbol{s}}$, the factor $\widehat\sigma({\boldsymbol{s}})^{-r}$ generally remains. This corresponds to Run 1, where the Gaussian working model includes an unknown scale. - **Known/fixed scale.** For fixed $\sigma$, the curvature factor $\lbrace\det[\left.\nabla_{{\boldsymbol{t}}}^2\widetilde U_{{\boldsymbol{w}}}({\boldsymbol{s}}+N_{{\boldsymbol{s}}}{\boldsymbol{t}})\right|_{{\boldsymbol{t}}=\boldsymbol{0}}]\rbrace^{-1/2} =2^{-r/2}\sigma^{-r}$ is constant and cancels upon normalization. This corresponds to the final inference stage of NE-EFI. Under the conditions for NE-EFI consistency, the terminal KDE consistently estimates the true error distribution. Writing $\pi$ for the true error density, the ideal limiting fiducial law is $$\frac{dP_n^*}{d\nu}({\boldsymbol{z}}) = \frac{\pi^{\otimes n}({\boldsymbol{z}})} {\displaystyle\int_{\mathcal Z_n^{\mathrm{reg}}} \pi^{\otimes n}({\boldsymbol{u}}) d\nu({\boldsymbol{u}})}, \qquad {\boldsymbol{z}}\in\mathcal Z_n^{\mathrm{reg}}.$$
Reviewer_14hHOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a unified framework for structurally constrained nonlinear regression based on Extended Fiducial Inference. The framework accommodates different structural constraints and unknown noise distributions, providing both confidence intervals and prediction intervals. Theoretical results establish a reduction from dense neural networks to locally identifiable low-dimensional models, while experiments demonstrate promising uncertainty quantification performance.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses an important problem in uncertainty quantification for structurally constrained neural networks.
  2. The proposed framework accommodates various structural constraints and potentially unknown, non-Gaussian noise distributions.
  3. The experimental results are encouraging, with comprehensive baseline comparisons and sensitivity analyses supporting the effectiveness of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited theoretical guarantees. The theoretical results rely on a locally identifiable low-dimensional representation and mainly establish feasibility equivalence and conditional uncertainty transfer. Their applicability to the full constrained function class remains insufficiently justified.
  2. Limited methodological novelty. Several key components, including the narrow-neck architecture and KDE-based noise refinement, originate from previous EFI studies. The methodological contributions beyond these existing approaches are not sufficiently distinguished.
Questions for authors
  1. Appendix B acknowledges a gap between the EFI-representable function class and the full admissible constrained class. Could the authors clarify how this gap affects the applicability of Theorem 4.3 to the considered experiments?
  2. Given that the narrow-neck architecture and KDE-based noise refinement originate from prior EFI work, could the authors clarify the main methodological innovations beyond these existing approaches?
1 comment

Response to W1 and Q1

The distinction is between the existence of a low-dimensional representation of the constrained class and whether the learned inverse captures that class. A sufficient condition for the former is a linear constraint Lf=r\mathcal Lf=r with dim⁡ker⁡(L)=q<n\dim\ker(\mathcal L)=q < n on the specified function space. Given a particular solution f0f_0 and a basis ψ1,…,ψq\psi_1,\ldots,\psi_q of ker⁡(L)\ker(\mathcal L), every admissible function has the unique representation

\qquad \mathcal L\psi_j=0.$$ For our 1-D Poisson example, the forcing is fixed and no boundary conditions are imposed. The continuous equation therefore gives $u(x)=u_0(x)+\phi_1+\phi_2x$, with $q=2$. This basis expansion characterizes the constrained function class. In implementation, the DNN learns the full function directly from the observations and differential constraint. Narrow-neck EFI learns an affine family of DNN parameters. Let $\rho$ map an admissible parameter to its effective function coefficients. Then $$\hat{\boldsymbol\theta}(\mathbf z) =\mathbf a_n+\Xi_n^\top\mathbf m(\mathbf z), \qquad \boldsymbol\phi(\mathbf z) =\rho\left(\mathbf a_n+\Xi_n^\top\mathbf m(\mathbf z)\right), \qquad \mathbf m(\mathbf z)\in\mathbb R^{d_h}.$$ Here $\mathbf a_n$ and $\Xi_n$ are learned output-layer parameters. The neck coordinates need not equal the effective coefficients. Representing the full constrained class requires the learned family's image under $\rho$ to cover the corresponding coefficient set; the narrow-neck architecture alone does not establish this coverage. When $d_h < q$, the proposed method is to quantify uncertainty of $\theta$ by restricting its variation within a lower dimensional space. Note that uncertainty of $\theta$ can still be correctly quantified within this restricted function class, provided that the $\mathbf{w}$-network is sufficiently expressive. The monotonic ablation (Appendix E.4, Table E.6) assesses the practical sensitivity to neck width: increasing $d_h$ from 4 to 16 changes CI coverage from 93.13% to 93.90%, with similar interval widths. This empirically supports the robustness of the learned low-dimensional representation. > **Revision note:** We have clarified the representation condition and the role of the narrow neck in Remarks 4.2–4.3 of the revised manuscript. ## Response to W2 and Q2 Although prior EFI constructions are compatible, extending and validating UQ in this broader setting is not trivial. Please see our Shared Response on Methodological Novelty for the statistical motivation, theoretical support, and empirical evidence.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Shared Response on Methodological Novelty

Shared Response on Methodological Novelty

We address an important modeling problem: statistically principled UQ for expressive nonlinear regression with an unspecified noise law. Without sufficient restrictions on the regression function, the model can absorb observational noise, making calibrated inference difficult to establish. We retain the expressive flexibility of DNNs and use problem-specific structural constraints to restrict the admissible function class:

f^\star\in\mathcal F_c,\qquad z_i\overset{\mathrm{i.i.d.}}{\sim}\pi_0,\quad \pi_0\ \text{unspecified}.$$ The two prior studies address complementary inferential problems: - **EFI-PINN (Shih et al., 2025):** inference for PDE-constrained neural models under Gaussian noise. - **NE-EFI (Wang and Liang, 2026):** inference with an unspecified noise distribution, developed primarily for classical low-dimensional regression with $n > p$. While the computational construction is inherited from prior EFI work, this paper identifies and formalizes its broader statistical role: structural restrictions can provide an identifiable low-dimensional representation ($q < n$) that connects dense nonlinear models ($p\gg n$) to applicable NE-EFI inference. ODEs and PDEs, together with boundary conditions, can strongly restrict the solution family and induce such representations. With weaker constraints, the admissible class may retain many degrees of freedom. The narrow-neck construction provides a learned low-dimensional affine approximation in parameter space to capture the variation relevant to inference. In the monotonic ablation (Table E.6), coverage and interval width change little as the neck widens, supporting the adequacy of a small neck. To the best of our knowledge, no other unified framework has demonstrated this combination of noise-law estimation and near-nominal frequentist coverage for both confidence and prediction intervals in the general setting considered here. In particular, the setting covers dense, over-parameterized neural networks. > **Revision note:** We have strengthened the presentation of our contributions in Section 1, emphasizing the statistical contribution, theoretical justification, and empirical support.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.