acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

LLM Content Detection and Interpretation

Abstract

In LLM-assisted writing, who develops a document's content can differ from who produces its final wording. Existing content detectors, however, can follow expression cues even when the content source remains unchanged. We study both content-source detection under changes in expression and the automatic discovery of recurring differences between human and LLM content choices across topics. To support both tasks, we decompose documents into self-contained content points and restate them in a common, plain register. Using these points as detector inputs substantially improves robustness to changes in paragraph structure and voice on HART and RAID. Across RoBERTa, RACE, and DETree, content-point inputs raise mean AUROC over 36 HART expression-change settings from 0.733 to 0.956, while avoiding the prediction reversals observed with raw-text inputs. For interpretation, we introduce content repertoire occupancy (CRO), which discovers and names recurring content choices without a predefined domain taxonomy. CRO learns a shared, overlapping repertoire of content choices without content-source labels, then compares how often human and LLM content points express each choice within matched topics. Across four writing domains, CRO identifies tens of content choices per domain, with both their population differences and descriptions supported on held-out data, revealing distinctions not made explicit in existing methods' topic words and steering descriptions. Together, these methods support a more systematic study of human–LLM content differences, combining more robust source detection across forms of expression with automatic discovery and naming of recurring content choices across topics.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
LLM, AI Detection, LLM Interpretation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_fJviOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies content-source detection under changes in expression and recurring differences between human and LLM content choices. Author propose converting documents into detailed content points restated in a neutral register, then using these as inputs to existing detectors, which show improved detection robustness to paragraph and voice changes. Meanwhile, they propose Content Repertoire Occupancy (CRO) learns overlapping content categories from topic-centered embeddings, which reveals population-level patterns that human writing more often includes concrete details, while LLM writing more often emphasizes significance and shared values.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear problem framing. The distinction between “content source” and “expression source” is insightful, and the proposed content-point strategy offers an intuitive approach to improving robustness.

  2. Thoughtful CRO design. Separately validating whether population-level differences replicate and whether category descriptions are meaningful is more convincing than simply presenting a few plausible cluster names.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The incremental contribution of content-point decomposition to detection robustness is not fully established. Appendix C.2 provides a useful comparison with detailed plain rewriting, but this ablation has a narrower scope than the main experiments. In Table 10, plain rewriting achieves nearly identical mean AUROC to content points across the 12 test-only expression-change settings (0.965 versus 0.964), suggesting that neutral restatement already recovers much of the observed robustness. Content points do reduce mean FPR (0.045 versus 0.067), although this accompanies lower TPR (0.852 versus 0.890). However, this comparison is restricted to RoBERTa on HART and does not cover training-side changes or joint train–test changes,. It therefore remains unclear how much additional detection robustness point decomposition provides over detailed neutral rewriting across the broader experimental setting.

  2. Sensitivity to the choice of content extractor remains unclear. Although the detection experiments cover multiple detectors and expression transformations, all content-point representations are produced by the same GPT-4o extractor. The results therefore leave open how sensitive the reported robustness gains are to this model’s particular content-selection and restatement behavior.

Questions for authors

See weakness.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Detailed Plain Rewriting and the Additional Benefits of Content-Point Decomposition

Thank you for recognizing the distinction between content and expression sources and the value of separately validating CRO's population differences and descriptions.

1. Detailed restatement and decomposition across the broader evaluation (new Appendix I).

Our detailed plain rewrite inherits the content-point extractor's specific design: retain every substantive claim, detail, and example while replacing distinctive expression with a common, neutral register. Both formulations were developed in this work, with instructions distinct from the prior rewriting prompts evaluated in Appendix J. Their key difference is structural: the plain rewrite retains connected prose, while the extractor decomposes the content into self-contained points.

Following your suggestion, we extend the comparison to four HART domains, all three detectors, and 36 expression-change settings covering training-only, test-only, and joint changes. The broader evaluation shows that both formulations provide strong voice robustness, while decomposition adds substantial robustness to paragraph changes.

The results below average RoBERTa, RACE, and DETree. TPR and FPR use thresholds calibrated to 5% human-content validation FPR and held fixed for the associated test evaluations.

ComparisonOur detailed plain rewritingOur content points
Mean voice-change AUROC0.9520.952
Mean paragraph-change AUROC0.7770.966
Overall mean AUROC0.8940.956
Overall mean TPR0.8590.855
Overall mean FPR0.1900.064

The benefit of decomposition is especially visible under joint paragraph changes. Reversing the paragraph–source assignment between training and testing can reverse plain-rewrite rankings, while content points retain strong discrimination. Across the broader evaluation, the reduction in mean FPR accompanies similar mean TPR, alongside improved AUROC. In Appendix I, we report the full detector-specific results across settings.

The plain rewrite's strong voice performance provides further support for the shared content-preservation and restatement design. Under the matched RoBERTa evaluation, it achieves mean voice-change AUROC of 0.956, compared with 0.858 for TruthOverTricks Summary and 0.823 for HART Simplify. We discuss these comparisons with prior prompts in our response to Reviewer wT2Z and Appendix J.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Robustness Across Content-Point Extraction Models

2. Robustness across extraction models (new Appendix K).

Strong content-source discrimination persists when different models construct the content points. We vary the extraction model while holding the extraction instruction and remaining experimental setup fixed, using the same four domains, three detectors, and 36 expression-change settings.

Extraction modelMean AUROCMean TPRMean FPR
GPT-4o0.9560.8550.064
Llama 3.3 70B Instruct0.9480.8240.069
Qwen3.8-27B0.9430.8080.065

All three extractors support strong ranking performance and similarly low false-positive rates, with some variation in recall. Appendix K presents the detector-specific setting comparisons and examples of the extracted content.

A matched video-prediction example makes the extraction behavior concrete. The source passage explains why predicting leg movement requires distinguishing walking from running. The corresponding content point from each extractor is reproduced verbatim below.

ExtractorCorresponding content point
GPT-4oFor example, predicting future leg movements requires knowing whether the partial motion corresponds to walking or running.
Llama 3.3 70B InstructFor instance, to predict the future of leg movement, it is necessary to know whether the partial leg movement belongs to walking or running.
Qwen3.8-27BPredicting future leg movement requires determining whether the observed partial movement is part of walking or running.

Each extractor retains the walking/running distinction despite differences in wording. The example illustrates preservation of the same substantive information; the broader performance comparison shows that strong detection persists across the three tested extractors.

We hope these additional results address your concerns about the role of decomposition and demonstrate the robustness of our findings across extraction models.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank You and Evaluations for Your Final Consideration

We especially appreciate your recognition of the distinction between content and expression sources, as well as CRO's careful validation of population differences and feature descriptions.

We believe our substantial additional experiments further strengthen the evidence for our content-source detection approach. Our expanded comparisons across detectors and expression-change settings demonstrate that both our detailed plain rewriting and content points achieve strong voice robustness by preserving substantive detail and neutralizing expression, while content-point decomposition provides substantial additional robustness to paragraph changes. Together, these results support our overall representation design, beyond just the performance difference between the two rewrites. Furthermore, our experiments with three different extraction models show consistently strong detection performance, supporting the robustness of our approach beyond a single extractor.

We sincerely hope this additional evidence has strengthened your assessment of our work. If you feel it has addressed your concerns, we would be very grateful if you would take these into account in your final assessment.

Thank you again for your time and consideration!

Reviewer_wT2ZOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

In LLM-assisted writing, the source of a document’s content may differ from the source of its final wording. This paper studies content-source detection under expression changes and the automatic discovery of differences between human and LLM content choices. It decomposes documents into self-contained content points and restates them in a common, plain register. On HART and RAID, this representation improves robustness to paragraph and voice changes. Across three detectors and 36 expression-change settings on HART, mean AUROC increases from 0.733 to 0.956. The paper also introduces CRO, which learns shared content features without predefined domain categories or source labels, then compares their occupancy between human and LLM content within matched topics. Across four writing domains, CRO identifies dozens of content choices per domain, with both population differences and feature descriptions supported by held-out evaluation.

Critical strengths

1.CRO is the most interesting part of the paper to me. Separating content-feature learning, population comparison, and description validation provides a useful way to study differences in what humans and LLMs choose to convey.

2.The experiments clearly show that raw-text detectors can fail substantially under the tested paragraph and voice changes. The appendix also provides several ablations and stability analyses.

Critical weaknesses

1.The novelty of plain rewriting needs further clarification. Decoupling Content and Expression: Two-Dimensional Detection of AI-Generated Text (HART) has already explored content extraction and simplified restatement. Truth over Tricks: Measuring and Mitigating Shortcut Learning in Misinformation Detection (NeurIPS 2025) also uses paraphrasing, factual summarization, and sentiment normalization to reduce detection shortcuts, although its task is misinformation detection rather than AI-text source detection. Thus, rewriting text to reduce reliance on surface cues has clear precedents. The paper should explain more clearly what plain restatement adds beyond these approaches. A direct comparison is also missing: using HART-style simplified text as input to the same detector, under the same training conditions, and comparing it with the paper’s detailed plain rewriting. The one-sentence central-claim summary is too compressed to replace this comparison.

2.The additional benefit of content-point decomposition remains unclear. In Table 10, detailed plain rewriting and content points achieve mean AUROCs of 0.965 and 0.964, respectively, across the 12 test-only expression-change settings with RoBERTa. This suggests that most of the robustness benefit in these settings can be obtained without decomposition. Appendix C.2 shows more stable false-positive rates for content points under paragraph interventions, but further experiments are needed to establish the additional value of decomposition under other conditions.

3.CRO’s generalization to new domains and generators needs further evaluation. Training separately in each domain, or learning from all domains before evaluating held-out groups, does not establish that the learned features transfer directly to a completely unseen domain. Direct tests on new domains and texts from unseen generators are still needed.

Questions for authors

Presentation Suggestions

1.Figure 2 does not label the specific settings represented by each group of four bars, requiring repeated reference to the appendix. Please add these labels directly.

2.Table 2 does not clearly show which features occur more often in human or LLM content. Please include occupancy rates or effect directions and explain how the table should be compared with Table 1.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Clarifying the Benefits of Detailed Plain Rewriting and Content-Point Extraction

Thank you for recognizing the value of CRO and our robustness experiments, and for the suggestions on comparing the input representations.

1. Content extraction's contribution and comparisons with other rewrites (new Appendix J).

Our controlled interventions show that existing approaches, including RACE, HART, and DETree, can still base content-source predictions on expression cues. Our key contribution is to demonstrate this dependence and establish a general approach to improving detection robustness: represent substantive content in a common, plain register for use with existing detectors. We do not claim novelty for rewriting itself, a common strategy in LLM research. Motivated by the prior work you highlighted, we further demonstrate that the specific rewriting instruction matters.

In Appendix J, we evaluate all three TruthOverTricks prompts (Summary, Paraphrase, and Neutral) and HART simplification alongside our content points and detailed plain rewriting under the same RoBERTa training and evaluation protocol. Both of our representations achieve higher overall mean AUROC than the tested prior prompts, with content points providing the strongest overall discrimination and lowest mean FPR.

The table reports averages over four HART domains and 36 expression-change settings, covering training-only, test-only, and joint changes. Voice and paragraph AUROCs average their respective settings; TPR and FPR average all 36 settings at thresholds calibrated to 5% human-content validation FPR. TruthOverTricks Summary is the strongest of its three tested prompts by overall mean AUROC.

Input / promptOverall mean AUROCVoice mean AUROCParagraph mean AUROCMean TPRMean FPR
Raw text0.7120.7070.7240.7500.485
HART Simplify0.8020.8230.7600.6650.203
TruthOverTricks Summary0.8630.8580.8720.7340.079
Our detailed plain rewriting0.8960.9560.7760.8640.195
Our content points0.9600.9550.9690.8670.071

Appendix J additionally compares HART simplification with RACE and DETree.

2. Content-point extraction and detailed plain rewriting (new Appendix I).

Our detailed plain rewrite inherits the content-point extractor's instructions to preserve substantive points, details, and examples while replacing distinctive phrasing, tone, and imagery with plain, neutral language. It retains connected prose. Its robustness to voice changes closely matches that of content points and exceeds that of the tested prior rewriting prompts. This result further supports the effectiveness of the shared content-preservation and restatement design, which prior work may not have needed to emphasize as strongly for its particular tasks and evaluation settings.

The two representations differ primarily in whether they retain connected prose or decompose it into content points, and the additional robustness of content points under paragraph changes reflects this structural distinction. In Appendix I, we compare the representations across training-only, test-only, and joint changes. Averaged over RoBERTa, RACE, and DETree, both representations achieve mean voice-change AUROC of 0.952. Under paragraph changes, however, mean AUROC is 0.777 for plain rewriting and 0.966 for content points.

Joint paragraph changes make the additional benefit of decomposition particularly visible. Plain rewriting can still produce reversed score rankings when the assignment of paragraph structures to content sources changes between training and testing, while content points sustain discrimination. Across the full three-detector comparison, content points also reduce mean FPR from 0.190 to 0.064 while retaining similar mean TPR, 0.855 versus 0.859 for plain rewriting.

Content-point extraction therefore combines strong robustness to voice and paragraph changes.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

CRO on Unseen Domains and Generator

3. CRO across domains and generators (new Appendix L).

In the main paper, we demonstrated CRO's applicability across writing domains. Following your suggestion, we examine how content-choice descriptions obtained from CRO learned in one domain transfer to other domains excluded from that learning, and how its learned features transfer to an unseen generator.

3a. Content-choice descriptions from one domain applied to unseen domains.

Applying fixed content-choice descriptions from a CRO repertoire learned in one domain to other, unseen domains reveals shared tendencies alongside domain-dependent associations. We learn CRO separately in news, arXiv, and creative writing, then evaluate eight descriptions from each repertoire across all three domains (24 descriptions in total). For each repertoire, the other two domains were excluded from its learning and naming. Each description's definition and diagnostic cue remain fixed when we assess its applicability to validation content points in the source and target domains.

The table identifies each description's source domain. H and LLM indicate the favored population; numbers are odds ratios. A dash denotes no estimable effect from eligible topics.

Source domainUnseen domainsContent-choice descriptionNewsarXivCreative writing
NewsarXiv, Creative writingQuantitative specificsH 4.93×H 5.55×H 3.29×
NewsarXiv, Creative writingEmphasizing importanceLLM 3.09×LLM 2.30×LLM 1.42×
NewsarXiv, Creative writingActions taken to address challengesLLM 2.35×LLM 1.15×H 1.50×
Creative writingNews, arXivA named central characterH 2.14×—LLM 2.06×
arXivNews, Creative writingFormal mathematical definitions or assumptions—H 3.96×—

The news descriptions of quantitative specificity and emphasizing importance retain their human-favored and LLM-favored associations, respectively, in the unseen domains of arXiv and creative writing. The description “a named central character,” obtained from creative writing, changes direction: it is LLM-favored in its source domain but human-favored in news. Coverage also varies: “formal mathematical definitions or assumptions,” obtained from arXiv, yields no estimable effect in either target domain, while “a named central character” yields none in arXiv. In Appendix L, we provide the complete comparison across all 24 descriptions.

3b. Learned CRO features on an unseen LLM generator.

All 16 selected news/arXiv features retain their favored population on Mistral Small 3.2 24B Instruct, an unseen generator, with CRO encoders and membership thresholds held fixed.

H/LLM identifies the favored population, followed by its occupancy odds ratio; both columns use matched validation topics.

DomainContent choiceReference generatorsMistral
NewsSpecific dates or timeframesH 6.46×H 6.27×
NewsEmphasizing importanceLLM 5.55×LLM 6.50×
arXivSpecific technical detailsH 4.68×H 5.03×
arXivProposing improvementsLLM 4.51×LLM 4.89×

The selected features reveal similar human–LLM content tendencies on Mistral. We also independently describe the transferred features using human–Mistral examples without supplying their reference names. For example, the feature originally named “specific dates or timeframes” is independently described as “temporal anchoring,” illustrating continuity in its interpretation. Appendix L reports all 16 feature comparisons and the independently produced descriptions.

4. Figure 2 setting labels.

We thank the reviewer for the suggestion. Figure 2 now labels the transformation families and training-only, test-only, and joint scopes, with a shared assignment key. Section 4.1 additionally explains the source assignments and how they produce the 36 expression-change settings.

5. Table 2 population directions and its relation to Table 1 (new Appendix M).

Both panels of Table 2 now identify the favored population and report mean feature response ratios. For example, Human 3.04× means that the feature's mean response in human content is 3.04 times that in LLM content. These ratios reflect both response frequency and magnitude; Table 1's CRO occupancy odds ratios measure within-topic membership differences. Section 5.2 explains this distinction. We add these population-response comparisons to help interpret the baseline outputs; Appendix M explains their calculation and interpretation.

For example, SAE-ATD returns “argumentative structure” (Human 9.29×) and “argument structure” (Human 5.21×), illustrating that strong population associations can accompany overlapping descriptions. As discussed in the paper, CRO first learns a shared repertoire of overlapping content choices without source labels, then compares their occupancy across populations. This design enables it to identify and name a much richer range of recurring content-choice differences that can be obscured by a focus on the strongest features separating the populations.

We hope these additional comparisons and analyses clarify the contribution of content-point extraction and the capabilities and limitations of CRO across domains and generators.

Reviewer_RnjMOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper focuses on two problems in the human-LLM writing domain. First, to identify who created the actual content of a document when its wording has been changed, and second, to understand what kinds of content humans and LLMs tend to include in their writing. For the first scenario, the authors propose converting documents into a content-point representation format, which decomposes a document into a list of self-contained claims using GPT-4o. Rather than using the raw text, they use this representation to train existing detectors. For the second part, they introduce Content Repertoire Occupancy (CRO), which uses topic-centred embeddings and sparse autoencoders to find recurring content features without using source labels during feature learning. Using three existing detectors across two benchmarks, the authors show that the proposed representations improve detection robustness, specifically in scenarios that cause raw-text detectors to reverse their predictions. They also show that CRO identifies recurring differences in human and LLM content choices across four writing domains.

Critical strengths

The paper empirically shows that content-source detectors can rely heavily on writing style and paragraph structure rather than the actual content, supporting the authors’ argument to change the input representation. Also, CRO provides an interesting approach to study human-LLM differences beyond binary classification. Learning a “shared repertoire” of content choices before comparing their inclusion rates is well motivated, as many choices can occur in both populations.

Critical weaknesses

The paper's presentation can be significantly improved. The writing is often dense, with several qualifications packed into individual sentences, making it difficult to identify the main claims.

It’s not entirely clear how generalizable the content-source differences are, and whether the observed content differences reflect true differences in human- LLM writing or how the datasets were constructed. In HART, the human documents are original texts, while the corresponding LLM documents are generated from titles or writing prompts (Appendix B.1). From Table 1, CRO’s findings in domains such as news and arXiv indicate that human writing includes more quantitative details, dates, and formal definitions, compared to LLM writing, which includes more general statements about significance. Could these differences reflect what information each writer had access to, rather than what each chose to include? Since the detectors are also trained on the same data, this could also impact detection. Differentiating between the detection and CRO results in scenarios where writers have comparable information and those where they do not would be more informative for the generalizability of the findings.

Questions for authors

NA

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Detection and CRO Extend to Settings Where LLMs Have Access to Source Material

Thank you for recognizing the value of content-source detection and CRO's shared-repertoire design.

1. Clearer explanations of the settings and findings.

We have clarified the main-text explanations of the evaluation settings and findings, with clearer figure and table guidance and references to supporting analyses (Sections 4–5; Figure 2; Table 2).

2. Content-source differences under access to source material.

LLMs are flexible foundation models that adapt their writing, including their content choices, to the instructions and context they receive. In the main paper, under established benchmark settings, we demonstrated improved detection robustness on HART and RAID and used CRO to discover and name recurring content choices across domains.

Your comment raises an important question about how access to source material changes these content choices and human–LLM differences. We examine it using the same detection approach and CRO framework, demonstrating how their general design allows direct application to this additional setting.

In news and arXiv, we compare two source-access conditions: providing the full human text or an information packet extracted from it. In both, the LLM chooses how to develop and organize its writing from the supplied material.

2a. Detection (new Appendix G).

Our content-point detectors continue to distinguish human from LLM content even when LLMs receive additional source material. We conduct two detailed experiments: LLMs receive either the original full human text or an information packet extracted from it as source material. The two cases yield mean AUROCs of 0.844 and 0.877, respectively, showing strong separability between the two classes. We note that both are lower than 0.966 under title/prompt-only generation, which is expected because the LLM can draw directly on information selected by the human writer while still developing its own writing. Our additional CRO experiment, discussed in the next point, examines which human–LLM content-choice differences are reduced and which remain.

Between the two source-access conditions, providing the full human text leads to lower detectability than providing an information packet. This is consistent with packets leaving more of the writing’s development and organization to the model. Importantly, in both conditions, our content-point detectors achieve higher mean AUROC than raw-text detectors in every domain–detector comparison.

We evaluate these conditions across three detectors and 36 expression-change settings covering training-only, test-only, and joint changes in Appendix G. The table reports AUROC averaged over these settings; “points” denotes our content-point inputs. The final row averages the six domain–detector pairs.

DomainDetectorTitle/prompt: rawTitle/prompt: pointsFull text: rawFull text: pointsPacket: rawPacket: points
NewsRoBERTa0.7080.9570.6380.8310.6920.865
NewsRACE0.6870.9500.6350.8120.6690.852
NewsDETree0.7970.9670.7300.8480.7490.876
arXivRoBERTa0.7210.9770.6730.8670.7090.894
arXivRACE0.6880.9710.6490.8460.6740.881
arXivDETree0.7990.9750.7560.8590.7730.892
Average0.7330.9660.6800.8440.7110.877

2b. Interpretation with CRO (new Appendix H).

With CRO, we show that access to human source material brings LLM content choices closer to those of human writers, while substantial differences still remain. Quantitative, temporal, and technical details remain human-favored, while emphasizing importance and proposing improvements remain LLM-favored. Full-text access generally brings these choices into closer alignment than packet access.

In Appendix H, we further analyze the content choices observed under full-text and information-packet access, including choices identified and named independently within each condition. Selected examples below report within-topic occupancy odds ratios favoring the indicated population; the title/prompt reference reports discovery estimates.

DomainContent choiceFavored populationTitle/prompt reference (discovery)Full textPacket
NewsQuantitative ratios or metricsHuman4.49×2.17×2.88×
NewsSpecific dates or timeframesHuman4.09×2.49×3.01×
NewsEmphasizing importanceLLM7.02×4.70×4.87×
NewsEnvironmental sustainabilityLLM5.33×2.76×3.98×
arXivSpecific technical detailsHuman5.32×2.08×2.65×
arXivFormal mathematical definitions or assumptionsHuman4.92×2.60×2.87×
arXivDynamic adaptationLLM5.30×2.48×3.44×
arXivProposing improvementsLLM3.81×3.03×3.67×

The detection and CRO findings both indicate that the form of the supplied information matters. This pattern is consistent with the full text providing both substantive information and potential cues for developing it into a complete piece, while packets leave more of that development to the model.

Beyond these reference-feature comparisons, we also learn CRO repertoires within each source-access condition in Appendix H, identifying recurring differences in attribution, technical detail, and broader significance.

Your question also connects to the broader issue of how human–LLM content differences vary across writing conditions. In our response to Reviewer wT2Z, we explore this further by applying our framework across domains and to an unseen LLM generator.

We hope these clarifications and additional experiments address your concerns and clarify our findings on human–LLM content differences, including when LLMs have access to source material.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank You and Findings for Your Final Consideration

We would like to thank you for your recognition of the expression-related shortcuts in existing content-source detectors and the value of CRO's shared-repertoire approach to studying human–LLM content differences.

Motivated by your question, we investigated both detection and CRO when LLMs receive source material, through either full human texts or information packets. Although access to source material narrows human–LLM content differences, substantial differences remain. Our content-point detectors continue to distinguish human from LLM content and substantially outperform raw-text inputs, while CRO systematically reveals which content-choice differences persist and how their magnitudes change across these settings. We believe these findings further demonstrate the value and generalizability of both approaches.

We hope these new analyses help clarify the role of source information in both detection and content interpretation. We would greatly appreciate it if you could reconsider your assessment in light of these additional findings.

Thank you again for raising this important question, which helped us strengthen our evaluation and provide further evidence for the generalizability of both methods!

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Clarifying the Scope of Our Contributions and Supporting Evidence

We sincerely thank all reviewers and the Area Chair for their time, effort, and consideration of our work. As the author response period concludes, we would like to clarify the scope of our scientific contributions and how our evaluations across a wide range of settings establish their value. For CRO, developing a general analytical framework for studying human–LLM content differences does not require every identified difference to persist across all settings. For content-source detection, our detailed plain rewriting shares key elements of our own content-point extraction design; our contribution is not limited to the differences between our detailed plain rewriting and content point extraction. We hope this perspective helps place our detailed responses in context.

1. Data characteristics and the generalizability of CRO:

We demonstrate the generalizability of CRO as an analytical framework: without domain-specific categorizations, the same CRO framework can discover and name rich sets of recurring content choices and measure their human–LLM differences across diverse domains, separately or pooled. We demonstrated this across four distinct domains; our rebuttal further uses CRO to examine which content-choice tendencies persist or change across domains and when using an unseen generator (Reviewer wT2Z), and how these differences change when LLMs have access to additional source material (Reviewer RnjM).

The reviewers’ comments raise natural extensions of the generalizability challenge addressed in our original submission: when the domain, generator, or available source information changes, which differences persist, and which change? The generalizability of CRO enabled us to investigate these questions directly. Indeed, our results reveal both domain-specific differences and recurring cross-domain tendencies in human–LLM content choices. Our contribution is a general analytical framework for systematically investigating content-choice differences and their variation, and we have documented these differences empirically across a wide range of settings.

2. Content-source detection, content-point extraction, and LLM rewriting:

For content-source detection, our central contribution is to identify and address a key challenge: existing detectors intended for content-source detection can depend heavily on expression cues, even reversing their predictions under changes in voice or paragraph structure. Our content-point extraction design has three important objectives to tackle this challenge: preserving substantive detail, neutralizing expression, and decomposing content into points. Our experiments demonstrate that these design choices matter substantially for content-source detection; we do not claim novelty for rewriting itself.

Our central-claim summarization approach yielded lower content-source discrimination performance. Both our content-point extraction and detailed plain rewriting achieve higher AUROC under voice changes than the HART Simplify and TruthOverTricks prompts, demonstrating that the choice of content representation matters for content-source detection. Our detailed plain rewriting shares goals with content-point extraction: it preserves substantive detail and neutralizes expression, but does not decompose content into points. Across a wide range of voice changes, their similarly strong performance supports the detail-preserving, expression-neutralizing design, while content-point extraction’s substantial advantage under paragraph changes demonstrates the additional benefit of decomposing content into points (Reviewers wT2Z and fJvi). Together, these comparisons support our combined design rationale: preserving substantive detail, neutralizing expression, and decomposing content into points.

We thank the reviewers for their thoughtful feedback and for recognizing both the challenge of robust content-source detection and CRO’s approach to overlapping human–LLM content choices. We hope the original submission and rebuttal together clarify our contributions and the evidence supporting them.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.