- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The author try to reduce the out of distribution sample of one step generative modeling. They do so by training the generator to map the sample closed to the "correct sample." The define the correct sample as the original sample x + d, where d is defined as the Jacobian of a pretrained vision encoder like DINO, and some sort of latent signal. The main contribution of this paper is that the author propose this "correction signal" should be normalized, and doing so slightly improve the model's generation quality, measured in FID.
Critical strengths
The author show some ablation study that normalizing the "correction signal" during this Feature guided drifting post-training is necessary, in a sense it improve FID a little bit.
Critical weaknesses
The main weakness is the writing. I think this paper is a AI generated report. I spend lots of time try to understand the paper, but still got confused with the notation and still could not quite understand the main method figure (Figure 1) and the method section. I think the author need to improve the writing. For example, the author use the word "Feature guided drifting" in their abstract to describe this post-training correction method they use. But I think this is a new term, and the author never describe it or explain the connection to author literature. In the related literature section, the author simply cite a bunch of literature but did not explain the connection to their works.
Overall, it's extremely tiring for reader to understand this paper, and I recommend the rejection of this paper solely for this reason. I strongly recommend the author to rewrite the paper without AI. I don't think rebuttal will change my assessment.
Questions for authors
N/A