- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SEQNet for irregular multivariate time-series forecasting. It combines compressed temporal memory with explicitly retained local events and uses query-conditioned, support-aware routing to balance self-history, cross-variable information, and learned priors. Experiments on four datasets show the lowest MSE among the compared methods, with additional ablations on event retention and routing.
Critical strengths
-
The combination of compressed global memory, retained local events, and support-aware routing is well motivated and directly addresses important characteristics of irregular time series.
-
The empirical results are strong, with the best MSE on all four datasets and results reported over five random seeds.
Critical weaknesses
-
The observation-deletion robustness experiment evaluates only SEQNet. This makes it difficult to determine whether its support-aware design is actually more robust than competing methods. The 416% average MSE increase on Activity makes this comparison particularly important.
-
Several training mechanisms are introduced together, including paired-view training, constrained family weighting, and auxiliary event supervision, but their individual contributions are not sufficiently isolated.
Questions for authors
-
How does SEQNet compare with strong baselines such as Hi-Patch or t-PatchGNN under the same observation-deletion environments, particularly on Activity?
-
What are the individual contributions of paired-view training, constrained family weighting, and event supervision? Could the authors provide ablations for these training components?
4 comments
Continued from previous comment
Paired views produce the largest individual reduction in this single-run ablation. With all three components enabled, D4 achieves the lowest MSE, 2.95% below D0. We will add the full ablation to §4.4 and Appendix F and identify the loss terms for each component in §§3.5–3.6.
Finally, thank you once again for the patient and thorough reading of our paper and recognizing its strengths. Your thoughtful questions and suggestions helped us improve the manuscript. We would be happy to continue the discussion if you have any further questions!
Thank you
I was wondering if our response has addressed your concern... If you feel that your concerns have all been addressed, we would be very grateful if you could consider giving it a higher score... But regardless, we sincerely thank you for carefully reading our paper and for your excellent suggestions, which have helped us improve it a lot!^^
Sorry for the quick follow-up...T T
As the rebuttal deadline is approaching, I’m sorry to bother you again... but we hope this message does not bring you any pressure at all...!!
We are very grateful for your initial recognition of this paper, and we feel truly happy and lucky that it was reviewed by you. We just wanted to confirm whether your concerns have been addressed. We really hope our response can make our paper more convincing.
Finally, we understand you may be very busy in real life. But regardless, hoping all your papers get accepted!~
Response to Reviewer MKu8
Thank you for recognizing the motivation behind SEQNet's design, which combines a summary of the history with direct access to selected observations and uses the available history to decide which sources to rely on. We also appreciate your noting that SEQNet achieved the lowest MSE among the compared methods on all four benchmarks, with results reported over five seeds. To address your questions, we compare SEQNet with strong baselines under observation deletion on Activity and PhysioNet, and test each training component with the architecture held fixed.
W1 & Q1. Comparison with strong baselines under the same observation-deletion environments
Activity. On the revised subject-disjoint split, we evaluated SEQNet, Hi-Patch, and t-PatchGNN on the same test samples using sample-micro MSE (Appendix E.3, Eq. (17)). We used the five observation-deletion families and four retention rates from §§3.5 and 4.3, yielding 20 test environments. Each result is from a single run (seed 1).
On held-out subjects, SEQNet achieves the lowest clean, mean, and worst-environment MSE. Its mean and worst-environment MSE are 66.26% and 71.26% lower than Hi-Patch's and 95.89% and 95.92% lower than t-PatchGNN's, respectively.
The 416.48% increase in Table 3 of the submission was measured on the original window-level split. On the subject-disjoint split, SEQNet's mean MSE increases by 43.81% over its clean MSE. The worst environment remains variable-subset deletion at a retention rate of 0.2, with an MSE of 0.008183.
PhysioNet. We also trained both baselines with paired deletion and evaluated them using the same five deletion families, four retention rates, and sample-micro MSE.
Paired-deletion training reduces mean and worst-environment MSE by 15.39% and 17.30% for t-PatchGNN and by 24.74% and 40.99% for Hi-Patch. With paired-deletion training applied to both baselines, SEQNet's mean and worst-environment MSE are still 11.06% and 11.71% lower than t-PatchGNN's and 11.15% and 11.96% lower than Hi-Patch's, respectively. We will add both comparisons to §4.3 and update the Activity results in Table 3.
To make it easier to reproduce our results, we provide the code in an anonymous repository.
W2 & Q2. Individual contributions of the three training components
We held the forecasting architecture fixed and ablated paired views, constrained family weighting, and auxiliary event supervision on PhysioNet. Paired-view training predicts the same targets from the original and deleted histories (§3.5, Eq. (5)). Both weighting configurations sample deletion families uniformly. Constrained weighting adjusts each family's contribution to the deleted-view forecasting loss (Eq. (6)). Auxiliary event supervision uses binary cross-entropy for lower- and upper-tail labels defined by the 5th and 95th percentiles of the training data (§3.6, Eq. (7)).
Due to the character limit, please see the remaining questions in the following comment.