- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work introduces a new task of Streaming Human-Object Interaction detection, which adopts a bounded-lag protocol to revise interaction recognition. The weakest aspect of the paper is arguably its ablation study, which makes it difficult for readers to understand whether the proposed revision mechanism actually benefits interaction recognition.
Critical strengths
This work introduces a new task of Streaming Human-Object Interaction detection, which adopts a bounded-lag protocol to revise interaction recognition. The motivation and visualizations are quite clear.
Critical weaknesses
Many experimental details are insufficiently specified, making the results difficult to reproduce. The connection between the experimental setup and the stated motivation is also not clearly articulated.
Questions for authors
1 In Table 2, the “Without sep. gate” setting may serve as an ablation of the revision mechanism. However, its impact is minimal, with an mAP drop of only −0.001, which appears inconsistent with the paper’s main motivation. It remains unclear whether this limited effect stems from the experimental setup rather than from the revision mechanism itself.
2 We further examine the design of this gate, which may correspond to the “Gate4 scoring” described in Section 3.2. This appears to be a conditional piecewise function involving a relatively complex four-condition mechanism. However, the function is not fully specified, and it is unclear whether it contains learnable parameters, which may affect the gate’s experimental behavior and makes the presentation unfriendly to readers.
3 The correspondence between Table 2 and Figure 2 is also poorly aligned. For example, the “Retrieval-Based Supervision” component shown in Figure 2 does not have a clearly identifiable technical implementation in the method description.
4 The experiments use a Gaussian Mixture Model to learn a prior, but the motivation for this choice is not well justified. It is unclear why other distributions were not considered. The evidence learning component therefore appears to lack sufficient theoretical depth. Moreover, the parameter sensitivity of the GMM is only examined in the single-Gaussian case, making it difficult to assess how sensitive the model is to GMM hyperparameters.
5 The model employs multiple loss terms, including L_sim and L_ret. However, the paper does not provide a comprehensive ablation study over the loss functions, and the loss hyperparameters are not clearly specified, which hinders reproducibility.
6 Because the paper adopts a bounded-lag protocol, many details regarding temporal partitioning and data splitting are not clearly described, further complicating experimental reproduction.