- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SHE-Net for ultrasound standard plane recognition. The method consists of two main components: (1) Hierarchical Vision-Language Alignment (HVLA), which aligns visual features at different network stages with local, relational, and plane-level anatomical text semantics; and (2) Semantic-Routed Anatomical Experts (SRAE), which uses semantic supervision to guide routing among local, relational, and recognition experts. Textual information is only required during training. The paper also introduces a new kidney ultrasound dataset, KU2026, containing 3,716 images. Experiments on FPUS23, LP2025, and KU2026 report consistent improvements over the selected baselines, with additional ablations and Grad-CAM visualizations.
Critical strengths
-
The local/relational/plane-level semantic hierarchy is reasonably aligned with the clinical reasoning process, and using textual supervision only during training avoids additional inference-time requirements.
-
The method is evaluated on fetal, liver, and kidney ultrasound datasets, and consistently improves over the reported baselines. The newly collected KU2026 dataset also broadens evaluation beyond commonly studied fetal ultrasound settings.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper does not clearly report the train/validation/test splits, the number of patients/examinations, or whether samples from the same patient or acquisition sequence are strictly separated across splits. This is consequential because image-level leakage could substantially inflate performance in ultrasound datasets.
-
In particular, the related work cites SEMC, a recent mixture-of-experts contrastive method specifically developed for ultrasound standard plane recognition, but it is absent from the main quantitative comparison. Instead, several compared methods originate from more general long-tailed recognition, segmentation, few-shot learning, or other medical imaging tasks. This makes it difficult to determine whether the reported gains represent a meaningful advance over the most directly relevant prior work.
A related reproducibility issue is that Align(·) is introduced only abstractly as a “prototype-based visual-semantic alignment objective,” while the semantic scores used to supervise expert routing are also not explicitly defined.
Questions for authors
-
What are the exact train/validation/test splitting protocols for FPUS23, LP2025, and KU2026? In particular, are the splits patient-/examination-/video-level, and can frames or images from the same subject appear in both training and test sets?
-
Please provide the exact mathematical definition of
Align(·)and of the semantic consistency scores . What text encoder, semantic prototypes, EMA momentum , and routing temperature are used? -
Why is SEMC (Cai et al., 2026), which is highly relevant as a mixture-of-experts method for ultrasound standard plane recognition, not included in the quantitative comparison? A comparison under the same data split and training protocol would materially affect my assessment.
-
Are the reported results from a single run or averaged over multiple random seeds? Given that several improvements over the strongest baselines are below one percentage point, standard deviations or statistical significance would be helpful.