- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper challenges the conventional evaluation of exposure correction methods, which primarily measures fidelity to a designated ground-truth image using metrics such as PSNR and SSIM. The authors argue that a mis-exposed input may preserve reliable scene details that are absent from the ground truth, meaning that greater numerical similarity does not necessarily indicate better perceptual quality.
Critical strengths
This paper identifies an important issue with existing exposure correction methods and proposes an approach to address it.
The authors have constructed a dataset, which required a considerable amount of effort.
The paper is well written and shows no obvious signs of AI-generated content.
Critical weaknesses
The authors appear to have conflated several concepts. Suppose that the dependent variable represents image quality, while the independent variables represent image attributes, such as exposure, color temperature, artifacts, and so on. Existing work on exposure correction can be divided into two settings:
- Improving by modifying only one component of , namely exposure, as in the SICE [1] dataset and UEC [2].
- For images degraded in terms of exposure, improving by modifying multiple components of , as in the MSEC dataset.
[1] Learning a Deep Single Image Contrast Enhancer from Multi-Exposure Images
[2] Unsupervised Exposure Correction
Your assessment framework seems to alternate between these two settings. First, you state that models trained on MSEC are used as candidates, which suggests that your work follows the second setting. Later, however, you construct the qMap based on MEF, which is more aligned with the first setting. Why are the other components of ignored at this stage? Furthermore, the first setting has already been investigated in prior work, such as P-IEANet [3] and IEMx [4].
[3] Rethinking No-reference Image Exposure Assessment from Holism to Pixel: Models, Datasets and Benchmarks
[4] Towards Automatic Image Exposure Level Assessment
In image enhancement, it may not be necessary to draw a strict distinction between these two settings, because enhancement models can potentially be applied across both. However, your work focuses on assessment, for which such ambiguity is problematic, since the problem formulation itself constitutes part of the contribution.
You also acknowledge that the variables considered in your work differ from those used in general-purpose IQA. This raises a fundamental question: What exactly does include in your formulation? This point is not clearly explained in the current manuscript. In contrast, [3] provides an explicit definition of the problem: it determines the image attributes to be assessed based on Adams' Zone System theory and subsequently develops corresponding scoring criteria.
Questions for authors
What exactly does include in your formulation?(Please see Critical Weaknesses for details)