- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper considers the problem of distribution matching on multiple distributions based on some distance measure. This is done so by learning a barycenter, then using Taylor approximation to learn the residual terms. The correction terms are iteratively learned, with the weights updated so that it is within a defined trust region.
Critical strengths
- Based on what I understand, the claims in the paper seems to be sound. The method as provided seems to make sense, and there is quite a bit of theoretical evidence as to why the method works (although I did not verify them closely).
Critical weaknesses
- Given that I am not familiar with the topic of the paper, I do find the paper to be a bit difficult to follow. Given the current structure, I do find it a bit unclear as to see in full how the components would fit into an overall framework without very careful reading/inferring. The results shown is unclear in what the benchmarks being compared against are or what their significances are, what the results themselves show, and whether there are any ablations on the components being introduced in the methods. I acknowledge that this may also be because I am unfamiliar with the topic of the paper, and so would also be understandable if this is the norm for the papers in the sub-area, but the work is quite hard to follow if read by a more general audience.
Questions for authors
Mainly for clarification of some of the contents in the paper, particularly the empirical results. As to why the experiments chosen are designed as such, and what their main findings are (as they are still somewhat unclear for me).