- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper builds on DynaDiff, which decodes from the raw single-trial fMRI time series instead of the GLM preprocessing used by most other methods. DynaDiff maps each time point to a latent vector and learns one weight per time point to combine them into a single weighted average. The method adds conditioning on the individual time points, while DynaDiff conditions only on their weighted average. This leads to some improvement in PixCorr and SSIM over DynaDiff.
Critical strengths
- The paper works with the fMRI time series instead of the usual GLM betas and explores better use of its temporal information, a relatively under-explored research direction.
- The paper shows some improvement in pixel correlation and SSIM over the method it builds on.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is very hard to follow. It uses complex terminology that I find unnecessary, does not add much substance and hinders clarity.
- The paper only compares against the model it builds on. This is very strange given the multiple works addressing this problem. One might argue that those works report results on averaged fMRI. However nothing prevents running inference on single-trial fMRI or asking the authors of those papers for such results.
- The generalizability of the results to other methods is questionable as the approach is very technical and tailored to DynaDiff.
- The work improves only pixel correlation and SSIM. More recent works report much better results on these metrics and take a more methodological approach to capturing the layout and structure of the images measured by these low-level metrics. The work does not compare to such works or discuss them. Additionally the capacity of diffusion guidance approaches might be limited for low-level metrics due to the nature of diffusion models.
- The paper uses "Official" to denote DynaDiff results. This is a misuse of the term. "Official" would refer to a base model released by the authors of the dataset examined.
Questions for authors
I have no further questions.